So it's Official, this was the year of

not the PS3. 360 had more AAAs. Wii had a AAAA. Even the major Sony supporters will have a hard time making the argument for the PS3 this year.

Highlights:

360:

Halo Reach 9.5

Mass Effect 2 9.0

Alan Wake 8.5

Dance Central 8.5

PS3:

God Of War 3 9.0

Heavy Rain 8.5

GT5 8.0

MAG 8.0

PC:
StarCraft 2 9.5

Super Meat Boy 9.5

Mass Effect 2 9.0

Football Manager 2 8.5

Wii:
SMG 10.0

DKCR 8.5

Goldeneye 8.5

Kirby 8.5

Year of the PS3... AGAIN!

Search your feelings, you know it to be true :twisted:

I don't care who's year it was. I don't get any money from it.

The 360 and PS3 both got owned this year by the Wii and PC. PS3 especially so this fall. lolStevo_the_gamer

Year of the PS3... AGAIN!

Search your feelings, you know it to be true :twisted:

FragTycoon

[QUOTE="FragTycoon"]

Year of the PS3... AGAIN!

Search your feelings, you know it to be true :twisted:

themyth01

I don't care who's year it was. I don't get any money from it.

4_Horsemen

hahaha, yeah, you just lose money.

its been the year of the flop all round :P

There's no official winner. We can't play numbers even if those numbers are a number of letters.

Dance Central could be AAAAAAAAAE and it'd still a piece of **** to me.

Yeah, that just my opinion but yours is just that as well TC.

[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="FragTycoon"]

Year of the PS3... AGAIN!

Search your feelings, you know it to be true :twisted:

Cherokee_Jack

360 Wins there too: 9.5 > 9.0. Only AAAE PS3 has had this year was GoW3, 360 had Reach. So not even that. Heck if you include, XLIVE titles, 360 has had more AAAEs too. 360 just did better this year with quality games in general, that is the most important metric.

its been the year of the flop all round :P

razgriz_101

I second this.

Every console has had some serious flops this year.

its been the year of the flop all round :P

razgriz_101

There's no official winner. We can't play numbers even if those numbers are a number of letters.

Dance Central could be AAAAAAAAAE and it'd still a piece of **** to me.

Yeah, that just my opinion but yours is just that as well TC.

Filthybastrd

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"][QUOTE="themyth01"] Like I said, tough to make an argument for it. 360 had more AAAs than PS3. I guess the only metric where PS3 would win this year would be by how many people in here would vote for it. themyth01

360 Wins there too: 9.5 > 9.0. Only AAAE PS3 has had this year was GoW3, 360 had Reach. So not even that. Heck if you include, XLIVE titles, 360 has had more AAAEs too. 360 just did better this year with quality games in general, that is the most important metric.

8.0+ 360 exclusives in 2010:

Halo Reach

Dance Central

Alan Wake

Deathsmiles

8.0+ PS3 exclusives in 2010:

God of War III

Gran Turismo 5

ModNation Racers

Yakuza 3

MLB 10: The Show

Heavy Rain

MAG

Counting only AAAs and saying 9.5>9.0 is all well and good, but the PS3 still pretty clearly had more quality exclusives this year.

[QUOTE="Filthybastrd"]

There's no official winner. We can't play numbers even if those numbers are a number of letters.

Dance Central could be AAAAAAAAAE and it'd still a piece of **** to me.

Yeah, that just my opinion but yours is just that as well TC.

themyth01

That's why I mentioned that we can't numbers. If those highly rated games are products such as Dance Central and GT5 then the scores become moot to me.

As I also mentioned, that's just my opinion but everyone has one so we're stuck with voting, which is also inaccurate.

Edit: SW version:

Halo + Kinect is what 360 offered this year, a clear loser to me fx. The Wii always manages to underwhelm me, even with it's very highly rated games and I can't even think up a ps3 line-up right now.

If anything I'd say the PC won with SC2 + superior multiplats but I don't want to bring fuel to an as of yet unlit fire + it's just my opinion.

[QUOTE="razgriz_101"]

its been the year of the flop all round :P

Stevo_the_gamer

and i love a few of those games aswell despite their short comings :'( doesthis make me a bad person :(

Crackdown 2 was a riot when we were drunk at my mates passing the pad was just so much of a laugh,fo needs more work and a decent patch and well gt is gt xD.

