Most inexplicably overrated score on GS this gen?

Overrated-GTA4 (but everybody overrated it), NMH as well. Underrated - I think GS underrates lots of games. GS is one of the only sites to not give R&C and Uncharted AAA Am I the only one that thinks Assassins Creed was NOT overrated??POJO_MOFO

I would say...

Overrated: GTA4

Underrated: R&C, Lost Winds (if that counts), Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn, and possibly Boom Blox :o

[QUOTE="POJO_MOFO"]Overrated-GTA4 (but everybody overrated it), NMH as well. Underrated - I think GS underrates lots of games. GS is one of the only sites to not give R&C and Uncharted AAA Am I the only one that thinks Assassins Creed was NOT overrated??Czenkus

[QUOTE="voxware00"]

perfectly rated: NMH and WW:SM

RuprechtMonkey

Hahaaha.

Fanboy alert.

ww:sm was the first true console version of WW, plus 12 player multiplay with 1 wiimote = win.. i'm actually able to compare it to the other iterations unlike the haters as well

NMH wins due to design and artistic reasons, all technical issues get a pass when no other game can touch it in terms of humor and 4th wall message.. too much hate on original ips

i'd much rather defend these games than say PDO... personally i hate crap like oblivion but i'm not going to say its overrated simply because i haven't played it.. same should go for microgame haters who never sampled the chaos

as for you.. i've seen your topics so easily you're a bigger fanboy than i :P anyone who trolls making negative posts is clearly the bigger hater

[QUOTE="POJO_MOFO"]Overrated-GTA4 (but everybody overrated it), NMH as well. Underrated - I think GS underrates lots of games. GS is one of the only sites to not give R&C and Uncharted AAA Am I the only one that thinks Assassins Creed was NOT overrated??Czenkus

just like oblivion, although personally i think oblivion is miles better than AC

Overrated - MGS4

Underrated - LBP

:D

BioShockOwnz

Both are under rated.