Rage Vs. Killzone 3 : A Clash of Epic Proportions!

[QUOTE="i_am_interested"]

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Can't be bothered to create gifs, but if you insist... Give me 10 minutes. :)

WhenCicadasCry

dont get me wrong, im a fan of the megatexture system but thats all it is, detailed textures, which also happen look awful upclose which is why tim wilts never stops to look around indoors and instead constantly keeps moving

none of those textures outside are up close

Bleh, all the gifs I make are over 10mb and don't really feature much. :( Just watch the vids. :) I've noticed every seen in Killzone 3 which features tons of stuff going on inscreen at once is scripted, or onrails.

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

[QUOTE="i_am_interested"] good, i look forward to seeing those outdoor exploring gifs that display nothing more than the detailed megatexture landscape, you know where he just stands there outside looking that the amazing texture landscape

dont get me wrong, im a fan of the megatexture system but thats all it is, detailed textures, which also happen look awful upclose which is why tim wilts never stops to look around indoors and instead constantly keeps moving

none of those textures outside are up close

i_am_interested

Bleh, all the gifs I make are over 10mb and don't really feature much. :( Just watch the vids. :) I've noticed every seen in Killzone 3 which features tons of stuff going on inscreen at once is scripted, or onrails.

They're the only impressive scenes. :?

[QUOTE="i_am_interested"]

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Can't be bothered to create gifs, but if you insist... Give me 10 minutes. :)

WhenCicadasCry

dont get me wrong, im a fan of the megatexture system but thats all it is, detailed textures, which also happen look awful upclose which is why tim wilts never stops to look around indoors and instead constantly keeps moving

none of those textures outside are up close

Bleh, all the gifs I make are over 10mb and don't really feature much. :( Just watch the vids. :) I've noticed every seen in Killzone 3 which features tons of stuff going on inscreen at once is scripted, or onrails.

[QUOTE="i_am_interested"][QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Bleh, all the gifs I make are over 10mb and don't really feature much. :( Just watch the vids. :) I've noticed every seen in Killzone 3 which features tons of stuff going on inscreen at once is scripted, or onrails.

WhenCicadasCry

They're the only impressive scenes. :?

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

[QUOTE="i_am_interested"] ive seen the vids, im well aware of id tech 5 and its megatexture system yeah, theyre called set pieces, just like when giant buildings in crysis 2 fall downChutebox

They're the only impressive scenes. :?

Maybe I have high standards? They look great, but nothing to go crazy about. Rage and Crysis 2 are easily onpar.

[QUOTE="Chutebox"]

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

They're the only impressive scenes. :?

WhenCicadasCry

Maybe I have high standards? They look great, but nothing to go crazy about. Rage and Crysis 2 are easily onpar.

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

[QUOTE="Chutebox"] Check the gifs from page 7 near the bottom of the page. Only one of those are scripted and all of them are impressive. But I'm sure you'll pick something nonexistent to complain about.

Chutebox

Maybe I have high standards? They look great, but nothing to go crazy about. Rage and Crysis 2 are easily onpar.

SW Disagrees with you.

[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

Maybe I have high standards? They look great, but nothing to go crazy about. Rage and Crysis 2 are easily onpar.

WhenCicadasCry

SW Disagrees with you.

Technically Rage is up to Killzone 3, but Killzone 3 looks better visually.

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

[QUOTE="Chutebox"] On consoles, I disagree.Chutebox

SW Disagrees with you.

Couldn't careless about Rage. :lol: I just want a game on the 360 to look as good as PS3s exclusives for teh lolz. :P

[QUOTE="Chutebox"][QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

SW Disagrees with you.

WhenCicadasCry

Couldn't careless about Rage. :lol: I just want a game on the 360 to look as good as PS3s exclusives for teh lolz. :P

Well, I don't think we've seen one on par with KZ3...Maybe Ucharted 2, but I don't know. I need to see some real footage of Crysis 2, not the "360" version from e3 lol.

From a technical aspect, what id has done with Rage is nothing short of amazing, and obviously the game itself looks fantastic. KZ3 didn't impress me that much, but Crysis 2 did.

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"]hmm i wonder who wins. Bus-A-Bus

"To put it in an simple & contrite manner, the answer would be [Pulls out Riot Shield ] Rage…"

:D

Though God of War 3 is not a part of this thread, why is it that most people ignore ign's review where they say, at times, it is "the best-looking game ever" (under the graphics heading at the bottom). Do you think it would be far-fetched to say a game like Killzone 3, if it has a more consistent graphics engine, could be the best-looking game ever? Or will the Crysis series remain the front-runner in terms of graphics?

GeoW 3, Rage and Killzone 3 are all a year away and I think they will be the major nominees for Console Graphics King. The footage they showed at E3 for al three was like Pre-Alpha, any one of them can win at this point. I think Rage will be the one though, Killzone 3/GeoW 3 already had their engines built with the second installments and I don't think they will improve that significantly from their predecessors, all Epic/Guerilla can do is just add some more poish and set pieces.

