Official GeoW3 vs UC3 thread!! KEEP IT HERE!

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Avatar image for waltefmoney
waltefmoney

18030

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#201 waltefmoney
Member since 2010 • 18030 Posts

Yeah that is right in case the game Uncharted 3 the sequels to the highest rated exclusive PS3 game flops.tormentos

Seems like a weird thing to do when a game flops.

Avatar image for tormentos
tormentos

33793

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#202 tormentos
Member since 2003 • 33793 Posts

[QUOTE="tormentos"]Yeah that is right in case the game Uncharted 3 the sequels to the highest rated exclusive PS3 game flops.waltefmoney

Seems like a weird thing to do when a game flops.

You know for some one who basically told me that i have to play both games to say which has better graphics,i say you are quite fast jumping the gun even daring to pull the word flop on a Uncharted 3 thread,what if Gears flop.? Oh yeah it will not because is warranty to not flop based on your opinion,and since Uncharted 3 not flopping is based on my opinion it doesn't count,Uncharted 3 has as many chances of flopping as Gears 3 have. Basically non i have to add.
Avatar image for waltefmoney
waltefmoney

18030

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#203 waltefmoney
Member since 2010 • 18030 Posts

You know for some one who basically told me that i have to play both games to say which has better graphics,i say you are quite fast jumping the gun even daring to pull the word flop on a Uncharted 3 thread,what if Gears flop.? Oh yeah it will not because is warranty to not flop based on your opinion,and since Uncharted 3 not flopping is based on my opinion it doesn't count,Uncharted 3 has as many chances of flopping as Gears 3 have. Basically non i have to add.tormentos

Dude, read my original post again and think about what you're doing wrong.

Avatar image for tormentos
tormentos

33793

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#204 tormentos
Member since 2003 • 33793 Posts

[QUOTE="tormentos"]You know for some one who basically told me that i have to play both games to say which has better graphics,i say you are quite fast jumping the gun even daring to pull the word flop on a Uncharted 3 thread,what if Gears flop.? Oh yeah it will not because is warranty to not flop based on your opinion,and since Uncharted 3 not flopping is based on my opinion it doesn't count,Uncharted 3 has as many chances of flopping as Gears 3 have. Basically non i have to add.waltefmoney

Dude, read my original post again and think about what you're doing wrong.

I say 50% in favor of Uncharted 3 and you exploded into flames,accusing me of claiming ownage when i did not do that period.
Avatar image for waltefmoney
waltefmoney

18030

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#205 waltefmoney
Member since 2010 • 18030 Posts

I say 50% in favor of Uncharted 3 and you exploded into flames,accusing me of claiming ownage when i did not do that period.tormentos

The question(again) - Why did you post it? What is the purpose of marking the point where 50% of the poll is in favor of Uncharted 3's box art?

Avatar image for tormentos
tormentos

33793

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#206 tormentos
Member since 2003 • 33793 Posts

[QUOTE="tormentos"]I say 50% in favor of Uncharted 3 and you exploded into flames,accusing me of claiming ownage when i did not do that period.waltefmoney

The question(again) - Why did you post it? What is the purpose of marking the point where 50% of the poll is in favor of Uncharted 3's box art?

Are you serious.? Is this guy really serious.? I already told you why,and you actually spin what i say,claiming that i did it to at least have something if Uncharted 3 flopped,you even dare to bring the word flop into this thread lol.. I tell you this i am not like you,i actually like Gears and have play both 1 and 2,and i will get the 3rd if you are waiting for me to say Gears will flop or suck or any thing like that,then you have to do a long wait dude,i also like Uncharted 3 and i know non of the 2 will flop,and like i already told you i did it to mark the moment when UC3 got 50% on the poll nothing less nothing more. You can spin it any way you like,i did not say anything bad or bring the word flop in this thread.
Avatar image for waltefmoney
waltefmoney

