Seeing as Uncharted 2 and Brutal Legend are comming out in the same day...

[QUOTE="Dead-Memories"][QUOTE="Revolution316"]never put brutal legend and uncharted 2 in the same sentence. its very degradingRevolution316

[QUOTE="StealthMonkey4"]

[QUOTE="enterawesome"]I'm NOT trying to tick others off. I COULD CARE LESS ABOUT UNCHARTED 2. The only reason I might ever be mad at this game is because Naughty Dog is doing this and leaving poor Jak and Daxter in the dust. :xenterawesome

You should know that saying an exclusive game can "SMB" in SW is going to tick people off, you're not level 1 and you're not new to system wars. Also instead of leaving a childish comment about a game and just leaving it at that, you could offer constructive criticism as to why you think it's bad. Also, Jak and Daxter is going to have a sequel on PSP so it's not completely forgot about. :D

Your opinion seems very uninformed, have you actually played the game (first Uncharted)? Regardless, I'm not saying to change your opinion I just said it would of been better and made you not look uninformed and childish if you had put a more well constructed response than telling a game to "SMB", but I can understand as fanboys do ten to get up in arms over the slightest thing.

Stop being ignorant, Brutal Legend has Multiplayer. All of the critics are impressed by it. It has been in developement longer than the SP has.SparkyProtocol

[QUOTE="enterawesome"]

[QUOTE="StealthMonkey4"]

You should know that saying an exclusive game can "SMB" in SW is going to tick people off, you're not level 1 and you're not new to system wars. Also instead of leaving a childish comment about a game and just leaving it at that, you could offer constructive criticism as to why you think it's bad. Also, Jak and Daxter is going to have a sequel on PSP so it's not completely forgot about. :D

Your opinion seems very uninformed, have you actually played the game (first Uncharted)? Regardless, I'm not saying to change your opinion I just said it would of been better and made you not look uninformed and childish if you had put a more well constructed response than telling a game to "SMB", but I can understand as fanboys do ten to get up in arms over the slightest thing.

[QUOTE="SparkyProtocol"]Stop being ignorant, Brutal Legend has Multiplayer. All of the critics are impressed by it. It has been in developement longer than the SP has.Revolution316

[QUOTE="Revolution316"][QUOTE="Dead-Memories"] Should probably do your research before saying such things :| SAGE_OF_FIRE

If the game is as good as your stating, why hasn't it recieved as many awards as uncharted?

[QUOTE="SparkyProtocol"]Stop being ignorant, Brutal Legend has Multiplayer. All of the critics are impressed by it. It has been in developement longer than the SP has.Revolution316

[QUOTE="StealthMonkey4"]

[QUOTE="enterawesome"]No, I honestly did not consider how other people would react to my opinion. I'm not going to shape it in a way that won't offend them, I going to speak my mind however I want. Also, yes, I'm not new at Gamespot, so I know that however I say I don't like or care about Uncharted 2 is going to piss people off in one way or another. If you want to know why I'm not interested, you should have just said so. :) In which case, I don't care because: The graphics are creepy and downright disturbing. Its like Polar Express how it looks really real, but yet, it doesn't. Multiplayer is.... just a shooter multiplayer. Nothing more nor less, just... that. As for story (this really isn't an informed opinion, I haven't had the time to indulge myself in Uncharted lore) and gameplay it looks like a mutated cross breed between James Bond and Indiana Jones, and just ripping elements off from both and molding it into a crappy Gears of War/Tomb Raider game, but instead of blending the two, it just copy and pastes elements from both. There. I suggest we all hype other great PS3 exclusives instead, like GT5 and God of War 3 now.

enterawesome

Your opinion seems very uninformed, have you actually played the game (first Uncharted)? Regardless, I'm not saying to change your opinion I just said it would of been better and made you not look uninformed and childish if you had put a more well constructed response than telling a game to "SMB", but I can understand as fanboys do ten to get up in arms over the slightest thing.

I suggest you give it more of a chance, it is a really good game. :D, Also it actually does in my opinion bring something new to the table. 3rd person, cover, and platforming, and stealth are rarely used together in a game. If anything I'd say this has brought new things to multiplayer than many past games, what multiplayer games do you play? I don't really get you're part about the story, I found it good and easy to follow, and it still explained everything. Also about the graphics, I don't really know what to say, it looks like most other realistic games on the market. :?

