The best Zelda game of all time is...?

Lots of different opinions. Shows how much depth the franchise has.

I am going with Link to the Past. I have far too many warm memories of that game, even more so than OoT (though this was also an excellent game).

What's with all this praise A Link To The Past is getting, i would have guessed it had such a depth that it would put most games to shame or something. I thought it was a simple top down action-adventure game with a standard simple story. How's the story? How's the gameplay? I never played this also (god damn!), but i'm not gonna miss out on it if its worth it.

Lucianu

for me its like this

1.OOT

2.A Link to the Past

3.Windwaker

4.The Legend of Zelda

5.Majora's Mask

[QUOTE="Lucianu"]

What's with all this praise A Link To The Past is getting, i would have guessed it had such a depth that it would put most games to shame or something. I thought it was a simple top down action-adventure game with a standard simple story. How's the story? How's the gameplay? I never played this also (god damn!), but i'm not gonna miss out on it if its worth it.

charizard1605

i remember waking up early on weekends to play it when i was a kid, definitely one of those games that made me love gaming

Ocarina of Time. Best game ever made

U mad Chaz? :P

U mad Chaz? :P

Arach666

I enjoyed Wind Waker the most, Twilight Princess the least. I dont understand how people like TP so much, it was lacking in so may areas.

Scythes777

It probably has the best dungeons in the entire series.

Anyways, Phantom Hourglass is the best Zelda

[QUOTE="Arach666"]

U mad Chaz? :P

charizard1605

Yeah,it´s that awesome!

Majora's Mask, the story was more darker and fleshed out. The villian was new and had more of a character than just being pure evil, the use of the masks was fun and interesting, and the world was new and fun to explore.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="locopatho"] 2D Zelda fo life ;)AmayaPapaya

If your looking for just fun in your Zelda games, Ninty said that SS is going to focus less on story and dungeons, and more on "fun."

Wow. This would definitely suck, please tell me Nintendo didnt say that.

Objectively, I think it comes down to a three way brawl between A Link to the Past, Ocarina of Time, and Majora's Mask.

Personally, I'd give it to Ocarina. Playing Ocarina for the first time was experiencing something truly exceptional. Very few games have made me feel that way.

[QUOTE="Scythes777"]

I enjoyed Wind Waker the most, Twilight Princess the least. I dont understand how people like TP so much, it was lacking in so may areas.

bobcheeseball

It probably has the best dungeons in the entire series.

Anyways, Phantom Hourglass is the best Zelda

The dungeons were possibly the best in the series. However, I never really enjoy the dungeons in Zelda games. TP didnt really do anything else as good as the previous games.

Edit: Also, I really enjoyed PH, much more than ST.

Really tough call between Wind Waker and OoT, but I liked Wind Wakers art style more, so that.

A Link to the Past. It isn't even a contest.foxhound_fox

^This. The greatest game in my opinion.

[QUOTE="Lucianu"]

What's with all this praise A Link To The Past is getting, i would have guessed it had such a depth that it would put most games to shame or something. I thought it was a simple top down action-adventure game with a standard simple story. How's the story? How's the gameplay? I never played this also (god damn!), but i'm not gonna miss out on it if its worth it.

charizard1605

That good? .. No way, do not tempt me, i already spent enough getting MGS1, 2 and 3; Zelda OoT & MM, a N64 console and a few more for my PS1. I got enough to play for a couple of months, maybe i'll get it i find some cheap used one.

[QUOTE="charizard1605"][QUOTE="Lucianu"]

What's with all this praise A Link To The Past is getting, i would have guessed it had such a depth that it would put most games to shame or something. I thought it was a simple top down action-adventure game with a standard simple story. How's the story? How's the gameplay? I never played this also (god damn!), but i'm not gonna miss out on it if its worth it.

Lucianu

That good? .. No way, do not tempt me, i already spent enough getting MGS1, 2 and 3; Zelda OoT & MM, a N64 console and a few more for my PS1. I got enough to play for a couple of months, maybe i'll get it i find some cheap used one.

Yay! I see ALTTP has received more votes. That one is the best one and the one that actually defined the series. The following Zeldas are just basically 3D representations of what ALTTP introduced.