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"] Or high-scoring exclusives.Cherokee_Jack

360 Wins there too: 9.5 > 9.0. Only AAAE PS3 has had this year was GoW3, 360 had Reach. So not even that. Heck if you include, XLIVE titles, 360 has had more AAAEs too. 360 just did better this year with quality games in general, that is the most important metric.

8.0+ 360 exclusives in 2010:

Halo Reach9.5

Dance Central

Alan Wake

Deathsmiles

8.0+ PS3 exclusives in 2010:

God of War III 9.0

Gran Turismo 5 8.0

ModNation Racers

Yakuza 3

MLB 10: The Show

Heavy Rain

MAG

Counting only AAAs and saying 9.5>9.0 is all well and good, but the PS3 still pretty clearly had more quality exclusives this year.

It's about quality, not quantity. If we count all games though then you'd have to add:

Splinter Cell: Conviction

Mass Effect 2

leaving the PS3 looking worse still. I guess you could say PS3 had more AAEs but 360 had more AAAs.

lets just all agree that PC kicked every1s A********

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

360 Wins there too: 9.5 > 9.0. Only AAAE PS3 has had this year was GoW3, 360 had Reach. So not even that. Heck if you include, XLIVE titles, 360 has had more AAAEs too. 360 just did better this year with quality games in general, that is the most important metric.

8.0+ 360 exclusives in 2010:

Halo Reach9.5

Dance Central

Alan Wake

Deathsmiles

8.0+ PS3 exclusives in 2010:

God of War III 9.0

Gran Turismo 5 8.0

ModNation Racers

Yakuza 3

MLB 10: The Show

Heavy Rain

MAG

Counting only AAAs and saying 9.5>9.0 is all well and good, but the PS3 still pretty clearly had more quality exclusives this year.

It's about quality, not quantity. If we count all games though then you'd have to add:

Splinter Cell: Conviction

Mass Effect 2

leaving the PS3 looking worse still. I guess you could say PS3 had more AAEs but 360 had more AAAs.

[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="Filthybastrd"]

There's no official winner. We can't play numbers even if those numbers are a number of letters.

Dance Central could be AAAAAAAAAE and it'd still a piece of **** to me.

Yeah, that just my opinion but yours is just that as well TC.

Filthybastrd

That's why I mentioned that we can't numbers. If those highly rated games are products such as Dance Central and GT5 then the scores become moot to me.

As I also mentioned, that's just my opinion but everyone has one so we're stuck with voting, which is also inaccurate.

We can't numbers?? :? What's that suppose to mean? We've always judge on GS scores exactly to avoid conflicting opinions. Voting only shows which system has more fanboys, we all know the PS3 does, this is no popularity contest. Or are we doing away with GS scores now, because they were widely used last year, and every time a PS3 gets a good score :roll:

It's about quality, not quantity.

themyth01

Except the PS3 had quality and quantity as well.

And the Wii and PC stomped them both.

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"]

8.0+ 360 exclusives in 2010:

Halo Reach9.5

Dance Central

Alan Wake

Deathsmiles

8.0+ PS3 exclusives in 2010:

God of War III 9.0

Gran Turismo 5 8.0

ModNation Racers

Yakuza 3

MLB 10: The Show

Heavy Rain

MAG

Counting only AAAs and saying 9.5>9.0 is all well and good, but the PS3 still pretty clearly had more quality exclusives this year.

sonofsmeagle

It's about quality, not quantity. If we count all games though then you'd have to add:

Splinter Cell: Conviction

Mass Effect 2

leaving the PS3 looking worse still. I guess you could say PS3 had more AAEs but 360 had more AAAs.

And MLB 10 is on the PS2 and PSP, but they're not on the other platform. Of course, we judge libraries by the games on the system, in that regards undoubtedly the 360 outdid the PS3.

[QUOTE="themyth01"]Cool story.

Except the PS3 had quality and quantity as well.

And the Wii and PC stomped them both.

shinrabanshou

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

It's about quality, not quantity.

shinrabanshou

Except the PS3 had quality and quantity as well.

And the Wii and PC stomped them both.

[QUOTE="razgriz_101"]

its been the year of the flop all round :P

Stevo_the_gamer

I thought Heavy Rain didn't flop according to its hype thread?

