Really... every G4 category...

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="tok1879"] I guess your standards must be really high, because everywhere i keep reading about people being wowed by it. And i was too. Anyway outta curiosity, what games do wow you?12345678ew

In no particular order

Age of empires

Star Craft

Diablo I/II

Halflife

Morrowind

Oblivion

Far Cry

Kotor

OOT

Counter Strike

Geow

WoW

TF2

Goldeneye

Perfect Dark

Doom I/II

Super Mario World

Final Fantasy

Crysis

+many many more

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

The burden of proof is on you.

789shadow

Lets me break it down for you, by your logic a runner's 1K time and a 1000HP custom racing automobiles 1K time are directly comparable.

Makes perfect sense...

Oh and find me a link saying they are not directly comparable, I will be waiting.

I'm still waiting for your link.

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] Please direct me to a link where they say all platforms scores are weighted equally.

htekemerald

The burden of proof is on you.

Lets me break it down for you, by your logic a runner's 1K time and a 1000HP custom racing automobiles 1K time are directly comparable.

Makes perfect sense...

Oh and find me a link saying they are not directly comparable, I will be waiting.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="KukicAdo"]U2 Is one of the best games this gen.Zero_epyon

actually, since the game is so cinematic, it was a bore playing through it again because you knew what was going to happen. I couldn't do it :/

but it was amazing the first time.

U2 Is one of the best games this gen.KukicAdo

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

Lets me break it down for you, by your logic a runner's 1K time and a 1000HP custom racing automobiles 1K time are directly comparable.

Makes perfect sense...

Oh and find me a link saying they are not directly comparable, I will be waiting.

I'm still waiting for your link.

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

Biased much?

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

I'm still waiting for your link.

nervmeister

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

this is just like the time GeOW was in practically everything in g4.

soiheardyoulike

The only difference being uncharted is actually a good game.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

I'm still waiting for your link.

nervmeister

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

[QUOTE="nervmeister"][QUOTE="htekemerald"] You say platforms do not have different standards therefore a game that is graphically perfect on say the DS looks as good as crysis. Comeback when you have an argument other than "give me an arbitrary link".

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

htekemerald

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

It's far superior only in opinion.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="nervmeister"] What about the multiplats shared between PC and consoles that scored the same amount? Are you honestly trying to suggest that the PC versions of those are in fact better than the console versions even though they have no major advantages in PC's favor?789shadow

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

It's far superior only in opinion.

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] No major advatages except playable framerates, decent resolutions, modability, better multiplayer, ect.

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

htekemerald

It's far superior only in opinion.

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

It's far superior only in opinion.

789shadow

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

[QUOTE="nervmeister"][QUOTE="htekemerald"] You say platforms do not have different standards therefore a game that is graphically perfect on say the DS looks as good as crysis. Comeback when you have an argument other than "give me an arbitrary link".

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] Sure :roll:

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

nervmeister

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] Sure :roll:

htekemerald

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

Oh, yeah, I forgot, consoles don't have those things.:roll:

[QUOTE="soiheardyoulike"]

this is just like the time GeOW was in practically everything in g4.

Sully28

The only difference being uncharted is actually a good game.

they're both incredible games actually :D

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="nervmeister"] What about the multiplats shared between PC and consoles that scored the same amount? Are you honestly trying to suggest that the PC versions of those are in fact better than the console versions even though they have no major advantages in PC's favor?789shadow

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

It's far superior only in opinion.

why not, Uncharted 2 is one of the best games ever made.InfiniteBlak

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

Please prove to me that the PC version is better. With facts this time.

789shadow

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

Oh, yeah, I forgot, consoles don't have those things.:roll:

if you think that is good. I advise you try PC gaming.

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] :roll:

Unless you hate games with a playable frame rate, a good resolution, mods, constant updates, and more the PC version is better.

htekemerald

Oh, yeah, I forgot, consoles don't have those things.:roll:

if you think that is good. I advise you try PC gaming.

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

Oh, yeah, I forgot, consoles don't have those things.:roll:

deangallop

if you think that is good. I advise you try PC gaming.

Uhhh, I'm going to let you work that one out yourself.

[QUOTE="InfiniteBlak"]why not, Uncharted 2 is one of the best games ever made.superapo

so your telling me that the story in u2 can be found exactly the same in another game, oh and btw there really hasnt been an "original" game since like what the 80's and even then those games were "copies" of the games that came before it

[QUOTE="deangallop"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] sub 720p and sub 30 fps

if you think that is good. I advise you try PC gaming.

htekemerald

Uhhh, I'm going to let you work that one out yourself.

No proof that the console version runs at 30 fps and the PC version runs at 60 fps, and while your at it you should find some gameplay footage of both that proves the PC version looks and plays better, that isnt asking very much , is it????

[QUOTE="deangallop"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] sub 720p and sub 30 fps

if you think that is good. I advise you try PC gaming.

htekemerald

Uhhh, I'm going to let you work that one out yourself.

why are people argueing with you when you clearly cant comprehend that fact is not the same thing as an opinion, if you cant work THAT one out yourself you shouldnt be telling that to other people

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="deangallop"] Here I'll ask again for you shadow... Where's the proof????

deangallop

Uhhh, I'm going to let you work that one out yourself.