18030

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#207 waltefmoney
Member since 2010 • 18030 Posts

Are you serious.? Is this guy really serious.? I already told you why,and you actually spin what i say,claiming that i did it to at least have something if Uncharted 3 flopped,you even dare to bring the word flop into this thread lol.. I tell you this i am not like you,i actually like Gears and have play both 1 and 2,and i will get the 3rd if you are waiting for me to say Gears will flop or suck or any thing like that,then you have to do a long wait dude,i also like Uncharted 3 and i know non of the 2 will flop,and like i already told you i did it to mark the moment when UC3 got 50% on the poll nothing less nothing more. You can spin it any way you like,i did not say anything bad or bring the word flop in this thread.tormentos

I didn't say Uncharted 3 will flop. :|

I said "in case" Uncharted 3 flops. And why? Why mark it? It's a simple question.

"you even dare to bring the word flop into this thread lol"

This made me lol.

Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#208 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it. Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

Avatar image for PAL360
PAL360

30574

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 31

User Lists: 0

#209 PAL360
Member since 2007 • 30574 Posts

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it. Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin

Man, the only thing ppl dont like about Gears 2 is it´s multiplayer and it´s not any bad like you are making it sound. It got positive reviews because of it´s great campaign and coop modes like horde.

Third instalements wise you cant make conclusions yet. All ppl have played of both games so far are their betas and (goint by epic and gears 3 forums) i have yet to see a guy disappointed with the game.

Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#210 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it. Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

PAL360

Man, the only thing ppl dont like about Gears 2 is it´s multiplayer and it´s not any bad like you are making it sound. It got positive reviews because of it´s great campaign and coop modes like horde.

Third instalements wise you cant make conclusions yet. All ppl have played of both games so far are their betas and (goint by epic and gears 3 forums) i have yet to see a guy disappointed with the game.

It was not only the multiplayer that was beyond broken and terrible. The Single player had a terrible pace, much worse then the first game, the story was so cringe worthy, their attempt to put emotion into a game like gears was beyond dumb. That whole Maria thing just no... The boss fights were terrible. The game was just supremely overrated for a AAA franchise. I just have no faith in them honestly. And the MP did not get positive reviews, the MP wasn't even online when the reviews came out. They assumed the mp was great. Probably why the game was so overscored.
Avatar image for marklarmer
marklarmer

3883

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#211 marklarmer
Member since 2004 • 3883 Posts

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it.Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin

and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest game of all time on Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have better everything, Gears has much greater variety in weapons,enemies and vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#212 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it.Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

marklarmer

and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest game of all time on Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have better everything, Gears has much greater variety in weapons,enemies and vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year, so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans.
Avatar image for PAL360
PAL360

30574

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 31

User Lists: 0

#213 PAL360
Member since 2007 • 30574 Posts

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it. Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin

Man, the only thing ppl dont like about Gears 2 is it´s multiplayer and it´s not any bad like you are making it sound. It got positive reviews because of it´s great campaign and coop modes like horde.

Third instalements wise you cant make conclusions yet. All ppl have played of both games so far are their betas and (goint by epic and gears 3 forums) i have yet to see a guy disappointed with the game.

It was not only the multiplayer that was beyond broken and terrible. The Single player had a terrible pace, much worse then the first game, the story was so cringe worthy, their attempt to put emotion into a game like gears was beyond dumb. That whole Maria thing just no... The boss fights were terrible. The game was just supremely overrated for a AAA franchise. I just have no faith in them honestly. And the MP did not get positive reviews, the MP wasn't even online when the reviews came out. They assumed the mp was great. Probably why the game was so overscored.

the boss fights were terrible and...that´s where it ends. The pacing was awesome, the story was ok, the grapgics and gameplay improved in all aspects. Im playing it´s campaign again and im impressive of how good it is. You should do the same or at least read some reviews.