Except 360 had more AAAs... :roll:themyth01

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"] [QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

It's about quality, not quantity.

themyth01

Except the PS3 had quality and quantity as well.

And the Wii and PC stomped them both.

Only reach scored 9.5 what are the others exclusive that got 9.0 here

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="razgriz_101"]

its been the year of the flop all round :P

Gxgear

I thought Heavy Rain didn't flop according to its hype thread?

People were crossing their fingers for a 9/10, but I don't think anyone could picture Heavy Rain getting anything higher than that. You are right though, people were basically hyping the game anywhere from an 8-9.

[QUOTE="themyth01"]Except 360 had more AAAs... :roll:shinrabanshou

I thought Heavy Rain didn't flop according to its hype thread?

Gxgear

[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]Cool story.

Except the PS3 had quality and quantity as well.

And the Wii and PC stomped them both.

badtaker

Only reach scored 9.5 what are the others exclusive that got 9.0 here

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"]Except 360 had more AAAs... :roll:themyth01

It's about quality, not quantity. If we count all games though then you'd have to add:
Splinter Cell: Conviction

Mass Effect 2

leaving the PS3 looking worse still. I guess you could say PS3 had more AAEs but 360 had more AAAs.themyth01

It's about quality and quantity, and we were talking about exclusives so ME2 and SCC are irrelevant.

Really, if you go by GS scores it's pretty much a fact that the PS3 has more high-quality exclusives than the 360 this year. The only way you can argue for the 360 winning is to count up multiplats, or say that it wins instantly by having Reach.

Also Super Meat Boy is out on PC as of today, so no longer exclusive even as a download.

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"]Except 360 had more AAAs... :roll:themyth01

Also fixed. While the PC had an extra AAAE and about 8 extra AAEs. And the Wii had an AAAAE and an extra 12 AAEs.

[QUOTE="themyth01"]It's about quality, not quantity. If we count all games though then you'd have to add:
Splinter Cell: Conviction

Mass Effect 2

leaving the PS3 looking worse still. I guess you could say PS3 had more AAEs but 360 had more AAAs.Cherokee_Jack

It's about quality and quantity, and we were talking about exclusives so ME2 and SCC are irrelevant.

Really, if you go by GS scores it's pretty much a fact that the PS3 has more high-quality exclusives than the 360 this year. The only way you can argue for the 360 winning is to count up multiplats, or say that it wins instantly by having Reach.

If you go by GS scores, 360 still managed more quality exclusives. If you count all games, 360 has more quality. Like I said, whatever you count games wise 360 comes on top this year by GS.

[QUOTE="Filthybastrd"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"] That's why I'm using GS scores rather than your or my opinion, we're in GS you should know how things work around here by now. themyth01

That's why I mentioned that we can't numbers. If those highly rated games are products such as Dance Central and GT5 then the scores become moot to me.

As I also mentioned, that's just my opinion but everyone has one so we're stuck with voting, which is also inaccurate.

We can't numbers?? :? What's that suppose to mean? We've always judge on GS scores exactly to avoid conflicting opinions. Voting only shows which system has more fanboys, we all know the PS3 does, this is no popularity contest. Or are we doing away with GS scores now, because they were widely used last year, and every time a PS3 gets a good score :roll:

You just decided for yourself that AA games are'nt good enough to count so this thread is already dilluted by your arbitrary rules. You're clearly just setting up an anti Sony thread. But congratulations on spotting a missing word in my post :roll:

[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]While the PC, PS3 and Wii had a greater quantity of high quality exclusives. So yeah, cool story.

shinrabanshou

Also fixed. While the PC had an extra AAAE and about 8 extra AAEs. And the Wii had an AAAAE and an extra 12 AAEs.

Fixed. Shouldn't count MLB since you're playing the AAE game.

If you go by GS scores, 360 still managed more quality exclusives.themyth01

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

[QUOTE="Filthybastrd"]

That's why I mentioned that we can't numbers. If those highly rated games are products such as Dance Central and GT5 then the scores become moot to me.

As I also mentioned, that's just my opinion but everyone has one so we're stuck with voting, which is also inaccurate.

