Official Bioshock Review Discussion Thread - 9.0 (POST HERE OR BE SUSPENDED)

Wow. Gamespot flops another game...TrueReligion_

Not the 9.5 or 10 I was hopeing for but it's still AAA.

.....and people are still mad? 9.0 = AAA

EDIT: So much for that video. (see sig)

Nice job narrowly avoiding a flop lemmings. :lol:

chalck up another AAA for 360.

should of gotten 9.5.

[QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...mis3ry

After seeing all the perfect scores, I thought this would easily get a 9.5.

[QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...mis3ry

It was widley hyped AAAA and this IS system wars. The only place a AAA game can be called a flop.

I bet he gave it the same as Zelda but rounded it up to 9.0 because of the rating scheme.

;D

9.0, thought it would be 9.5 but at leat its AAA.

i said 9.5 it got a 9. i was owned/xbox360isgr8t

I said 9.5 too, I kinda hoped this game would get a 10. Because the last game that got AAAA was tony hawks I think.

[QUOTE="mis3ry"][QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...MGS9150

It was widley hyped AAAA and this IS system wars. The only place a AAA game can be called a flop.

no AAA game can be called a flop. that's a system wars rule.

Annoying hitches? In both the PC *and* 360 version Jeff, or was this reviewed on a broken 360?subrosian

This is the 360 version. If the PC version can't get 9.5, WHAT CAN?!

[QUOTE="MGS9150"]

[QUOTE="mis3ry"][QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...CaseyWegner

It was widley hyped AAAA and this IS system wars. The only place a AAA game can be called a flop.

no AAA game can be called a flop. that's a system wars rule.

I'm not saying its a flop, i'm saying this is system wars. Fanboys will even call a AAAA a flop if they find ONE thing wrong with it.

Way to go Jeff, you scored one of the best games ever, the lowest score on the net, you're cool. Not that it actually matters, your review is so late it's lost all meaning. People already know this game is GOTY, they don't need your attention seeking review to prove anything to themselves.

Won't even read it.

Annoying hitches? In both the PC *and* 360 version Jeff, or was this reviewed on a broken 360?subrosian

thinking the same thing.

The fact that the freezing problem hasn't been mentioned in ANY other reviews makes me question it's credibility...

When it has gotten constant 10/10s and 9.5s, it just seems iffy when they give it a 9.0.

Either way, I don't really care. I'll be playing this tomorrow and will be very happy about it.

EDIT: And he actually complained about the combat? Funny how all the other reviews say that the combat is some of the best in a FPS ever, and he says he doesn't like it. Oh, and if I read this correctly, they didn't even mention hacking. Disappointing review Gamespot, especially for being so late.

[QUOTE="MGS9150"]

[QUOTE="mis3ry"][QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...CaseyWegner

It was widley hyped AAAA and this IS system wars. The only place a AAA game can be called a flop.

no AAA game can be called a flop. that's a system wars rule.

Is it one of those unwritten rules everyone knows or is there actually a link?

[QUOTE="mis3ry"][QUOTE="TrueReligion_"]Wow. Gamespot flops another game...TrueReligion_

After seeing all the perfect scores, I thought this would easily get a 9.5.

yea same here. i even thought this game might even have a chance of getting a 10. doesnt matter i still want it badly and cant wait till i pick it up tomorrow.

Way to go Jeff, you scored one of the best games ever, the lowest score on the net, you're cool. Not that it actually matters, your review is so late it's lost all meaning. People already know this game is GOTY, they don't need your attention seeking review to prove anything to themselves.

Won't even read it.

NickyJo

Why don't you read it to see why it got a 9 huh? Instead of being ignorant.

Geeze, your just like the sheep when Twilight Princess game got reviewed.

Eh, still picking it up tomorrow. Kind of surprised that the only two things listed under the "Bad" section were nitpicks, yet they still cost the game a full point.

Guess the new GS scoring system's going to be a great deal stricter than before

REVIEWS IS IN!!

WE HAVE SOME LOSERS IN SW Bets!!! Muahaha

9.5 and under means we need to collect on some bets people

:o 9 is lower than I expected. Ah well, GOTY confirmed. TCHBO and TSHBO! :lol: