PS3 Flops vs 360 Flops

[QUOTE="GootHimp"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="SolidGame_basic"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped SaintsRowSam

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

Too Human got 68% on gamerankings if that makes you happy. :|

and it got 4/5 on xplay if that makes you happy

gamerankings uses the average of all sites if that makes you happy. and wat the hell is xplay,more than half the ppl dont even know about that site so y are you useing that one. use gamernakings. too human is a flop, uncharted isnt deal with it.

so your saying you can only use gamespot and gamerankings if it benifits you, but you cant use other sites that benifit other people?

dude are you even reading my messages???

I said use gamerankings!! so it uses every site so it doesnt matter what benefits who. and so we dont have to argue which site to use. and its most accurate on gr.

[QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.Lionheart08

And Mass Effect. I don't really see the point of this thread though. :|

mass effect isnt exclusive

It was exclusive at time of the review though...

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

[QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="GootHimp"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="SolidGame_basic"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped GootHimp

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

Too Human got 68% on gamerankings if that makes you happy. :|

and it got 4/5 on xplay if that makes you happy

gamerankings uses the average of all sites if that makes you happy. and wat the hell is xplay,more than half the ppl dont even know about that site so y are you useing that one. use gamernakings. too human is a flop, uncharted isnt deal with it.

so your saying you can only use gamespot and gamerankings if it benifits you, but you cant use other sites that benifit other people?

dude are you even reading my messages???

I said use gamerankings!! so it uses every site so it doesnt matter what benefits who. and so we dont have to argue which site to use. and its most accurate on gr.

Just to clear up all confusion, and since we're on GameSpot forums, we should just use GameSpot scores.

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.wmc540

And Mass Effect. I don't really see the point of this thread though. :|

mass effect isnt exclusive

It was exclusive at time of the review though...

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

Well it was only the 360 version which flopped so...

[QUOTE="zath5"]im a huge 360 fan boy but isnt flop a little harsh on like half of those ps3 games?? most of those are great gamesRob_101

Exactly. 360 has more bad games than PS3. Hour of Victory anyone?

This statement is false.

[QUOTE="wmc540"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.locopatho

And Mass Effect. I don't really see the point of this thread though. :|

mass effect isnt exclusive

It was exclusive at time of the review though...

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

Well it was only the 360 version which flopped so...

So Gears of War is a 360 exclusive because the 360 version got a 9.6 and the PC version got a 9.0?

dude are you even reading my messages???

I said use gamerankings!! so it uses every site so it doesnt matter what benefits who. and so we dont have to argue which site to use. and its most accurate on gr.

GootHimp

Please read the system wars rules sticky. Only gamespot scores count when makin score comparisons here, so that there's a set standard.

LOOL ratchet and clank and heavenly sword WERE NOTTT HYPED (HS more then RC, but they still were like "meh, more games, woo"iesexywarden

Just did some research. Heavenly Sword Offical Hype thread was AAA (I admit wrongness on that part.) I couldn't find R&C, but it was diffenently in the AA/AAA range.

So Gears of War is a 360 exclusive because the 360 version got a 9.6 and the PC version got a 9.0?

wmc540

No... but if one version gets 8.5 and other gets 9, one flopped and the other didn't. Meh doesn't matter anyway since I love Mass Effect no matter what the score :D

[QUOTE="wmc540"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"][QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.locopatho

And Mass Effect. I don't really see the point of this thread though. :|

mass effect isnt exclusive

It was exclusive at time of the review though...

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

Well it was only the 360 version which flopped so...

The thing about that is, if Mass Effect is counted as a flop, then Gears of War must be counted as an AAA exclusive and I never see people granting the 360 Gears as an AAA.

The thing about that is, if Mass Effect is counted as a flop, then Gears of War must be counted as an AAA exclusive and I never see people granting the 360 Gears as an AAA.

Tragic_Kingdom7

Lol System Wars is confusing :P

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

wmc540

Because, clearly my track record has shown me being anti-360 in every thread. Or better yet, you ignored the part where I accepted the reason why Mass Effect shouldn't be used. :roll:

[QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped GootHimp

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

nope lmao at too human. too human on gamerankings is around 65 right now. and it was hyped AA. uncharted is a 9 rite now on gr and it was hyped AAA

Too Human was no way hyped AA. It's possibly the most hated on game of this gen. :?