Filthybastrd

We can't numbers?? :? What's that suppose to mean? We've always judge on GS scores exactly to avoid conflicting opinions. Voting only shows which system has more fanboys, we all know the PS3 does, this is no popularity contest. Or are we doing away with GS scores now, because they were widely used last year, and every time a PS3 gets a good score :roll:

You just decided for yourself that AA games are'nt good enough to count so this thread is already dilluted by your arbitrary rules. You're clearly just setting up an anti Sony thread. But congratulations on spotting a missing word in my post :roll:

Where the hell did that happen? Add up all the scores of not just AA but A too, and see what comes on top between PS3 and 360: *hint* 360

[QUOTE="themyth01"]If you go by GS scores, 360 still managed more quality exclusives.Cherokee_Jack

360 has more quality titles according to GS for the year of 2010, are you saying otherwise?

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]

[QUOTE="themyth01"] So 360 had more quality games, and PS3 had 1more AAEs and 360 has 1 more AAAE, ok whatever works for you. I think that means 360 won the year since we use number of AAAs but cool story. themyth01

Also fixed. While the PC had an extra AAAE and about 8 extra AAEs. And the Wii had an AAAAE and an extra 12 AAEs.

Fixed. Shouldn't count MLB since you're playing the AAE game.

360:

Halo: Reach - 9.5
Dance Central - 8.5
Alan Wake - 8.5
DeathSmiles - 8.0

PS3:

God of War III - 9.0
Heavy Rain - 8.5
Gran Turismo 5 - 8.0
ModNation Racers - 8.0
Yakuza 3 - 8.0
MLB '10: The Show - 8.0
MAG - 8.0

MLB '10 is an exclusive in the metagame. Oh Snap. Work on your math.

Edit: And for good measure...

PC:

Starcraft II: Wings of Liberty - 9.5
Sid Meier's Civilization V - 9.0
Football Manager 2011 - 8.5
Napoleon: Total War – 8.5
Warhammer 40,000: Dawn of War II – Chaos Rising – 8.5
ArmA II: Operation Arrowhead – 8.5
Age of Conan: Rise of the Godslayer – 8.5
Amnesia: The Dark Descent - 8.5
The Sims 3: Ambitions – 8.0
Tropico 3: Absolute Power – 8.0
STALKER: Call of Priyapat – 8.0
King's Bounty: Armored Princess – 8.0
King's Bounty: Crossworlds - 8.0

Wii:

Super Mario Galaxy 2 - 10.0
Donkey Kong Country Returns - 8.5
No More Heroes 2: Desperate Struggle - 8.5
Tatsunoko vs Capcom: Ultimate All Stars - 8.5
Sin and Punishment: Star Successor - 8.5
Metroid: Other M - 8.5
Kirby's Epic Yarn - 8.5
GoldenEye 007 - 8.5
Trauma Team - 8.0
Monster Hunter Tri - 8.0
Endless Ocean: Blue World - 8.0
Wii Party - 8.0
NHL Slapshot - 8.0
Sonic Colors - 8.0

[QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"][QUOTE="themyth01"]If you go by GS scores, 360 still managed more quality exclusives.themyth01

[QUOTE="themyth01"]

[QUOTE="shinrabanshou"]I didn't read that in the System Wars Officially Licenced Handbook.

Also fixed. While the PC had an extra AAAE and about 8 extra AAEs. And the Wii had an AAAAE and an extra 12 AAEs.

shinrabanshou

Fixed. Shouldn't count MLB since you're playing the AAE game.

Halo: Reach - 9.5
Dance Central - 8.5
Alan Wake - 8.5
DeathSmiles - 8.0

God of War III - 9.0
Heavy Rain - 8.5
Gran Turismo 5 - 8.0
ModNation Racers - 8.0
Yakuza 3 - 8.0
MAG - 8.0

MLB '10 is an exclusive in the metagame. Oh Snap. Work on your math.

MLB is also on PS2 and PSP.

You should check this website more throughly.

You should check this website more throughly.

themyth01

Shouldn't have bothered with this thread beyond my initial Cool Story.

[QUOTE="themyth01"][QUOTE="Cherokee_Jack"] How? Count them out.Cherokee_Jack

I'm wondering why you left Limbo out. I take it you counted MLB 10 for PS3 even if it's on PS2 and PSP?!

But alas, best year goes to the system with better games overall, not just exclusives, so I'll leave the exclusive only at that and go back to the main topic. Best system of the year:

# of AAAs:

360

PC

Wii

PS3

# of AAs:

Wii

360

PC

PS3

I'm sure you can begin to see the pattern.