Most overrated, fairly rated and underrated game this generation? (56k)

Overated : Geow (should be 7.5)

Fairly Rated : Orange Box

Underrated : CoH - OF (atleast 9.0)

By Gamespot:

Overrated: Gears

Fair: No More Herso

Underrated: Dead Rising

By Fanboys:

Overrated:Halo 3 and Gears

Fair: SMG

Underrated: Mario Kart Wii (everyones bashing it without even playing it it's amazing.)

overrated: Halo 3, Oblivion, Ninja Gaiden Sigma, Rainbow Six Vegas

fairly rated: Mass Effect, DMC4, COD4, Bioshock

underrated: Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, Viva Piñata

None

none

none

Geez this geow hate is so strong today and every hater says that is short, glithed up, and has a bad story but the gameplay is so good how can u not like it?? I haven't had that much fun with a game since tribes.

anyway, the best way to enjoy geow is to play with a few freinds practice alot then go out and have fun. Seariously gears is like the most up close and personal multiplayer game ever.

Overrated: GeoW, WarioWare: Smooth Moves, Perfect Dark Zero, No More Heroes

Fairly Rated: Bioshock, Uncharted, DMC4, Mario Galaxy

Underrated: R & C: TOD, Resistance

Overrated: Assassins Creed, GeoW

Fairly Rated: Uncharted, Oblivion

Underrated: Resistance, Team Fortress 2 (not Orange Box) It didnt get the attention it deserved casuals have never heard of it

None

none

none

EuroMafia

Hmmm, then why post?

Overrated: Gears of War, Halo 3, Assassin's Creed, Bioshock (Or overhyped? Not really sure, probably both)

Fairly Rated: Crysis, Oblivion (yes I said it), Command and Conquer 3 (PC), Super Smash Bros. Brawl, Orange Box

Underrated: Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn, The Witcher, The Darkness, Viking: Battle for Asgard (only on GS, deserved a 6.5-7.0), Mass Effect

every ps3 game is underrated

every thing else is overrated

...we get it, move on

overrated: resistance, orange box TONY HAWKS 3

fairly rated: all that isn't above or below. but some that i feel get bashed: halo 3, gears, smg.

underrated: metroid prime 3, twilight princess pgr 4

going by GS scores

Overrated: SMG, CoD4

Fairly Rated: Gears of War, Halo 3

Underrated: Lost Odyssey, Uncharted

Overrated

Fairly Rated

Underrated

Overrated - Gears of War, Assassins Creed

Fairly rated - Mass Effect, Halo 3, CoD4, Motorstorm, Forza 2

Underrated - R&CF, Uncharted, Dead Rising

Overrated:

Fairly Rated:

Underrated:

stephant_6

this guy knows where its at

Overated

Accurately / Fairly Rated

Underrated

Overrated - Gears of War

Fairly rated - Mass Effect, Halo 3, CoD4

Underrated - R&CF, Uncharted

leviathan91

typical cow veiw of the universe

[QUOTE="leviathan91"]

Overrated - Gears of War

Fairly rated - Mass Effect, Halo 3, CoD4

Underrated - R&CF, Uncharted

thegoldenpoo

typical cow veiw of the universe

Overrated: Super Smash Bros. Brawl

Fairly rated: Halo 3

Underrated: Mass Effect

Overrated:

Call of Duty 4

Halo 3

Gears of War

God of War II (technically not this gen I know)

Rainbow Six Vegas

Underrated

Ratchet and Clank

Fairly Rated

The Orange Box

The Elder Scrolls IV:Oblivion

I think that Gears of War was fairly rated - the game was almost perfect in everyway. An overrated game... World of Warcraft. As for underrated, I'd say Uncharted.

Overrated: Assassins Creed, GeoW

Fairly Rated: Uncharted, Oblivion

Underrated: Resistance, Team Fortress 2 (not Orange Box) It didnt get the attention it deserved casuals have never heard of it

speedjunkie1992

You should see all the funny screens people make

overated - gears of war (boring IMO) and brawl (never liked any of the series) also metroid (3d metroid still sucks balls)

fairly rated - orange box (best value for money game in a long time simply brilliant)

underated - uncharted, R&C, RfoM, pro evo (its not that bad)

its strange how despite having had all 3 consoles its only the PS3 games that seem to be underated :P i cant hide my colours

Overrated: Gears of War

Deserving: Orange Box or Sins of a Solar Empire

Underrated: STALKER, Witcher

Overrated: Super Mario Galaxy

Fairly Rated: Halo and Gears (They deserve what they got)

Underrated: LoZTP, Warhawk

Overrated:Halo3,Assassin Creed.