Avatar image for PAL360
PAL360

30574

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 31

User Lists: 0

#214 PAL360
Member since 2007 • 30574 Posts

[QUOTE="marklarmer"]

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it.Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin

and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest game of all time on Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have better everything, Gears has much greater variety in weapons,enemies and vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year, so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans.

Then, if you find other ppl opinion so important, you should pay more attention to Gears 3 beta feedback. You will be impressed :)

Anyway, all you are saying is that Gears 2 is overrated and Uncharted 2 sederved it´s praise. Typical :P

Avatar image for marklarmer
marklarmer

3883

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#215 marklarmer
Member since 2004 • 3883 Posts

[QUOTE="marklarmer"]

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it.Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin

and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest gameof all timeon Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have bettereverything, Gears hasmuch greatervariety in weapons,enemiesand vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year,so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans.

so you're judging whether a game is 'overscored' based on the quality of the other games released just that year? :|

Avatar image for tormentos
tormentos

33793

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#216 tormentos
Member since 2003 • 33793 Posts

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it. Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

DrWin
Which is even worst in the first one,which was a buggy mess online,and offline controls were sluggish unresponsive and slow,your squad AI was just plain dumb,enemies acted dumb from time to time as well,i don't even know how some sites even dare to rate it perfect even that they noted all the flaws the game had,i have see games been trow into the fire for smaller problems that the ones Gears of war had,let alone having so many problems combined,it was rated on graphics more than actual merits period,and the problems the game had like. 1)Poor Squad AI on a Squad shooter. 2)Cheap enemies which also acted dumb from time to time. 3)Glitchest were you would get stock in parts,unable to move,happen more often when you walked over the place where you threw a grenade. 4)Dom was useless practically getting more in your way than helping you,and would get stock in places and refuse to fallow you,leaving you fight alone when he is suppose to help you. 5)Online was laggy and broken even that it was just a 4 vs 4 game,which make me think that reviewers never played the game online. 6)By far one of the most horrible host advantages issues an online game could experience happen to this game,basically if you were the host and had a shotgun it was a massacre what happen to other players,very easy to notice when you shut the host and he was able to just turn around an shotgun you to hell,even when you well placed shots on him even with prefect reload.
Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#217 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"][QUOTE="marklarmer"]and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest gameof all timeon Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have bettereverything, Gears hasmuch greatervariety in weapons,enemiesand vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

marklarmer

Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year,so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans.

so you're judging whether a game is 'overscored' based on the quality of the other games released just that year? :|

Is this a joke question? Ofcourse that's how reviews work. THey depend on their genre and their competition... If 10 RPGS come out this year and are all amazing RPG's the standards for RPG's goes up, reviews take that into account...
Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#218 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"][QUOTE="marklarmer"]and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest game of all time on Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have better everything, Gears has much greater variety in weapons,enemies and vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

PAL360

Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year, so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans.

Then, if you find other ppl opinion so important, you should pay more attention to Gears 3 beta feedback. You will be impressed :)

Anyway, all you are saying is that Gears 2 is overrated and Uncharted 2 sederved it´s praise. Typical :P

I'm confused, did you miss the aprt where I played the game? How else would I know so much about it? This is my opinion, backed up by GEars veterans to back up my credibility. And to say Gears 2 had good pacing dear god please never make a video game.
Avatar image for marklarmer
marklarmer

3883

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 0

#219 marklarmer
Member since 2004 • 3883 Posts

[QUOTE="marklarmer"]

[QUOTE="DrWin"] Uncharted got amazing reviews, let the hype die down, and then proceeded to win a record breaking amount of awards at the end of the year,so it was not over scored. The honeymoon period passed and people still deemed the game worthy of that praise. It's still deemed worthy today. Gears 2 on the other hand failed miserably post reviews. And it's been heavily criticised for a long time and by a lot of people included hardcore gears veterans. DrWin

so you're judging whether a game is 'overscored' based on the quality of the other games released just that year? :|

Is this a joke question? Ofcourse that's how reviews work. THey depend on their genre and their competition... If 10 RPGS come out this year and are all amazing RPG's the standards for RPG's goes up, reviews take that into account...

but Gears of War 2 released the same years as GTA4 and MGS4, both rated higher than it on Gamerankings and both which scored 10 here, the odds were those games would win more GOTY awards than Gears of War 2, how does that effect whether Gears of War 2 deserved its score? :| now look at the games that released the same year as Uncharted 2..........

Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#220 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"][QUOTE="marklarmer"]so you're judging whether a game is 'overscored' based on the quality of the other games released just that year? :|

marklarmer

Is this a joke question? Ofcourse that's how reviews work. THey depend on their genre and their competition... If 10 RPGS come out this year and are all amazing RPG's the standards for RPG's goes up, reviews take that into account...

but Gears of War 2 released the same years as GTA4 and MGS4, both rated higher than it on Gamerankings and both which scored 10 here, the odds were those games would win more GOTY awards than Gears of War 2, how does that effect whether Gears of War 2 deserved its score? :| now look at the games that released the same year as Uncharted 2..........

Just a way to prove Uncharted to didn't get some sort of free pass with reviews and reviews off hype cause they were backed up with awards later down the line. Gears 2, not so much...
Avatar image for tormentos
tormentos

33793

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#221 tormentos
Member since 2003 • 33793 Posts
but Gears of War 2 released the same years as GTA4 and MGS4, both rated higher than it on Gamerankings and both which scored 10 here, the odds were those games would win more GOTY awards than Gears of War 2, how does that effect whether Gears of War 2 deserved its score? :| now look at the games that released the same year as Uncharted 2..........marklarmer
I think Gears 2 deserved the score out side the whole nostalgia thing that was a joke,it fixed or at least try to many of the problems the first Gears of War had,which i think is the one that should not have score more than 8.5 based on all the problems it had,from lag and horrible host advantage issues,to AI and control problems this are serious problems that never went away on Gears 1 and that have send many games spinning into bad scores. Is clear that Gears 2 faced some good games on 2008,but Uncharted 2,faced many great and popular ones as well including Call of Duty Modern Warfare 2,Forza 3,Batman Arkham Asylum,Street Fighter 4 and many other.
Avatar image for iory2
iory2

370

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#222 iory2
Member since 2003 • 370 Posts

If those are final I'd choose gears by far.

Avatar image for MrJack3690
MrJack3690

2227

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#223 MrJack3690
Member since 2004 • 2227 Posts

Playing through Gears 1 again now. Man I haven't played gears 2 yet, and it's been since late 06 early 07 since I've played it. I've only played it at friends' houses, and finally got it for myself. (Got the gears triple back for my birthday) and I plan on playing through 2 to get me ready for 3.

I've already played through Uncharted 1 and 2 plenty of times, so I'm well ready for Uncharted 3. But I might play through some of both and some U2 multiplayer anyways :)

Avatar image for planbfreak4eva
planbfreak4eva

2856

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#224 planbfreak4eva
Member since 2006 • 2856 Posts

[QUOTE="DrWin"]

I'm 100% sure Uncharted will come out on top. I think Gears may sell more, maybe even score around the same just maybe a little higher, but it'll be all on hype. Cause Gears 2 got amazing reviews and everyone hated it.Reviewers seem to get overhyped on gears and not even truly review the game for what it is.

That being said, Uncharted will win where it matters most, the awards at the end of the year. After the hype has died down, awards are the true way to see who had the better game. ANd Uncharted will destroy Gears in awards. It's just a much higher quality game. It has better everything, graphics, story, music, polish, gameplay, pacing, production values, replayablity, multiplayer. In the end, when all is said in done. Uncharted will win. It'll be remembered as the better game.

marklarmer

and yet Uncharted 2 sits rated as the 6th highest game of all time on Gamerankings, with a final boss fight that consists of running in circles :? and no Uncharted doesn't have better everything, Gears has much greater variety in weapons,enemies and vehicle sections.

