MLB 10: The Show PS3 Officially Exclusive To the PS3 (NOT MLB 09!)

now that mlb the show 10 is in there they should go back and change the status of 09 because that should be exclusive as well.

drakecool1

Well is GRAW counted as exclusive then? Because the same logic applies.walkingdream

Thats the point :P

He's using the Graw review as a precedent.

Sad for SW.

Just shows how many Cows there are here, where they brought up this topic enough times to make a mod give up :| +1toPS3fanboys

It just further highlights the stupidity of SW, when people argue over these differences for so long and a games like NG2/Sigma2 are not considered exclusive - just like that. I am speechless. Of course we know why the fanboys don't bicker over NG2/Sigma2: because it wouldn't make a difference between the platforms - not anymore anyway. When it first came out I guess it meant 360 lost an exclusive +1toPS3fanboys.

We should keep it consistant and not give leeway to fanboys.

A game like ME1 also won't be considered exclusive, despite the differences between the 2 platforms. +1toPS3fanboys

To summarise:
ME1 - not exclusive
NG2/Sigma 2 - not exclusive
MLB 10 - somehow exclusive

What's the difference? One is Sony exclusive.

What's the similarity? All benefit PS3 fanboys on SW.

Seriously does anybody truly care about the game or only the exclusivity of it?

Wasdie

I do, day one buy.

[QUOTE="Rza_rectah"]

wow, whothought logic would previal in here of all places?

NVIDIATI

to Casey's credit... this is all he has asked for the past year.....someone just finally put together a list for him.....so in the end, it's actually our fault for not creating this list sooner.

these "E" lists are all fun and games for SW...but at the end of the day its the owners of PS3 who will be enjoying one of the best sports series ever....just as 360 owners had the luxury of GRAW

*I used to be sooo jealous* shhh

someone find me that old GRAW gif of that building exploding :)

[QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]

Sad for SW.

Just shows how many Cows there are here, where they brought up this topic enough times to make a mod give up :| +1toPS3fanboys

It just further highlights the stupidity of SW, when people argue over these differences for so long and a games like NG2/Sigma2 are not considered exclusive - just like that. I am speechless. Of course we know why the fanboys don't bicker over NG2/Sigma2: because it wouldn't make a difference between the platforms - not anymore anyway. When it first came out I guess it meant 360 lost an exclusive +1toPS3fanboys.

We should keep it consistant and not give leeway to fanboys.

A game like ME1 also won't be considered exclusive, despite the differences between the 2 platforms. +1toPS3fanboys

To summarise:
ME1 - not exclusive
NG2/Sigma 2 - not exclusive
MLB 10 - somehow exclusive

What's the difference? One is Sony exclusive.

What's the similarity? All benefit PS3 fanboys on SW.

NVIDIATI

I have seen Mass Effect debated by PC gamers before, and listed a link to an article I found using Google. I guess it was more important that 360 lost an exclusive again, despite their differences.

I vote that MLB stays multiplat, and that we keep SW consistent.

Now, in all seriousness and all fanboyism aside; if MLB 10 The show is exclusive, then this should be exclusive also

Im not trying to be a fanboy or anything, seriously, if SW is fair then it should be, Im not maing a list (Maybe someone will) but it should be if The show is a PS3 exclusive.

[QUOTE="opex07"]

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] Why? its already been approved.NVIDIATI

Because Gamespot copied and pasted the same Fact sheet article to their preview of the PS2 version of the game.

I really wonder how many here bragging about the game are actually going to play it.

SpinoRaptor24

I dont brag about it but I will have it day 1

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"][QUOTE="opex07"]

Because Gamespot copied and pasted the same Fact sheet article to their preview of the PS2 version of the game.

opex07

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"][QUOTE="SaltyMeatballs"]

Sad for SW.

Just shows how many Cows there are here, where they brought up this topic enough times to make a mod give up :| +1toPS3fanboys

It just further highlights the stupidity of SW, when people argue over these differences for so long and a games like NG2/Sigma2 are not considered exclusive - just like that. I am speechless. Of course we know why the fanboys don't bicker over NG2/Sigma2: because it wouldn't make a difference between the platforms - not anymore anyway. When it first came out I guess it meant 360 lost an exclusive +1toPS3fanboys.

We should keep it consistant and not give leeway to fanboys.

A game like ME1 also won't be considered exclusive, despite the differences between the 2 platforms. +1toPS3fanboys

To summarise:
ME1 - not exclusive
NG2/Sigma 2 - not exclusive
MLB 10 - somehow exclusive

What's the difference? One is Sony exclusive.

What's the similarity? All benefit PS3 fanboys on SW.

SaltyMeatballs

I have seen Mass Effect debated by PC gamers before, and listed a link to an article I found using Google. I guess it was more important that 360 lost an exclusive again, despite their differences.

