Uncharted 2 - the actual Halo killer?

Every Cow says Halo is a crappy overhyped, overrated series.

Yet they are still trying to beat it and kill it, what gives?

And no, it isn't, same with every other exclusive PS3 shooter.

Level one poster... *grabs popcorn*Diviniuz

Yes uncharted 2 will kill halo, wait no it cant kill a game. On october 13 halo will not just die, its not like halo will be taken off of the market, or that when you boot up halo itll say this game died, because of uncharted 2. Thats the definition of dead. No game will kill another

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] I remember xbox fanboys claimed that it started as an expansion, but Bungie added so much to the package that is was a full game that warranted that 60 dollar price tag, now its an expansion again?TintedEyes

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="TintedEyes"] I remember xbox fanboys claimed that it started as an expansion, but Bungie added so much to the package that is was a full game that warranted that 60 dollar price tag, now its an expansion again?TintedEyes

It got a 9.0 on GS, and on every other reputable site it was AA-AAA. How are those scores underwhelming?

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"][QUOTE="Meltedweasel"] The game itself is an expansion. 15 of the 200 people in Bungie were making ODST. That's what you call an expansion. When the entire company isn't busy making a game and less than a fraction are, then you know it's an expansion. The Halo disc came with the game, it was a good add-on and it justified the $60 price tag, but that's not what the 15 people were working on. Got it? Is it that hard to understand?Fizzman

It got a 9.0 on GS, and on every other reputable site it was AA-AAA. How are those scores underwhelming?

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Call of Duty is the most actively played online game on consoles, not your precious, little Halo. Halo 3 is a waste of time that sold by the hype alone.SuperiorSoldier

so a multiplat beats out an exclusve game in terms of users.......ILL ALERT THE MEDIA!!!!!!!

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Call of Duty is the most actively played online game on consoles, not your precious, little Halo. Halo 3 is a waste of time that sold by the hype alone.SuperiorSoldier

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="Meltedweasel"] No it's not. Not on XBL. I think you're also forgetting that CoD is on all consoles while Halo 3 is only on the 360. On the 360 it's the most played. Stop failing. Fizzman

so a multiplat beats out an exclusve game in terms of users.......ILL ALERT THE MEDIA!!!!!!!

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Yeah, I said on consoles. Learn to read. And CoD4 is on PS3, as well. So when you take into account that, it beats your precious overrated Halo 3. Don't be sad now. And not only did Halo get beaten, its latest game was outscored by the superior Uncharted 2. SuperiorSoldier

so a multiplat beats out an exclusve game in terms of users.......ILL ALERT THE MEDIA!!!!!!!

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. DeadMagazines

So it begins!!! TC a more fair comparision would be betweem GeoW and U2:AT in which case U2 destroys it!!!

Uncharted 2 is in a league of it's own. A league that doesn't consist of generic FPS games.Messiahbolical-

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Yeah, I said on consoles. Learn to read. And CoD4 is on PS3, as well. So when you take into account that, it beats your precious overrated Halo 3. Don't be sad now. And not only did Halo get beaten, its latest game was outscored by the superior Uncharted 2. SuperiorSoldier

Kinda crazy that MS can charge 50bucks for an inferior service while Sony gives it away for free, and no one even wants it.

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="Fizzman"]

so a multiplat beats out an exclusve game in terms of users.......ILL ALERT THE MEDIA!!!!!!!

Fizzman

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

Uncharted 2 is in a league of it's own. A league that doesn't consist of generic FPS games.Messiahbolical-

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] When Modern Warfare 2 comes, all of the CoD4 players and newcomers will upgrade to MW2 and it will destroy Halo 3. I don't expect Halo 3 - from when Modern Warfare is released - to reach above 50 000 - 100 000 daily.SuperiorSoldier

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

[QUOTE="ogvampire"]

[QUOTE="TintedEyes"] Well of you want to compare the most recent games in the series, Uncharted wins.TintedEyes

and if you want to compare the first games of the series, halo wins

what does this prove again?

last time i checked the first game of the series was Uncharted... not Uncharted 2

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="Fizzman"]

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

Fizzman

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Aw, hold on, let's not get carried away with the sales now. Remember, 9.5 > 9.0, and scores are more important than sales figures, so you lose, no matter what.TintedEyes

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] When Modern Warfare 2 comes, all of the CoD4 players and newcomers will upgrade to MW2 and it will destroy Halo 3. I don't expect Halo 3 - from when Modern Warfare is released - to reach above 50 000 - 100 000 daily.SuperiorSoldier

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

How exactly are Uncharted 2 and Halo comparable? They both charge 60$ for all their games? :P

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Aw, hold on, let's not get carried away with the sales now. Remember, 9.5 > 9.0, and scores are more important than sales figures, so you lose, no matter what.TintedEyes

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"][QUOTE="Fizzman"]

You are missing the point you are comparing a game thats on 2 systems as opposed to one. Its not fair, and makes you look like a bigger misinformed fanboy then you already are.

Fizzman

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

[QUOTE="Wii_Gamer_277"][QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"] Why isn't there atleast 4-5 million playing it a day then?GreyFoXX4

What other games? Cod series? Or a demo?

Try splitting communities with Socom, R2, KZ2, LBP, cod series and heck even Fat Princess, its always rolling with 32 player games lol and theres still a mgonline community going. And right now the communities are getting split just because of the MAG beta and U2 demo lol.