Rage on the other hand seems to be the next step for consoles, the engine is developed by id Software and it can still be improved. I trust id to add more goodies that will push the hardware of 360/PS3 even further. I mean this is the first time we see an open world FPS running at 60 fps that has vehicles, different adapting AI and still manages to pull of graphics that are almost on par with the best out there. All the reviewers/media reporters that saw the game were literally staring at it, the game needs to be seen in motion to be appreciated. And I think everyone will be awed by it next year.

[QUOTE="WhenCicadasCry"]

[QUOTE="Chutebox"] They also agree that KZ3 looks better than Rage, so I guess you agree with that too, ya?Chutebox

Couldn't careless about Rage. :lol: I just want a game on the 360 to look as good as PS3s exclusives for teh lolz. :P

Well, I don't think we've seen one on par with KZ3...Maybe Ucharted 2, but I don't know. I need to see some real footage of Crysis 2, not the "360" version from e3 lol.

It was the 360 version.

Though God of War 3 is not a part of this thread, why is it that most people ignore ign's review where they say, at times, it is "the best-looking game ever" (under the graphics heading at the bottom). Do you think it would be far-fetched to say a game like Killzone 3, if it has a more consistent graphics engine, could be the best-looking game ever? Or will the Crysis series remain the front-runner in terms of graphics?

JMR09

You know that guy was fired after his God of War 3 review, I guess people didn't agree with him lol.

Both games look top-notch. Anybody saying one is substantially better looking than the other is probably biased.

Im sorry but Playstation unlimited???? So a site dedicated to the PS3 is putting a PS3 exclusive against two multiplats and we are suppose to await on some "unbiased" results?:lol: I would be very very suprised if KZ3 does not "win" at that place. Its like a poll here of anything Xbox verses PS3!:lol:

Decided I would throw a quick comparison together that consisted of more than links to a couple videos. This is my first time making anigifs, so sorry if they're not up to standard. Some are 10fps so some hit animations don't show through correctly. *Click pics for 720p. (56k warning!)

---

I know Rage is supposed to be open world, but so far it looks like a boring tube-run. (looking at the vid)

RAGE is starting to remind of Bioshock...

In screenshots I'd say KZ3, but in motion I have to give the nod to Rage cause of 60fps.

edit: dayum at those KZ3 gifs on page 7...might have to change my mind :o

Just my 2 cents.

am i crazy if i say Rage looks better, but halo reach looks better with it's art design and epic skyboxes? how can you do graphical comparisons of each game. each game has ups and downs look at killzone 3 Great gun models, bad textures, rage great textures, bad Gun models, every game has visual up and downs, so why make a comparison i mean reach has the most impressive skyboxes on any sytem( to me) but is there any graphical comparsons with crysis 2 No, play what you believe to look good. and to hell with these comparisons.

Umm... we will have to wait till the games come out...

People saying clearly Rage clearly didn't read the article or watch the footage. KZ3 is way more impressive, your personal art style taste doesn't change that.

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"]hmm i wonder who wins. Bus-A-Bus

"To put it in an simple & contrite manner, the answer would be [Pulls out Riot Shield ] Rage…"

:D

Well, if it's being done on a PS3 fanboy site, most likely KZ3 would win. On any other real, non-fanboy site, RAGE would win easily.

*********************************************************************************************

People saying clearly Rage clearly didn't read the article or watch the footage. KZ3 is way more impressive, your personal art style taste doesn't change that.

Mestitia

[QUOTE="Bus-A-Bus"]

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"]hmm i wonder who wins. blackace

"To put it in an simple & contrite manner, the answer would be [Pulls out Riot Shield ] Rage…"

:D

[QUOTE="Bus-A-Bus"]

[QUOTE="AAllxxjjnn"]

"To put it in an simple & contrite manner, the answer would be [Pulls out Riot Shield ] Rage…"

:D

blackace

Well, if it's being done on a PS3 fanboy site, most likely KZ3 would win. On any other real, non-fanboy site, RAGE would win easily.

*********************************************************************************************

People saying clearly Rage clearly didn't read the article or watch the footage. KZ3 is way more impressive, your personal art style taste doesn't change that.

Mestitia

I'm really going to have to agree with Mestitia and the article here. RAGE looked great, but it didn't feel 'alive' like Killzone 3 and Crysis 2 did. I don't know about you, but the world honestly felt a bit static. Beautiful, but static nonetheless.

Killzone 3 got the cell, now if they showed some PS3 footage of Rage, it might actually look better.

This is a joke thread right? Of course RAGE looks better...

This is a joke thread right? Of course RAGE looks better...

pelvist

[QUOTE="pelvist"]

This is a joke thread right? Of course RAGE looks better...

Mestitia

Maybe it's the id fanboy in me, but I like the visuals of Rage more than KZ3. I can't judge the gameplay, but from previews I'd have to take Rage as well.

[QUOTE="Mestitia"][QUOTE="pelvist"]

This is a joke thread right? Of course RAGE looks better...

T-razor1

How can anyone say anything looks better if there pre alpha...

How can anyone say anything looks better if there pre alpha...

Aboogie5

I guess you can if what you say pertains to which game looks better going by their current stages of development?

Seems easy enough to me. :)