I vote that MLB stays multiplat, and that we keep SW consistent.

Ninja Gaiden 2 should be 360 exclusive and Sigma PS3 exclusive IMO. But Mass Effect is exact same game dispite controller and some technical glitches.

Well I hate baseball so I don't care either way.

[QUOTE="SpinoRaptor24"]

I really wonder how many here bragging about the game are actually going to play it.

DanteSuikoden

I dont brag about it but I will have it day 1

I'm not going to play it. But sustem wars is all about exclusives and AA and AAA games so it is fun to talk about. We need a little controversy around here.

*facepalm* Honestly I'm not here to argue this with you, just look at the 1st post and read it and you'll understand what the PS3 version has over the PS2 and PSP versions.

NVIDIATI

Have you not seen the actual fact sheet, or are you just relying on this guys post? notice that all of the features under the core franchise features are not exclusive to the PS3 which is the core of the game.

@ Everyone complaining about Ninja Gaiden, Mass Effect, Tiger Woods PGA, etc. If you believe there is a big enough difference to make the 2 games different make a list and submit it to the people in control of the list. If you carry enoughvalid points then you will have a case on your hands. Until then deal with the fact this game is now an exclusive.

We need a little controversy around here.

15strong

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] *facepalm* Honestly I'm not here to argue this with you, just look at the 1st post and read it and you'll understand what the PS3 version has over the PS2 and PSP versions.

opex07

Have you not seen the actual fact sheet, or are you just relying on this guys post?

• Custom Music, Fan Yells, and Chants – New to The Show this year, users can now assign music or a recording to an entire team, not just a player. Edit tracks to assign batter walk-up music or record your own voice and assign it to play for the team or player during the situation of your choice.
• Weekly Live Roster – An updated live roster will be available every week throughout the entire season. Included in the update will be all roster changes, addition of new MLB players (with correct attributes), and player attribute updates to reflect hot and cold streaks.

You know it's funny. The GRAW debate actually showed differences from PC and 360, yet when reading the reasons for ps3, they didn't state the differences between platform versions, just the differences from 09 to 10. But as usual, whiny cows get their way otherwise their tears would flood this place. :roll:DeadMagazines

You know it's funny. The GRAW debate actually showed differences from PC and 360, yet when reading the reasons for ps3, they didn't state the differences between platform versions, just the differences from 09 to 10. But as usual, whiny cows get their way otherwise their tears would flood this place. :roll:DeadMagazines

shinrabanshou made a list of all the differences and Casey approved it. If you are willing to make a valid list of the differences for Ninja Gaiden or Mass Effect then be my guest but until then this is what we have to deal with. NVIDIATI

I just formatted it into an easy to follow structure, so that people could look at the information and determine the game's status.

If it's been approved though that's cool, in the big picture it doesn't make the game any better having an E alongside it.

-----

Also regarding MLB 09, there's a similar list for that game and it doesn't seem the differences are substantive enough yet in that game. Although they seem to have been built on even further in 10 - making differences quite tangible. This is all imo of course.

@ Everyone complaining about Ninja Gaiden, Mass Effect, Tiger Woods PGA, etc. If you believe there is a big enough difference to make the 2 games different make a list and submit it to the people in control of the list. If you carry enoughvalid points then you will have a case on your hands. Until then deal with the fact this game is now an exclusive.

NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="15strong"]We need a little controversy around here.

DanteSuikoden

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

[QUOTE="15strong"]We need a little controversy around here.

DanteSuikoden

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

Seriously does anybody truly care about the game or only the exclusivity of it?

Wasdie

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"] *facepalm* Honestly I'm not here to argue this with you, just look at the 1st post and read it and you'll understand what the PS3 version has over the PS2 and PSP versions.

opex07

Have you not seen the actual fact sheet, or are you just relying on this guys post? notice that all of the features under the core franchise features are not exclusive to the PS3 which are the majority of changes being made this year.

But new features in successive entries deem and differentiate them as a new different game.

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"]

@ Everyone complaining about Ninja Gaiden, Mass Effect, Tiger Woods PGA, etc. If you believe there is a big enough difference to make the 2 games different make a list and submit it to the people in control of the list. If you carry enoughvalid points then you will have a case on your hands. Until then deal with the fact this game is now an exclusive.

SaltyMeatballs

I vote that MLB stays multiplat, and that we keep SW consistent.

SaltyMeatballs

who cares if its exclusive. The point of the matter is the MLB series has always been an exceptional game and the past two years has been the best sports game out on the market...If you dont like baseball thats one thing, but to deny that is an exceptional simulation of the sport is just wrong

[QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]

[QUOTE="15strong"]We need a little controversy around here.

lawlessx

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

I thought it was being hyped AAE to begin with? There hasn't been a sports title this gen on GS that's gotten back to back AAA scores. Just saying.