I'm sorry but there is alot of quality mp games/shooters to play on the ps3. Where as the 360 its Gears, Halo and cod series. Not only that but not really just one game defines the Playstation brand, where as Halo defines the xbox experience. I find it crazy when I meet someone that ownes a xbox and don't own Halo3, I just scratch my head lol.

yup... as we all know, in terms of online games the 360 ONLY has halo, gears, and cod, right? :roll:

[QUOTE="Fizzman"]

[QUOTE="SuperiorSoldier"] Aw, hold on, let's not get carried away with the sales now. Remember, 9.5 > 9.0, and scores are more important than sales figures, so you lose, no matter what.SuperiorSoldier

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

isnt this thread titled "UC2 - the actual halo killer"

isnt halo 3 a couple of years old....

do you not see the irony?

[QUOTE="Messiahbolical-"]Uncharted 2 is in a league of it's own. A league that doesn't consist of generic FPS games.Meltedweasel

[QUOTE="Meltedweasel"][QUOTE="Messiahbolical-"]Uncharted 2 is in a league of it's own. A league that doesn't consist of generic FPS games.Messiahbolical-

yup.... UC is WAY more like tomb raider than anything else

which is why it was nicknamed 'Dude Raider'

@ogvampire

LIVE Activity for week of Sept. 28th

Xbox 360 Top LIVE Titles (based onUU's)
1Halo 3
2Call of Duty 4
3Halo 3: ODST
4Call of Duty: WaW
5Gears of War 2
6Madden NFL 10 (Download the demo)
7Forza 3 Demo (Download the demo)
8GTA IV
9Left 4 Dead
10 FIFA 10 (Download the demo)

Hmm, in the top 10 Halo3, cod series, gears, a demo, a 1 1/2 year old game, another 1 1/2 year old game, and madden and fiffa hmmm, so in the shooter market what do you have again? Its exactly what I said, There is literally 2 exclusives in that list.

Major Nelson

P.S.

1. Socom
2. Kz2
3. R2
4. cod4
5. cod waw
6. LBP
7. U2 demo
8. MAG beta
9. Madden

All exclusives minus cod series. See how communities can be broke apart when you have alot of exclusives to go alone with the multiplates.

Why is this subject always brought up with every single hyped PS3 exclusive? Get over it already.

@ogvampire

LIVE Activity for week of Sept. 28th

Xbox 360 Top LIVE Titles (based onUU's)
1Halo 3
2Call of Duty 4
3Halo 3: ODST
4Call of Duty: WaW
5Gears of War 2
6Madden NFL 10 (Download the demo)
7Forza 3 Demo (Download the demo)
8GTA IV
9Left 4 Dead
10 FIFA 10 (Download the demo)

Hmm, in the top 10 Halo3, cod series, gears, a demo, a 1 1/2 year old game, another 1 1/2 year old game, and madden and fiffa hmmm, so in the shooter market what do you have again? Its exactly what I said, There is literally 2 exclusives in that list.

Major Nelson

P.S.

1. Socom
2. Kz2
3. R2
4. cod4
5. cod waw
6. LBP
7. U2 demo
8. MAG beta
9. Madden

All exclusives minus cod series. See how communities can be broke apart when you have alot of exclusives to go alone with the multiplates.

GreyFoXX4

considering that the ps3 sold 20mil units... the community is not even close to being 'broke apart' :roll:

also, this proves that ps3 players mostly play shooters... looks like they took the crown from MS

MS actually has variety...

[QUOTE="DeadMagazines"]You're fooling yourself if you think Uncharted will have 1 million users daily 2 years from now, much less have support from ND in 2 years..at least more than minimum support. But go ahead and think so. SuperiorSoldier

[QUOTE="GreyFoXX4"]

@ogvampire

LIVE Activity for week of Sept. 28th

Xbox 360 Top LIVE Titles (based onUU's)
1Halo 3
2Call of Duty 4
3Halo 3: ODST
4Call of Duty: WaW
5Gears of War 2
6Madden NFL 10 (Download the demo)
7Forza 3 Demo (Download the demo)
8GTA IV
9Left 4 Dead
10 FIFA 10 (Download the demo)

Hmm, in the top 10 Halo3, cod series, gears, a demo, a 1 1/2 year old game, another 1 1/2 year old game, and madden and fiffa hmmm, so in the shooter market what do you have again? Its exactly what I said, There is literally 2 exclusives in that list.

Major Nelson

P.S.

1. Socom
2. Kz2
3. R2
4. cod4
5. cod waw
6. LBP
7. U2 demo
8. MAG beta
9. Madden

All exclusives minus cod series. See how communities can be broke apart when you have alot of exclusives to go alone with the multiplates.

considering that the ps3 sold 20mil units... the community is not even close to being 'broke apart' :roll:

also, this proves that ps3 players mostly play shooters... looks like they took the crown from MS

MS actually has variety...

Oooh oooh ooh Lets play Guess the Ban Dodger! Any takers?

So, Uncharted 2 for 2.5 million copies in 2 weeks right?

Aw, hold on, let's not get carried away with the sales now. Remember, 9.5 > 9.0, and scores are more important than sales figures, so you lose, no matter what.SuperiorSoldier

Halo 9.7>Uncharted 2

lol you lose

So, Uncharted 2 for 2.5 million copies in 2 weeks right?

ActicEdge

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

So, Uncharted 2 for 2.5 million copies in 2 weeks right?

Messiahbolical-

how come 1.5 million players online every day 2 years after a games release doesn't reflect quality?

Wow , I must say, this troll has been well fed. Good job guys.

[QUOTE="ActicEdge"]

So, Uncharted 2 for 2.5 million copies in 2 weeks right?

Messiahbolical-

This thread is about killing Halo. What are you going to kill a AAA series with? A AAA game? Naw, more like your game comes out and makes everybody forget about the series it killed and vastly outsells it. So yes, this is entirely about sales.