Most inexplicably overrated score on GS this gen?

Over rated -Braid and most of the other 360 exclusives

Under rated-Wipe out HD,LBP,Resistance and most of the other PS3 exclusives

Overated = Haze, giving this game a 6/10 is more generous than Bill Gates leaving his entire fortune to a blind and deaf orphan who's country is at war.

Underated = SIREN: Blood Curse and Wipeout HD for obvious reasons.

[QUOTE="Chutebox"]

R&C deserved a higher score.

Gonna sit and wait for someone (I already know who) to mention MGS4.

Chutebox

Overrated - MGS4

Underrated - LBP

:D

BioShockOwnz

Am I good or what! lol

I was actually a little let down that LBP got a 9 here, thought it would be 9.5 for sure.

9 is good, look at the bad points, one says that it can take a long time to make good levels.... how is that bad????

Do you look at a piece of art and say, its very good, but it took ages to make so I dont like it. You dont have to spend ages, it takes as long as you want it to. It depends on how good you ewant your level to me imo.

Overrated: Warioware: Smooth Moves

Underrated: Company of Heroes (should have gotten a 9.5 at least)

over rated- GTA4, NMHS, Wario Ware, Pdz, graw

under rated- Dead Rising, Rachet, Mass Effect, Halo 3 (jk)

Overated

Bioshock

What a piece of trash, the only brand new game ive bought in years and i wholely regret it...

Most overrated is that Wii game ... err, No more Heroes.

Underrated? Disgaea 3 Or ShadowRun

Overrated: PDZ, MGS4, Assassins Creed, and GTA 4
Underrated: Ratchet and Clank, Lost Odyssey, Dead Rising, Crackdown, and Disgaea 3

[QUOTE="Chutebox"]

R&C deserved a higher score.

Gonna sit and wait for someone (I already know who) to mention MGS4.

Chutebox

Overrated - MGS4

Underrated - LBP

:D

BioShockOwnz

Am I good or what! lol

I was actually a little let down that LBP got a 9 here, thought it would be 9.5 for sure.

Lol, I knew it! But I also was expecting/hoping that LBP got an 9.5. Still AAA regardless though :).

I think that Uncharted, Ratchet & Clank, and Mass Effect are underrated while PD0 and Wario Smooth Movies are overrated.

Over rated -Braid and most of the other 360 exclusives

Under rated-Wipe out HD,LBP,Resistance and most of the other PS3 exclusives

lesner87

I think that GS overrates XBL arcade games and underrates PSN games. When I think about it maybe they're just underrating PS3 games in general.

R&C deserved a higher score.

Gonna sit and wait for someone (I already know who) to mention MGS4.

Chutebox

[QUOTE="lesner87"]

Over rated -Braid and most of the other 360 exclusives

Under rated-Wipe out HD,LBP,Resistance and most of the other PS3 exclusives

Episode_Eve

I think that GS overrates XBL arcade games and underrates PSN games. When I think about it maybe they're just underrating PS3 games in general.

MGS4 says hi.

Also, PD0 deserved it's score as much as Resistance did. Both very decent FPS games, but ... that's about it.

[QUOTE="Episode_Eve"][QUOTE="lesner87"]

Over rated -Braid and most of the other 360 exclusives

Under rated-Wipe out HD,LBP,Resistance and most of the other PS3 exclusives

ukillwegrill

I think that GS overrates XBL arcade games and underrates PSN games. When I think about it maybe they're just underrating PS3 games in general.

MGS4 says hi.

Also, PD0 deserved it's score as much as Resistance did. Both very decent FPS games, but ... that's about it.

MGS4 is one game out of dozens. And the reviewer seemed to be a fan of the franchise. I am too so I can't complain :P. I guess we'll have to disagree on PD0 score (I'm not alone on this one). Also I think Resistance got a pretty good score. I'd rate it a little higher, maybe 9.0.

But games like Uncharted, R&C: ToD, Wipeout HD, and Super Stardust HD deserved higher.

Over: gta4

Under: Tales of Vesperia ( got over a hundred hours on this beast so far, still am enjoying the combat / getting achveiments ^.^) and Crackdown!

Overrated MGS4, Gears Of War

Underated The Witcher and Crackdown

ovverated GTA4.

underrated....

overrated - gears of bore

underrated - company of heroes : opposing frontsanshul89

overrated - gears of bore

underrated - company of heroes : opposing frontsanshul89

atleast this guy knows what im talking about! gears was boring and repetitive for me.

Overrated-Ninja Gaiden Sigma, CoD 4, MGS 4, NMH

Underrated-Ninja Gaiden 2, Ratchet and Clank

[QUOTE="anshul89"]overrated - gears of bore

underrated - company of heroes : opposing frontsblue_hazy_basic

Overrated- GTA4, MGS4, Oblivion

Underrated - R&C FTOD, Shadowrun, Crackdown

Overrated - MGS4

Underrated - LBP

:D

BioShockOwnz

Little Big Planet got AAA? Just what did you people expect for that game? AAAA? I actually agree it shouldn't get AAAA....it seems that score is being passed out like candy lately and pretty soon it'll numb us to titles getting it in the future.

I also agree, MGS4 or GTA4 could be the most overrated. I've played MGS4 for over an hour.....I don't know how that got AAAA. Definetly a fan of the series reviewed that game.

Overrated - MGS4

Underrated - LBP

:D

BioShockOwnz

Amen to that. ;)

Also ....

Overrated - GTAIV, MGS4

Underrated - Lost Odyssey

Overrated - MGS4, GTA4, Halo3, SMG

Underrated - MP3

R&C deserved a higher score.

Gonna sit and wait for someone (I already know who) to mention MGS4.

Chutebox

Me?

Overrated - MGS4, GTAIV

Underrated - Lost Odyssey, Civilization Revolution

Overrated - Assassin's Creed - The most boring "AAA" game I've ever played... I liked Lair better, no kidding.

Underrated - Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction - 7.5? Give me a break.

Honorable mention for being overrated - GTAIV - A great game, but not a 10.

Most deserving of a 10? METAL GEAR SOLID 4 - You heard that right. :lol:

OVERRATED:

1: Perfect Dark Zero.

2: No More Heroes.

3: WarioWare Smooth Moves.

Honorable Mention: Assassin's Creed

UNDERRATED:

1: Twilight Princess

2: Mass Effect

3: Ratchet and Clank

Overrated on Gamespot?VGobbsesser

I think so.

That's what I based my list on, at least.

Most overrated - PD0

Most underrated - R&C:TOD

[QUOTE="AMitch24"]PDZ deserved a 9 when it came out. It was a decent game and as a launch title where you don't have much to compare it to, it did deserve a 9. I know PGR3 and CoD2 were better games but maybe they were a little underrated. Just my .02 not fact of anything.SolidTy

I don't agree. COD2 owned all the other FPS's that year. There were better FPS's on Xbox and PS2 as well. It was a shoddy, awkward game, and one that all the other sites agreed, wasn't worth a "9."

In fact, after PDZ, Halo 2 became the most played 360 game on Xbox Live....AFTER PDZ made it's impact.

Basically, 360 owners would rather have played old, last gen game like Halo 2, than play or buy PDZ.

I bought TWO copies of PDZ, since I thought I was going to have some fun LAN parties with it (I own Two 360's.).

Laughably, COD2 became that game, along with Halo 2, Halo, etc.

Thank God for a Year later, Gears of War (GeoW). GeoW finally took the mantle from HALO2, as the most played game on 360 Xbox Live.

PDZ was a competent game, but very, very lackluster if you played FPS's since the early 90's.

I'm saying whoever reviewed it here, you can't blame them.

most overrated has to be assassins creed and halo3.

most underrated is audiosurf.

Overrated: Halo3

Underrated: Kameo

Over:WarioWare Smooth Moves (8.0 at best)

Under:R&C ToD

I forgot to add to my overatted list DEAD RISING

why do lemmings praise this repetitive tedious game so much with crap shooter controlls and ridiculous story.

Gh0st_Of_0nyx

I'm no lemming, but from what I played, if I had a 360, Dead Rising would be my first game.

perfectly rated: NMH and WW:SM