Uncharted 3 is by far more superior technically than Gears of War 3

Well TC, since all you want is proof, here it is:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-vs-gears-of-war-3

'Gears 3 is one of the most technically advanced games this generation' Considering both consoles are equally capable, do you honestly think a PS3 game will ever look 'fat superior' to the best looking game on 360?

Both seem tied to me. If something, would give Gears 3 the advantage for moving so many objects on screen, especially when played in coop.

PAL360

They said similar things for Uncharted 3, and named it one of the best looking games of all time.

fail thread, i am not going to say one is better than the other because i have the decency not to comment on a game i have not played, and good set pieces have nothing to do with engine tech, engine tech is lighting,AA, on-screen AI,physics ,particle effects, etc, etc, just because a game has more set pieces doesn't mean it has better tech, COD has more set piece moments than most games but the tech isn't exactly ground-breaking.delta3074

Why is it that people think that I am asking them to compare the quality of the two games? I'm just talking about moments that show off the tech. I never once talk about the quantity of set pieces, I didn't even say "only set pieces", I asked for moments. Moments can be anything. These moments are meant to show how breathtaking the game is. People are trying to convince me that Uncharted 3 isn't a good game technically, yet Digital Foundry and a lot of other reviewers say otherwise....

"Where Uncharted 3 is peerless and unparalleled is in its ability to defy the technological constraints of current-generation platforms, which raises an interesting question about whether ideas are the real premium now over and above the technological arms race that has powered current-gen console game development"

The other thread pretty much proved my point.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Well TC, since all you want is proof, here it is:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-vs-gears-of-war-3

'Gears 3 is one of the most technically advanced games this generation' Considering both consoles are equally capable, do you honestly think a PS3 game will ever look 'fat superior' to the best looking game on 360?

Both seem tied to me. If something, would give Gears 3 the advantage for moving so many objects on screen, especially when played in coop.

XVision84

They said similar things for Uncharted 3, and named it one of the best looking games of all time.

Exactly, im saying both look equally impressive, not that Gears 3 is superior.

Of course in Sony hardcore fans eyes, that would be translated in: 'Uncharted 3 is BY FAR the best looking game ever created' :lol:

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Well TC, since all you want is proof, here it is:

http://www.eurogamer.net/articles/digitalfoundry-vs-gears-of-war-3

'Gears 3 is one of the most technically advanced games this generation' Considering both consoles are equally capable, do you honestly think a PS3 game will ever look 'fat superior' to the best looking game on 360?

Both seem tied to me. If something, would give Gears 3 the advantage for moving so many objects on screen, especially when played in coop.

PAL360

They said similar things for Uncharted 3, and named it one of the best looking games of all time.

Exactly, im saying both look equally impressive, not that Gears 3 is superior.

Of course in Sony hardcore fans eyes, that would be translated in: 'Uncharted 3 is BY FAR the best looking game ever created' :lol:

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

They said similar things for Uncharted 3, and named it one of the best looking games of all time.

XVision84

Exactly, im saying both look equally impressive, not that Gears 3 is superior.

Of course in Sony hardcore fans eyes, that would be translated in: 'Uncharted 3 is BY FAR the best looking game ever created' :lol:

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

Well, i agree Uncharted 3 has more wow moments, mostly due to it´s more cinematic nature. Gears 3, on the other hand, has more open gameplay 4 players can make different approaches and tactics.

We have to give credit to what games are trying to do and not bash them for being different in concept.

Gears 3 wins when it comes to be more game than cinematic movie and I'll take that 8 dayzz a week umm, unless what I'm in the mood for is more movie than game, in that case....

MGS4>UC3>Gears 3. :P

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

Exactly, im saying both look equally impressive, not that Gears 3 is superior.

Of course in Sony hardcore fans eyes, that would be translated in: 'Uncharted 3 is BY FAR the best looking game ever created' :lol:

PAL360

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

Well, i agree Uncharted 3 has more wow moments, mostly due to it´s more cinematic nature. Gears 3, on the other hand, has more open gameplay 4 players can make different approaches and tactics.

We have to give credit to what games are trying to do and not bash them for being different in concept.

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Gears 3 wins when it comes to be more game than cinematic movie and I'll take that 8 dayzz a week umm, unless what I'm in the mood for is more movie than game, in that case....

MGS4>UC3>Gears 3. :P

TheGuardian03

Those you call movies scored higher btw.

I own both games you can check my gamertag on both systems, khalil19104. and gears 3 is a way bigger jump from gears 2 then uncharted 3 is from uncharted. Honestly uncharted 3 doesnt look any better than part 2.

[QUOTE="freedomfreak"]

You didn't play Geow3?

XVision84

Nope, I didn't play Gears of War 3 because I don't have an Xbox 360.

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

They said similar things for Uncharted 3, and named it one of the best looking games of all time.

XVision84

Exactly, im saying both look equally impressive, not that Gears 3 is superior.

Of course in Sony hardcore fans eyes, that would be translated in: 'Uncharted 3 is BY FAR the best looking game ever created' :lol:

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

For cryin out loud what's wrong with you man? :| They never said that. Read it again including that whole paragraph. This was already discussed in the other thread. I know you cows love to hype things through the roof. But now to lie and spread false information. Are you THAT desperate to see uc3 be labeled as graphics king? Wow.