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"][QUOTE="Revolution316"]my research?....ok...uncharted 2: won the most awards ever on E3, game of the show, best graphics, hyped as GOTY, developed by noughty dog, a huge blockbuster title....compared to a game thats just rock n roll, hit ppl with ur guitar so on an so on......WiiMan21

If the game is as good as your stating, why hasn't it recieved as many awards as uncharted?

:| :| :| :| :| :| :| :| :|

[QUOTE="BPoole96"]

Easily Uncharted 2. I don't really get the attraction of Brutal Legend anyway. It has Jack Black's voice in it. C'mon! Jack Black!?!?? No thank you

SAGE_OF_FIRE

But it's also Jack Black. He has never been apart of anything that was good (IMO). I mean, did you see Year One? HORRIBLE!!!! Watching Jack Black trying to be funny in that was overwhelming and exhausting. I don't need him bringing that to video games

[QUOTE="Revolution316"][QUOTE="SparkyProtocol"]Stop being ignorant, Brutal Legend has Multiplayer. All of the critics are impressed by it. It has been in developement longer than the SP has.enterawesome

I'm not a metal fan nor a jack black fan really so Uncharted 2 all the way. The first was my GOTY in 07 and this will probably be my GOTY in 09. Can't wait for it to come out.

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"][QUOTE="BPoole96"]

Easily Uncharted 2. I don't really get the attraction of Brutal Legend anyway. It has Jack Black's voice in it. C'mon! Jack Black!?!?? No thank you

BPoole96

But it's also Jack Black. He has never been apart of anything that was good (IMO). I mean, did you see Year One? HORRIBLE!!!! Watching Jack Black trying to be funny in that was overwhelming and exhausting. I don't need him bringing that to video games

NO! nu, NOOooooo! Its Tim Schafer... he has never made a bad game and this one looks just as good as the ones before. SAGE_OF_FIRE

But it's also Jack Black. He has never been apart of anything that was good (IMO). I mean, did you see Year One? HORRIBLE!!!! Watching Jack Black trying to be funny in that was overwhelming and exhausting. I don't need him bringing that to video games

[QUOTE="WiiMan21"]

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"] Yet every game Tim Schafer has made has been 100x better then Uncharted, and... Grim Fandango is one of the top contenders for best game of all time. :| don't hate on my timmy SAGE_OF_FIRE

If the game is as good as your stating, why hasn't it recieved as many awards as uncharted?

:| :| :| :| :| :| :| :| :|

Alright from what I see

Uncharted 2: Among Theives:

-Best of Show

-Best Console game

-Best Action/Adventure game

-Best Online multiplayer game

Brual Legend:

-Best of Show

-Best Orginial game

-Best Action/Adventure game

-Best Console game

Tied.

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"][QUOTE="BPoole96"]

But it's also Jack Black. He has never been apart of anything that was good (IMO). I mean, did you see Year One? HORRIBLE!!!! Watching Jack Black trying to be funny in that was overwhelming and exhausting. I don't need him bringing that to video games

SparkyProtocol

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"]

[QUOTE="WiiMan21"]

If the game is as good as your stating, why hasn't it recieved as many awards as uncharted?

WiiMan21

:| :| :| :| :| :| :| :| :|

Alright from what I see

Uncharted 2: Among Theives:

-Best of Show

-Best Console game

-Best Action/Adventure game

-Best Online multiplayer game

Brual Legend:

-Best of Show

-Best Orginial game

-Best Action/Adventure game

Very close with Brutal legend with one less award then Uncharted 2.

[QUOTE="enterawesome"][QUOTE="StealthMonkey4"]

Your opinion seems very uninformed, have you actually played the game (first Uncharted)? Regardless, I'm not saying to change your opinion I just said it would of been better and made you not look uninformed and childish if you had put a more well constructed response than telling a game to "SMB", but I can understand as fanboys do ten to get up in arms over the slightest thing.

I suggest you give it more of a chance, it is a really good game. :D, Also it actually does in my opinion bring something new to the table. 3rd person, cover, and platforming, and stealth are rarely used together in a game. If anything I'd say this has brought new things to multiplayer than many past games, what multiplayer games do you play? I don't really get you're part about the story, I found it good and easy to follow, and it still explained everything. Also about the graphics, I don't really know what to say, it looks like most other realistic games on the market. :?

