More Overrated, Uncharted 2 vs. Mass Effect 2?

Well I voted for mass Effect because I like uncharted more, but the real answer is NEITHER. They are both two of the best games I've ever played and deserve their scores. Imo.

Mass Effect 2 is criticized pretty widely for it's flaws. Uncharted 2 isn't, unanimous praise in a sea of hyperbole for game that isn't that remarkable. AAllxxjjnn

Oh, dear God, someone pinch me I must be dreaming. Someone else in this thread isn't blinded by the hype. :shock:DarkLink77

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]Oh, dear God, someone pinch me I must be dreaming. Someone else in this thread isn't blinded by the hype. :shock:Heil68

If these two games are overrated, what other games deserve the scores and praises these two garnered? Seriously, this overrated thing is getting old. I like constructive posts. If you think these two games are overrated then provide the name of games that should be in their place.

jun_aka_pekto

I'm sure they are both rated at exactly where they need to be.

[QUOTE="Heil68"][QUOTE="DarkLink77"]Oh, dear God, someone pinch me I must be dreaming. Someone else in this thread isn't blinded by the hype. :shock:DarkLink77

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="Heil68"] I can think of any other overrated game though. ;)Heil68

God, having no sense of wonder must suck.

[QUOTE="Heil68"][QUOTE="DarkLink77"] Eh, depends on the Halo. CE? No chance. As for SMG... not seeing it. 3D platforming perfection, friend.DarkLink77

God, having no sense of wonder must suck.

these "overrated" threads are ridiculous, if a game is famous and praised is for something, doesnt matter if the same people who doesnt like anything say its not that good or if its overrated.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

[QUOTE="Heil68"] SMG-i got bored after like 20 stars, uninspired and I couldn't finish it. Halo has gone down hill after Halo3 and CE is a quick cash in. Heil68

God, having no sense of wonder must suck.

1. Reach was a good game, and better than Halo 3 in a lot of ways. 2. I'm sorry that disturbs you. Perhaps you should see someone about your fear of fat Italian men dressed up as bees.DarkLink77

Reach was a good game in comparison with Halo 3. In reality it was just another generic space marine in a boring game :P

Anyway ME2 is highly overrated. It's almost at GTA4/RDR levels of massively overrated.

2) I did see someone about Mario dressing up as a bee but when I told him about the penguin outfit he told me I was 100% right and should immediately stop playing and cut my losses. Nobody should have to play through that nonsense. Heil68

So because of the somewhat silly suits, the game is bad?

Worse than Mass Effect 2? A game with not only terrible shooter elements, but with even worse roleplaying elements, and dont even get me started on the plot or planet scanning.

[QUOTE="Heil68"][QUOTE="DarkLink77"] 2) I did see someone about Mario dressing up as a bee but when I told him about the penguin outfit he told me I was 100% right and should immediately stop playing and cut my losses. Nobody should have to play through that nonsense. Maroxad

So because of the somewhat silly suits, the game is bad?

Worse than Mass Effect 2? A game with not only terrible shooter elements, but with even worse roleplaying elements, and dont even get me started on the plot or planet scanning.

Ah yes, "Over-rated." We have dismissed such claims

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]1. Reach was a good game, and better than Halo 3 in a lot of ways. 2. I'm sorry that disturbs you. Perhaps you should see someone about your fear of fat Italian men dressed up as bees.ChubbyGuy40

Reach was a good game in comparison with Halo 3. In reality it was just another generic space marine in a boring game :P

Anyway ME2 is highly overrated. It's almost at GTA4/RDR levels of massively overrated.

Ah yes, "Over-rated." We have dismissed such claims

skinny_man_69

Uncharted 2 and it's no contest really. ME 2 is certainly overrated (especially when the first game, which is actually better in some ways, didn't get the praise it deserved) but atleast it was a unique experience. Uncharted 2 is just like a glorofied version of Tomb Raider, or a video game version of Indiana Jones except you would have to replace Harrison Ford with Matthew McConaughey (sp?) and give him dark hair.

Coming from someone who likes generic war games like Battlefield that's f***ing hilarious. :lol:

DarkLink77

Generic war games? bro BF is THE war game. that's because it's the only game that has a MP that actually feels like a war. (Besides ArmA 2 of course.)