[QUOTE="GootHimp"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped Ninja-Hippo

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

nope lmao at too human. too human on gamerankings is around 65 right now. and it was hyped AA. uncharted is a 9 rite now on gr and it was hyped AAA

Too Human was no way hyped AA. It's possibly the most hated on game of this gen. :?

[QUOTE="Rob_101"]

[QUOTE="zath5"]im a huge 360 fan boy but isnt flop a little harsh on like half of those ps3 games?? most of those are great gamesDisturbed_One98

Exactly. 360 has more bad games than PS3. Hour of Victory anyone?

This statement is false.

It's not false, but the logic is definitely skewed.

The 360 is bound to have more stinkers because it has a bigger library period.

The PS2 had more stinkers than Xbox, but still had a far superior library simply because there were more games.

Also, I don't know why zath5 is bring words like harsh into it and saying most were great games. A mathematic evaluation of flops doesn't take harshness and opinions into account.

[QUOTE="Tragic_Kingdom7"]

The thing about that is, if Mass Effect is counted as a flop, then Gears of War must be counted as an AAA exclusive and I never see people granting the 360 Gears as an AAA.

locopatho

Lol System Wars is confusing :P

Yeah, that's why it's best to just have one standard: pure exclusives.

[QUOTE="wmc540"]

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

Lionheart08

Because, clearly my track record has shown me being anti-360 in every thread. Or better yet, you ignored the part where I accepted the reason why Mass Effect shouldn't be used. :roll:

My appologies. I just assume crazy fanboy first, examine facts second.

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="wmc540"]

ROFL here is a good case of someone wanting to have it both ways. Gears of War, Halo 2, etc aren't exclusives, but Mass Effect the flop is.

wmc540

Because, clearly my track record has shown me being anti-360 in every thread. Or better yet, you ignored the part where I accepted the reason why Mass Effect shouldn't be used. :roll:

My appologies. I just assume crazy fanboy first, examine facts second.

I actually started thinking that was how I was coming off when i first started posting on this thread so no problem. :P

[QUOTE="GootHimp"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped Ninja-Hippo

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

nope lmao at too human. too human on gamerankings is around 65 right now. and it was hyped AA. uncharted is a 9 rite now on gr and it was hyped AAA

Too Human was no way hyped AA. It's possibly the most hated on game of this gen. :?

what!!!!!?!?!?!?the last 4 months or so, the only 2 gaqmes i keep on seeing lemmings mention are too human and fable. and everytime i seen too human the was a hyped a score of AAA or AAAA. I never seen the official hype thread as ive been gone for a while but i do remember telling every single lemming here to just let go of too human the game is gonna suck. and then i got flamed.....bad. looks like i was right though.

Edit:that list seems pretty fair. though i still am angry about RaC. taking points away for haveing too much to do????i dont think ill ever get over that BS.

[QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

PLEASE REMIND ME IF I FORGOT ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE

Ps3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AAA, Score 4.5

Uncharted Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Haze Hyped AA-AAA (the halo killer), Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AAA, Score 7.5

Folklore Hyped AA, Score 7.0

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9 (one tenth of a point!)

Flops= 8 (maybe more)

360

Too Human, Hyped AA-AAA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.5

Flops=3 (maybe more)

Lionheart08

I don't recall R&C, Heavenly Sword, and Uncharted getting hyped AAA.:?

Moving on...

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

PLEASE REMIND ME IF I FORGOT ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE

Ps3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AAA, Score 4.5

Uncharted Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Haze Hyped AA-AAA (the halo killer), Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AAA, Score 7.5

Folklore Hyped AA, Score 7.0

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9 (one tenth of a point!)

Flops= 8 (maybe more)

360

Too Human, Hyped AA-AAA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.5

Flops=3 (maybe more)

MassiveKaos

I don't recall R&C, Heavenly Sword, and Uncharted getting hyped AAA.:?

Moving on...

He edited the list.

And Heavenly Sword was definitely hyped AAA and R&C definitely flopped.

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.SaintsRowSam

thanks :)

R&C was hyped AA, yes it flopped, but you're hype is wrong.

Also, Crackdown flopped.

PS3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AA, Score 4.5

Haze Hyped AA, Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AA, Score 7.5

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9

Flops = 6

360

Too Human, Hyped AA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA, Score 7.5

Blue Dragon Hyped AA, Score 6.0

Crackdown Hyped AA, Score 7.8

Flops = 5

Corrected list.

Slashkice

Mass effect floped, I remember cause I was here :P

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"]

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.SaintsRowSam

And Mass Effect. I don't really see the point of this thread though. :|

mass effect isnt exclusive

RRODSolidGame_basic

Didn't know that was a game?

