Tom McShea reviews Skyrim [x-post from Reddit]

Regarding his Zelda review...

:lol: i'm sigging this,it made my day :lol:

I think his Infamous 2 review was the worst, i mean black and white screen too much? stop sucking then! :P i kid but honestly too funny tho

I think his Infamous 2 review was the worst, i mean black and white screen too much? stop sucking then! :P i kid but honestly too funny tho

finalstar2007

I think the same

That got a chuckle out of me...you guys saying that it's not funny need to lighten up.

More please.

I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. Seriously

The Saboteur - 2.5 - The moment the game turned to black and white Tom turned off his console and gave it a 2.5

Edit - He actually reviewed The Saboteur! But it got a 7.5....

What an idiot.

This meme (and this thread) reeks of so much butthurt and try-hardedness it was painful to read.

What an idiot.

ristactionjakso

LA Noire - 5.5 - You have the option to play the game in black and white.

LA Noire - 5.5 - You have the option to play the game in black and white.

hanslacher54

Tom McShea is a figment of you guys imagination..

Tom McShea is a figment of you guys imagination..

aia89

I wonder how Gamestop picks who reviews what.

I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. Seriously

Pikminmaniac

His Prince of Persia Forgotten Sands re-review comes to mind.:P Well ok, more like a correction... and an extra point up for the score.:P

I wonder how Gamestop picks who reviews what.

Heirren

LA Noire - 5.5 - You have the option to play the game in black and white.

hanslacher54

[QUOTE="Heirren"]

I wonder how Gamestop picks who reviews what.

Bread_or_Decide

I was going to assume that, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was the case!(or is it, really?) ...and then the whole staff was, "uh, oh:(" when it landed on Tom for SS.

You know if you listened to the hot spot you'd realize that he's not alone another gamespot writer played it and backed up everything he had to say about the game. Bread_or_Decide

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"][QUOTE="Heirren"]

I wonder how Gamestop picks who reviews what.

Heirren

I was going to assume that, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was the case!(or is it, really?) ...and then the whole staff was, "uh, oh:(" when it landed on Tom for SS.

[QUOTE="Heirren"]

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"] They throw darts on a wall of pictures of their reviewers. percech

I was going to assume that, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was the case!(or is it, really?) ...and then the whole staff was, "uh, oh:(" when it landed on Tom for SS.

No! In fact, the review felt like it was reviewed by a fanboy! A disgruntled one, but a fanboy nonetheless.

This meme (and this thread) reeks of so much butthurt and try-hardedness it was painful to read.

StrongDeadlift

This thread, and the whole internet besides system wars and a bunch of fanboys.

[QUOTE="percech"][QUOTE="Heirren"]

I was going to assume that, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was the case!(or is it, really?) ...and then the whole staff was, "uh, oh:(" when it landed on Tom for SS.

Heirren

No! In fact, the review felt like it was reviewed by a fanboy! A disgruntled one, but a fanboy nonetheless.

[QUOTE="Bread_or_Decide"][QUOTE="Heirren"]

I wonder how Gamestop picks who reviews what.

Heirren

I was going to assume that, and I wouldn't be surprised if it was the case!(or is it, really?) ...and then the whole staff was, "uh, oh:(" when it landed on Tom for SS.

Meh. Not funny anymore the backlash against tom has gone overboard

I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. Seriously

Pikminmaniac

[QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. Seriouslylightleggy

[QUOTE="lightleggy"][QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. SeriouslyShinobishyguy

lol, you guys put way too much stock in numbers people give to stuff you like.

you are supposed to go, "OMG! that's not the right number!" then forget about it not spend days thinking about it, letting it rule your entire existence and plotting about how to avenge your loss by using corel draw for three and a half mins.

Tom McShea is my favorite reviewer. The rage he has caused from the Infamous and the Skyward Sword fanboys is truly epic.

[QUOTE="Pikminmaniac"]

I actually found that quite funny. How often has Mcshea said something or did something factually wrong when reviewing a game. Seriously

lightleggy

Huh!Can that arguement be used for anyone that has little to no experience with the zelda franchise? That includes reviewers to.

even Link sees things now...

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="lightleggy"] ok we get it, you are pissed, you wanted SS to score 10 but then THANKFULLY came mcshea not blinded by nostalgia and granted a fair score.Bread_or_Decide

even Link sees things now...

aia89

I've always said but you never believed it. Tom Mcshea is a System Wars imaginary creature.