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]

Coming from someone who likes generic war games like Battlefield that's f***ing hilarious. :lol:

ChubbyGuy40

Generic war games? bro BF is THE war game. that's because it's the only game that has a MP that actually feels like a war. (Besides ArmA 2 of course.)

[QUOTE="skinny_man_69"]

Ah yes, "Over-rated." We have dismissed such claims

DarkLink77

If they keep releasing games like Mass Effect 2?

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="skinny_man_69"]

Ah yes, "Over-rated." We have dismissed such claims

skinny_man_69

If they keep releasing games like Mass Effect 2?

[QUOTE="Heil68"][QUOTE="DarkLink77"] 1. Reach was a good game, and better than Halo 3 in a lot of ways. 2. I'm sorry that disturbs you. Perhaps you should see someone about your fear of fat Italian men dressed up as bees.DarkLink77

Nice observation, NSMBW had a penguin suit, not any of the galaxies.

I am sure we both know that both Halo and SMG are leagues ahead of ME 2, which is one of the worst "RPGs" (if not the worst) I have ever played.

[QUOTE="skinny_man_69"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"] Tell me, skinny, how does it feel to be owned by EA, body and soul? :PDarkLink77

If they keep releasing games like Mass Effect 2?

This coming from someone with Duke Nukem Forever in his sig......

[spoiler] Sorry, I had to :P [/spoiler]

I haven't played Uncharted 2 so I vote for Mass Effect 2 by default based purely on the fact that it's a dumb game that earned way too much praise for trying to be a third person Call of Duty with dialogue decisions.

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]1. Reach was a good game, and better than Halo 3 in a lot of ways. 2. I'm sorry that disturbs you. Perhaps you should see someone about your fear of fat Italian men dressed up as bees.ChubbyGuy40

Reach was a good game in comparison with Halo 3. In reality it was just another generic space marine in a boring game :P

Anyway ME2 is highly overrated. It's almost at GTA4/RDR levels of massively overrated.

I think both of those games are fantastic and not overrated at all.

WHAT!!! GENERIC SPACE MARINE!?! GOOD SIR I CANT JUST SIT HERE AND READ THIS GOOD DAY AS I GO PLAY MY GAME I LOVE INSTEAD OF BASHING OTHERS IN DEFENDENCE!!!!!!!!worknow222

Halo is generic and boring. Pewpew...pewpewpewpew....boorrrrring. :P

PS - Edit your post and take off all the caps. You can get modded for disruptive posting for posting in all caps.

[QUOTE="worknow222"] WHAT!!! GENERIC SPACE MARINE!?! GOOD SIR I CANT JUST SIT HERE AND READ THIS GOOD DAY AS I GO PLAY MY GAME I LOVE INSTEAD OF BASHING OTHERS IN DEFENDENCE!!!!!!!!ChubbyGuy40

Halo is generic and boring. Pewpew...pewpewpewpew....boorrrrring. :P

PS - Edit your post and take off all the caps. You can get modded for disruptive posting for posting in all caps.

I think you missed the point of my "Battlefield is generic" thing. :PDarkLink77

Battlefield 2142 broski. What now? :P

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]I think you missed the point of my "Battlefield is generic" thing. :PChubbyGuy40

Battlefield 2142 broski. What now? :P

Both are fantastic games and deserve their scores.

[QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"]I think you missed the point of my "Battlefield is generic" thing. :PDarkLink77

Battlefield 2142 broski. What now? :P

I had nothing else to add beyond that point. :)

[QUOTE="DarkLink77"][QUOTE="ChubbyGuy40"]

Battlefield 2142 broski. What now? :P

ChubbyGuy40

I had nothing else to add beyond that point. :)

Didn't vote because none was overrated:roll:

I haven't played Uncharted 2 so I vote for Mass Effect 2 by default based purely on the fact that it's a dumb game that earned way too much praise for trying to be a third person Call of Duty with dialogue decisions.

NeonNinja

Fine, you enjoy your generic military shooter and I'll enjoy my generic space marine shooter. AND WE'LL SEE WHO HAS MORE FUN! :PDarkLink77

I play on PC so I obviously have more fun by default

[spoiler] [/spoiler]

I don't think either is overrated. ME2 was a phenominal game as was Uncharted 2. I believe they are at the same level.

How about neither.....More hated would make a better poll.

The only possible way to overrate Mass Effect 2 is call it the definitive best game of all time. Not that the statement can't be made, it can, but ME2 is not that perfect. It's just mostly perfect.