[QUOTE="WiiMan21"]

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"] http://www.kotaku.com.au/2009/06/and-the-game-critics-best-of-e3-2009-award-nominees-are/

:| :| :| :| :| :| :| :| :|

SAGE_OF_FIRE

Alright from what I see

Uncharted 2: Among Theives:

-Best of Show

-Best Console game

-Best Action/Adventure game

-Best Online multiplayer game

Brual Legend:

-Best of Show

-Best Orginial game

-Best Action/Adventure game

Very close with Brutal legend with one less award then Uncharted 2.

My bad I didn't see that one, I edited my post.

[QUOTE="enterawesome"][QUOTE="Revolution316"]sooo? it still wont come close to uncharted 2....i see it getting AARevolution316

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"][QUOTE="WiiMan21"]

Alright from what I see

Uncharted 2: Among Theives:

-Best of Show

-Best Console game

-Best Action/Adventure game

-Best Online multiplayer game

Brual Legend:

-Best of Show

-Best Orginial game

-Best Action/Adventure game

Very close with Brutal legend with one less award then Uncharted 2.

WiiMan21

My bad I didn't see that one, I edited my post.

Uncharted 2, easily.

As shallow as this might be, I absolutely hate Jack Black. If it wasn't for him I'd be interested in BL.

[QUOTE="SparkyProtocol"][QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"] He's only a voice actor and was good in Tropic Thunder SAGE_OF_FIRE

I'll give him King Kong, but that was because he had a more serious role. Anything else I've seen him in was garbage. That's only my opinion though. It's the main reason I'm not getting the game

Uncharted 2, I'll probably pick up Brutal Legend later.

Brutal Legend (and I have a PS3).

So much bad taste in this thread. :P (Not so much a comment on the lovers as the haters.)

Uncharted 2. Brutal Legend seems way overhyped, but we'll see.

I'm going to be an individual here and say Uncharted 2

[QUOTE="WiiMan21"]

[QUOTE="SAGE_OF_FIRE"] Yet every game Tim Schafer has made has been 100x better then Uncharted, and... Grim Fandango is one of the top contenders for best game of all time. :| don't hate on my timmy SAGE_OF_FIRE

If the game is as good as your stating, why hasn't it recieved as many awards as uncharted?

:| :| :| :| :| :| :| :| :|

Those aren't awards won, those are nominations received. Among the actual winners, Brutal Legend won 0 awards, and Uncharted got 3 (2 of them beating out Brutal Legend). As much I I'm looking forward to Brutal Legend, these are the facts, and though I feel "meh" toward Uncharted if only because of my limited funds and free time), it looks to be a stand-up game too.

Why choose?

I'm buying both on Day One. :D

Going by this thread though, it looks like Tim Schafer is going to have another flop commercially. That man can not get a break.

I haven't decided what I will play first though.

Why choose?

I'm buying both on Day One. :D

Going by this thread though, it looks like Tim Schafer is going to have another flop commercially. That man can not get a break.

I haven't decided what I will play first though.

Why choose?

I'm buying both on Day One. :D

Going by this thread though, it looks like Tim Schafer is going to have another flop commercially. That man can not get a break.

I haven't decided what I will play first though.

Maxyboy13

He should've put explosions on the box art.

[QUOTE="SparkyProtocol"]Stop being ignorant, Brutal Legend has Multiplayer. All of the critics are impressed by it. It has been in developement longer than the SP has.Revolution316

[QUOTE="Maxyboy13"]

Why choose?

I'm buying both on Day One. :D

Going by this thread though, it looks like Tim Schafer is going to have another flop commercially. That man can not get a break.

I haven't decided what I will play first though.

MischiefmAker

He should've put explosions on the box art.

Or a generic Space Marine. :shock:

1,000,000+ sales confirmed. :P....:cry:

LOL @ these games games. i remember putting games like duke nukem time to kill on reserve, back in 1998, yea i was hyped for cool games like that. uncharted 2 and brutal legends i could give a damn about lolzlolatvideogames

[QUOTE="MischiefmAker"]

[QUOTE="Maxyboy13"]

Why choose?

I'm buying both on Day One. :D

Going by this thread though, it looks like Tim Schafer is going to have another flop commercially. That man can not get a break.

I haven't decided what I will play first though.

Maxyboy13

He should've put explosions on the box art.

Or a generic Space Marine. :shock:

1,000,000+ sales confirmed. :P....:cry:

Really, Tim should have known better. After all, he himself acknowledges that his best selling game, Full Throttle, had an explosion on the cover!