The difference seems to be people (at least here) are willing to list flaws with Gears of War, which you've decided means everybody hates it. where as Uncharted 2 ironically seems to have received the treatment you accused reviewers of giving Gears of War. in my opinion of course.

dude. tell me one good boss in the ending of a game. uc1,2,infamous 2, bioshock, dead space 2, god of war? its the same thing in all of them. you pretty much run around, block, hide, attack and again the same thing...thats all the bosses in the ending...even through the game just some strategy and done...i cant think of 1 boss ending which was actually exciting and you couldnt predict anything and it was a long fight...
Avatar image for deactivated-5c03000d4b1b4
deactivated-5c03000d4b1b4

1750

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#225 deactivated-5c03000d4b1b4
Member since 2010 • 1750 Posts
Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.
Avatar image for moose_knuckler
moose_knuckler

5722

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#226 moose_knuckler
Member since 2007 • 5722 Posts
Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.narutosup
The better story part is up in the air.
Avatar image for DrWin
DrWin

217

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#227 DrWin
Member since 2011 • 217 Posts
[QUOTE="narutosup"]Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.moose_knuckler
The better story part is up in the air.

l0l better story up in the air in a Gears vs Uncharted thread. l0l :lol:
Avatar image for StrongDeadlift
StrongDeadlift

6073

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#228 StrongDeadlift
Member since 2010 • 6073 Posts

[QUOTE="narutosup"]Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.moose_knuckler
The better story part is up in the air.

I have to spit my food up laughing @ "Gears" and "story" in the same sentence :lol:. I rented Gears 2 (2 years ago) and returned it the next day. The story was basically nonexistant for the most part, and the campaign was such an unpolished turd it wasnt even funny. The game looked like an unpolished Unreal Engine 3 tech demo with Horde Mode (which was the ONLY redeeming factor the game had going for it).

Ok its safe to say the Gears 3 hype is getting out of hand. It will have good multiplayer, but Really lems? Were hyping Gears 3's "Story" now? :lol:

Avatar image for BilkeLegenda
BilkeLegenda

1933

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#229 BilkeLegenda
Member since 2009 • 1933 Posts

Compared to UC story,Gears story isnt that good but it is descent,and if u deny that ur just hating on an overall amazing game.

Avatar image for rumbalumba
rumbalumba

2445

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

#230 rumbalumba
Member since 2011 • 2445 Posts
[QUOTE="narutosup"]Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.moose_knuckler
The better story part is up in the air.

HA. ha. hahahahahahha!
Avatar image for Avian005
Avian005

4112

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 51

User Lists: 0

#231 Avian005
Member since 2009 • 4112 Posts

[QUOTE="moose_knuckler"][QUOTE="narutosup"]Uncharted 3 will be better. better single player, better animation, better characters, better story.StrongDeadlift

The better story part is up in the air.

I have to spit my food up laughing @ "Gears" and "story" in the same sentence :lol:. I rented Gears 2 (2 years ago) and returned it the next day. The story was basically nonexistant for the most part, and the campaign was such an unpolished turd it wasnt even funny. The game looked like an unpolished Unreal Engine 3 tech demo with Horde Mode (which was the ONLY redeeming factor the game had going for it).

Ok its safe to say the Gears 3 hype is getting out of hand. It will have good multiplayer, but Really lems? Were hyping Gears 3's "Story" now? :lol:

I've always been interested in the Gears story, especially after reading the books. Sure, it's not great, but it's not bad either. And where's the unpolished turd? Never seen Gears 2 like that.

Uncharted's story is better though.

Avatar image for AdobeArtist
AdobeArtist

25184

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 0

#232 AdobeArtist  Moderator
Member since 2006 • 25184 Posts

OK, let's see how the forums do without the stick on this one :)