Only the exclusivity of it... I've never played the game but from what I've seen and heard it looks like a darn good baseball game.. However the freaking thing is out on 3 systems. And fanboys are fighting to say it's exclusive.. Weren't cow's (and Hermits) shouting from mount Olympus that if a game is available on another system IT'S NOT EXCLUSIVE.. what happened? OhSnapitz

The GRAW debate, different enough to be exclusive.

Me personally am on the fence on the whole debate I mean multiplat means on multiple platforms but the good version is exclusive to ps3.....if this is exclusive 360 should earn bayonetta as an AAAEseeing how Cows can get away with it

[QUOTE="Modern_Unit"]

Wait, then why do i see this listed:

MLB 10: The Show

• Playstation 3
• Playstation 2
• Playstation Portable

I thought it was exclusive to the ps3?

NVIDIATI

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

W1NGMAN-

I thought it was being hyped AAE to begin with? There hasn't been a sports title this gen on GS that's gotten back to back AAA scores. Just saying.

[QUOTE="OhSnapitz"] Only the exclusivity of it... I've never played the game but from what I've seen and heard it looks like a darn good baseball game.. However the freaking thing is out on 3 systems. And fanboys are fighting to say it's exclusive.. Weren't cow's (and Hermits) shouting from mount Olympus that if a game is available on another system IT'S NOT EXCLUSIVE.. what happened? DanteSuikoden

The GRAW debate, different enough to be exclusive.

Me personally am on the fence on the whole debate I mean multiplat means on multiple platforms but the good version is exclusive to ps3.....if this is exclusive 360 should earn bayonetta as an AAAEseeing how Cows can get away with it

You know it's funny. The GRAW debate actually showed differences from PC and 360, yet when reading the reasons for ps3, they didn't state the differences between platform versions, just the differences from 09 to 10. But as usual, whiny cows get their way otherwise their tears would flood this place. :roll:DeadMagazines

[QUOTE="lawlessx"][QUOTE="DanteSuikoden"]

I know, thats why a tiny part of me wants it to get 8.5 for the ownage:P

W1NGMAN-

I thought it was being hyped AAE to begin with? There hasn't been a sports title this gen on GS that's gotten back to back AAA scores. Just saying.

Oh, **** I need to read more!! I thought this was for MLB 09.So since MLB 10 has been accepted into exclusivity, what about MLB 09? And why in the **** are people making a push for this to be exclusive before we even got a score for it? I swear the more time I spend here, the less I understand the logic here.

Has any one in this thread actually played any of the past iterations of the game?

LMAO if the game doesnt get AAA. all this arguement for a AA baseball game that i bet the cows them selves dont even care about....lol cows becoming desperate

[QUOTE="Wasdie"]

Seriously does anybody truly care about the game or only the exclusivity of it?

OhSnapitz

Oh, **** I need to read more!! I thought this was for MLB 09.So since MLB 10 has been accepted into exclusivity, what about MLB 09? And why in the **** are people making a push for this to be exclusive before we even got a score for it? I swear the more time I spend here, the less I understand the logic here.

bez2083

:P SW is a strange place...

Has any one in this thread actually played any of the past iterations of the game?

BlancoBX

I will probably get MLB 10 at some point, but March is already too packed.

Oh well. At least I call that we no longer have to recognize the PC aguements too. Win Win

[QUOTE="NVIDIATI"][QUOTE="Modern_Unit"]

Wait, then why do i see this listed:

MLB 10: The Show

• Playstation 3
• Playstation 2
• Playstation Portable

I thought it was exclusive to the ps3?

Phazevariance

Yes! There is justice in the world. the lems might have won the battle with MLB 09 but cows finally win the war! now only if MLB 10 scores AAAE, heck even if it scores AAE that would be another AAE to chalk up for the PS3..

Seriously does anybody truly care about the game or only the exclusivity of it?

Wasdie

I care about the game. It was definitely one of my reasons for purchasing a ps3. I see what you're saying though since many people here probably care more about the "E" than anything else. I also believe it's a pretty pointless argument as it should've been exclusive from the get go, but usually common sense isn't found in fanboys.:P

Oh well. At least I call that we no longer have to recognize the PC aguements too. Win Win

vaderhater

I get this feeling most people don't realise this if for MLB 10: The show (unreleased /no review) and not MLB 09: The show (released / 9.0 GS).

Yes! There is justice in the world. the lems might have won the battle with MLB 09 but cows finally win the war! now only if MLB 10 scores AAAE, heck even if it scores AAE that would be another AAE to chalk up for the PS3..

Kennysolidsnake

Wow, a SW issue solved with a well-thought out argument. I am impressed. Now hopefully people will shut the **** up about it.

bez2083

So much win here. :lol:

It'll be really ironic if MLB 10 ends up a AAe for all this effort.