No proof that the console version runs at 30 fps and the PC version runs at 60 fps, and while your at it you should find some gameplay footage of both that proves the PC version looks and plays better, that isnt asking very much , is it????

[QUOTE="superapo"]

why not, Uncharted 2 is one of the best games ever made.InfiniteBlak

so your telling me that the story in u2 can be found exactly the same in another game, oh and btw there really hasnt been an "original" game since like what the 80's and even then those games were "copies" of the games that came before it

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="deangallop"] Here I'll ask again for you shadow... Where's the proof????

hyperboy152000

Uhhh, I'm going to let you work that one out yourself.

why are people argueing with you when you clearly cant comprehend that fact is not the same thing as an opinion, if you cant work THAT one out yourself you shouldnt be telling that to other people

I must not have paid attention in school.

i had no idea people took the G4 gaming awards seriously. Didn't fable 2 win last years when it clearly didn't deserve it?lawlessx

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

Lets me break it down for you, by your logic a runner's 1K time and a 1000HP custom racing automobiles 1K time are directly comparable.

Makes perfect sense...

Oh and find me a link saying they are not directly comparable, I will be waiting.

htekemerald

I'm still waiting for your link.

Oh and the Burden of proof is on you. Give me a link which proves different. See what a good argument style that is!

[QUOTE="789shadow"]

[QUOTE="htekemerald"] No major advatages except playable framerates, decent resolutions, modability, better multiplayer, ect.

Take the orange box for example, far superior on the PC yet it got the same score as on a console.

seabiscuit8686

It's far superior only in opinion.

Metacritic PC score = 96

Metacritic 360 score = 96

Who's ignorant again? Or do I need to tell you the difference between fact and opinion?

[QUOTE="seabiscuit8686"][QUOTE="789shadow"]

It's far superior only in opinion.

789shadow

Metacritic PC score = 96

Metacritic 360 score = 96

Who's ignorant again? Or do I need to tell you the difference between fact and opinion?

Anyone else notice how Uncharted 2: Among Thieves was nominated for just about every category of the video game awards...

http://g4tv.com/thefeed/blog/post/701150/G4s-Best-of-2009----The-Nominees-Are.html

Renzokucant

[QUOTE="seabiscuit8686"][QUOTE="789shadow"]

It's far superior only in opinion.

789shadow

Metacritic PC score = 96

Metacritic 360 score = 96

Who's ignorant again? Or do I need to tell you the difference between fact and opinion?

This doesn't help your argument at all. If anything he is stating the fact and you are giving the opinion, of course if you don't believe me ask yourself one thing...how's the class updates on the 360 version of TF2 going?

It will win everything. Even best Racing Game.Floppy_Jim

Yeah the part with the trucks blowing up on the mountain side was on the the best racers I've ever played. Elana was so close to winning but then that guy with the Rocket Launcher...

well its kind of hard to argue that uncharted 2 didnt have the best of everything. best story? hell ya. best animation? bar-none. best voice acting? the best. best action adventure? no ****. best soundtrack? its up there. best multiplayer? top 5. best graphics? dont get me started. i can go on and on

Revolution316

[QUOTE="htekemerald"]

[QUOTE="PBSnipes"]

Whoops.

RadecSupreme

I have the game on PC and its a very cool game but voice acting sucks. Especially in the beginning if you start off as a human noble.

reminds me of MGS4 almost sweeping the major awards here in GS. :P

reminds me of MGS4 almost sweeping the major awards here in GS. :P

___gamemaster__

Despite everything I still can't believe they gave graphics to it over Crysis Warhead...

Are the posters in this thread serious? You guys got to be kidding me, ic why I barely visit this section anymore... UC2 is NOMINATED, it hasnt won every category n it rightly so is NOMINATED. You guys got to be kidding me when youre saying oh DA wins soundtrack of the year or voice acting, uncharted is a worse bla bla bla.. GUESS WHAT? UC2 HASNT WON AND ITS ONLY NOMINATED, IF UC2 WON THOSE CATEGORIES THAT YOU GUYS CLAIM DA IS BETTER THAN I WOULD SEE A REASON FOR YALL TO BE UPSET ( which in the first place uncharted puts up a fight).

ALMOST every aspect of uc2 is top 3 in any category it is put up. SO WHEN A GAME IS ONE OF THE BEST IN A CATEGORY, REGARDLESS IF ITS THE BEST, WHAT HAPPENS? IT IS PUT UP AS A NOMINATION JUST LIKE UC2 HAS BEEN.

/rant you people lack logic sometimes.

Edit: Ic the reasons why you guys are upset n are jealous, because ur fav games havnt been nominated n some of them should be... guess what though? ITs not UC2 fault since that game deserves to be in the nominations but you should take out ur rantin on one of the other games in those categories since UC2 is always top 3 or so.