Fairly Rated:SSB, Call of duty 4,

Underrated:Unchated,Devil may cry 4

I will only judge the games I have played a lot of:

Overrated: GEOW and Oblivion

Fairly rated: Crysis, CoD 4, SoASE

Underrated: Wii sports, Twilight Princess, PES 2008, Super Mario Galaxy

gears of war: overrated

ssbb: fairly rated

smg: underrated.

I can't tell you about overrated or most fairly rated, but I can sure tell you what the most underrated game (by GS) of this generation is.

Seriously. A 6.0 because its too hard? Its not even that hard until the final few battles...

MetroidPrimePwn

The controls were the only thing dissapointing in that game...

Overrated: Assassins Creed, Gears of War

Fairly rated: COD4

Underrated: RFOM, Uncharted

• Halo 3
• TESIV: Oblivion
• BioShock

• Gears of War
• Call of Duty 4

• Twilight Princess
• Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
• The Orange Box
• God of War II (released in 2007)

• Max Payne (It's Max ****ing Payne... one of the best stories ever...)
• S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl
• Dead Rising (I spent more time with the demo than I did with BioShock and enjoyed the demo more)
• Audiosurf (a "shallow" $10 Indie game, what a joke)
• Shadowrun
• Crackdown (another game that I had more fun playing the demo than some other full games)

Overrated: CoD 4(this game is absolute trash)

Fairly Rated: Halo 3, Brawl

Underrated: Lost Odyssey, Uncharted

hey thrones im really starting to think you dont even own a 360.. your honestly 1 of the biggest ps3 fanboys on system warspro-nathan-07

...I praised Halo 3 as one of the greatest games this generations and..I hate the 360? Contact me on Xbox Live, I'm currently playing Gears of War until GTAIV comes out.

EDIT: In fact, I praise the Wii and PC alot as well. Along with 360..hmmm...Fable 2. I just find most of the 360 fanboys annoying on these forums, so contradicting them is one of my highest priorities :D

Overrated:

Half Life 2: Episode 1 ( 8.6 ) - I would rate it 8.3.

Call of Duty 2 ( 8.8 ) - I'd say 8.4.

WarioWare: Smooth Moves ( 9.1 ) - WTF? 7.2.

Fairly Rated:

Call of Duty 4 ( 9.0 ) - 8.9 in my opinion.

The Lord of the Rings: The Battle for Middle Earth 2 ( 8.3 ) - Pretty accurate score, it's a fun dune 2 clone, nothing more.

Underrated:

The Orange Box ( 9.5 ) - Deserves 10 easily.

S.T.A.L.K.E.R. Shadow of Chernobyl ( 8.5 ) - I would rate it 9.8.

Company of Heroes ( 9.0 ) - Yet another 10 for me.

Sins of A Solar Empire ( 9.0 ) - 9.6 IMO

Warhammer 40, 000: Dawn of War: Dark Crusade ( 8.8 ) - 9.3.

Overrated: Perfect Dark Zero

Fairly Rated: Metroid Prime 3

Underrated: None

overrated: half life series

faily rated: dmc4

underrated: lost odyssey

overrated: half life series

faily rated: dmc4

underrated: lost odyssey

Dante2710

Overrated:

Uncharted

GT5: P

Underrated:

Dark Sector

Gears of War

BioShockOwnz

[QUOTE="Dante2710"]

overrated: half life series

faily rated: dmc4

underrated: lost odyssey

thrones

Overrated - Nothing

Fairly rated - PDZ - CoD4 - Halo 3

Underrated - Definately Lost Odessy

Over Rated:... Um... Halo 3?
Fairly Rated: SMG
Underated: Fire Emblem walks in and takes this award from whatever game you have been thinking about.

Overrated:

Fairly rated:

Underrated:

Overrated: CoD4, Gears of War

Fairly Rated: Crysis, Orange Box and everything in it.

Underrated: Probably Audiosurf, what with the whole "being able to play your entire music library as a game for $10" thing.

Overrated:

1. Oblivion
2. Super Smash Brothers Brawl
3. Warioware
4. No More Heroes

Fairly rated:

1. Many games

Underrated:

1. Ratchet & Clank
2. Lost Odyssey
3. The Witcher
4. Fire Emblem
5. Mass Effect