[QUOTE="Slashkice"]

PS3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AA, Score 4.5

Haze Hyped AA, Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AA, Score 7.5

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9

Flops = 6

360

Too Human, Hyped AA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA, Score 7.5

Blue Dragon Hyped AA, Score 6.0

Crackdown Hyped AA, Score 7.8

Flops = 5

Corrected list.

Eddie-Vedder

Mass effect floped, I remember cause I was here :P

Oh yeah, Mass Effect. This thread is 360 vs. PS3 flops, not 360 Exclusives vs. PS3 Exclusive flops.

Mass Effect Definatly belongs, but I'm sure both system's have more we forgot.

PLEASE REMIND ME IF I FORGOT ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE

Ps3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AAA, Score 4.5

Haze Hyped AA-AAA (the halo killer), Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AAA, Score 7.5

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9 (one tenth of a point!)

Uncharted+Folklore removed

Flops= 6 (maybe more)

360

Too Human, Hyped AA-AAA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.5

Blue Dragon Hyped AA, Score 6.0

Blue Dragon added

Flops=4 (maybe more)

SaintsRowSam

um...how can you say resistance and ratchet were flops :|

Look at it this way:

The PS3 has the most flops and less AAAE and up games.

The 360 has the most AAE & AAAE games and less flops.

I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.Ibacai

[QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.jg4xchamp

that game was good short but good

[QUOTE="zath5"]im a huge 360 fan boy but isnt flop a little harsh on like half of those ps3 games?? most of those are great gamesRob_101

Exactly. 360 has more bad games than PS3. Hour of Victory anyone?

your avatar makes my fakeboy meter go off the scale

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="Ibacai"]I guess the old thread should be drug up because Uncharted, Heavenly Sword, and Folklore are not flops. Their actually hype according to the threads were in the same tier. And you're missing Blue Dragon for the 360.Iceman2911

that game was good short but good

[QUOTE="GootHimp"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

[QUOTE="GootHimp"]By using gamerankings, you will eliminate half those ps3 games. like uncharted got what it hped Ninja-Hippo

and too human got AA on other sites, that means too human would be eliminated

nope lmao at too human. too human on gamerankings is around 65 right now. and it was hyped AA. uncharted is a 9 rite now on gr and it was hyped AAA

Too Human was no way hyped AA. It's possibly the most hated on game of this gen. :?

[QUOTE="Lionheart08"][QUOTE="SaintsRowSam"]

PLEASE REMIND ME IF I FORGOT ABOUT ANYTHING ELSE

Ps3

Resistance Hyped AAA, Score 8.6

Lair Hyped AAA, Score 4.5

Uncharted Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Haze Hyped AA-AAA (the halo killer), Score 6.0

Heavenly Sword Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Ratchet and Clank Hyped AAA, Score 7.5

Folklore Hyped AA, Score 7.0

Motorstorm Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.9 (one tenth of a point!)

Flops= 8 (maybe more)

360

Too Human, Hyped AA-AAA, Score 5.5

Ninja Gaiden 2 Hyped AAA, Score 8.0

Lost Odyssey Hyped AA-AAA, Score 7.5

Flops=3 (maybe more)

MassiveKaos

I don't recall R&C, Heavenly Sword, and Uncharted getting hyped AAA.:?

Moving on...

It depends, do we go by the cow defined flops, which change to avoid PS3 games flopping or the standard rules? If we go by the standard rules then the whole PS3 launch line up is a flop...AlphaGamer469

they played that one safe

[QUOTE="AlphaGamer469"] It depends, do we go by the cow defined flops, which change to avoid PS3 games flopping or the standard rules? If we go by the standard rules then the whole PS3 launch line up is a flop...surrealnumber5

they played that one safe

Neither was a PS3 launch title...

[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"]

[QUOTE="AlphaGamer469"] It depends, do we go by the cow defined flops, which change to avoid PS3 games flopping or the standard rules? If we go by the standard rules then the whole PS3 launch line up is a flop...AlphaGamer469

they played that one safe

Neither was a PS4 launch title...

[QUOTE="surrealnumber5"]

[QUOTE="AlphaGamer469"] It depends, do we go by the cow defined flops, which change to avoid PS3 games flopping or the standard rules? If we go by the standard rules then the whole PS3 launch line up is a flop...AlphaGamer469

they played that one safe

Neither was a PS3 launch title...

resistance wasn't a flop