Gears 3 wins when it comes to be more game than cinematic movie and I'll take that 8 dayzz a week umm, unless what I'm in the mood for is more movie than game, in that case....

MGS4>UC3>Gears 3. :P

SecretPolice

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

tormentos

Well, i agree Uncharted 3 has more wow moments, mostly due to it´s more cinematic nature. Gears 3, on the other hand, has more open gameplay 4 players can make different approaches and tactics.

We have to give credit to what games are trying to do and not bash them for being different in concept.

Gears 3 has 4 or 5 character....allies. Now add all the enemies and you allways have huge battles. Considering that, and the fact it has the same visual quality of Uncharted 3, i would say it´s a very impressive achievement.

Oh, you mention fire and water, very apropriate. Why dont you also bring explosions, particles, smoke, god rays, etc to the equation?

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

[QUOTE="TheGuardian03"] That's the excuse everytime lems bring ? cinematic movie ?

Those you call movies scored higher btw.

TheGuardian03

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="XVision84"]

Okay, I admit that I put the "by far" thing to attract attention to the thread :P, but Digital Foundry says that Uncharted 3 is unmatched in its ability to produce technically amazing graphics in current-gen hardware. From what I've seen of Gears 3, I'm just more impressed with Uncharted 3 overall.

tormentos

Well, i agree Uncharted 3 has more wow moments, mostly due to it´s more cinematic nature. Gears 3, on the other hand, has more open gameplay 4 players can make different approaches and tactics.

We have to give credit to what games are trying to do and not bash them for being different in concept.

Gears Of War 3 Campaign is by far the weakest out of the series. Anyone who disagrees needs to really play GEOW 1 and 2 again. It was sooo flat! *run duck shoot* FIRE IN THE HOLE *BAM* *insert stupid remark from fenix* *on his blue tooth headset*, "LAMBANTTTTTTTTTTTTTT". Rinse and repeat. This is what majority of the game consists off. Now, It was a good game, dont get me wrong, but no way as good as the first 2.

Uncharted series have significantly improved over each one, yeah, theres a tonne of scripted events, but thats what makes your jaw drop. It looks freaking amazing. I rather be doing all that platforming, shooting in multiple ways, run duck and shoot, rather then JUST run duck and shoot for 8-10 hours i.e. Gears Of War 3, it just because a mindless duck and shooter.

[QUOTE="tormentos"][QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Gears 3 wins when it comes to be more game than cinematic movie and I'll take that 8 dayzz a week umm, unless what I'm in the mood for is more movie than game, in that case....

MGS4>UC3>Gears 3. :P

sts106mat

no, more co-op players = more enemies.sts106mat

[QUOTE="tormentos"][QUOTE="sts106mat"]no, more co-op players = more enemies.sts106mat

LoL, peasants.

Why do people post about UC3 or Gears 3 looking better than one another... When they both look on par VISUALLY in almost every comparable scene?

Is anyone on SW blind? Or is it plain fanboyism? Or maybe people are suddenly convinced that better set pieces = better graphics. I guess Enslaved is more technically advanced than Gears 3 too...

THIS is a game that looks BETTER. And it's the PC version.

LoL @ Sub-HD Console franchises.

Don't forget the Witcher 2

[QUOTE="SecretPolice"]

Gears 3 wins when it comes to be more game than cinematic movie and I'll take that 8 dayzz a week umm, unless what I'm in the mood for is more movie than game, in that case....

MGS4>UC3>Gears 3. :P

tormentos

LoL @ Sub-HD Console franchises.

Don't forget the Witcher 2Kankaseni1

[QUOTE="Kankaseni1"]

LoL @ Sub-HD Console franchises.

Don't forget the Witcher 2mems_1224

Nah, it's just the Fact-Wagon passing by :lol:

[QUOTE="tormentos"][QUOTE="PAL360"]

Well, i agree Uncharted 3 has more wow moments, mostly due to it´s more cinematic nature. Gears 3, on the other hand, has more open gameplay 4 players can make different approaches and tactics.

We have to give credit to what games are trying to do and not bash them for being different in concept.

PAL360

Gears 3 has 4 or 5 character....allies. Now add all the enemies and you allways have huge battles. Considering that, and the fact it has the same visual quality of Uncharted 3, i would say it´s a very impressive achievement.

Oh, you mention fire and water, very apropriate. Why dont you also bring explosions, particles, smoke, god rays, etc to the equation?

[QUOTE="PAL360"]

[QUOTE="tormentos"] No dude Uncharted 3 look consistently better,the fire and water are second to non,on Gears 3 those elements look silly,the water look like a transparent glace,and the fire is compose of spinning textures to simulate fire. While Gears has 4 characters at once some times 5 i think,those are balance by taking enemies out of the equation,so you render 2 more characters and render 2 less enemies at once. Been a little more open doesn't mean much when you have a traced path to fallow,which you can't change.tormentos

Gears 3 has 4 or 5 character....allies. Now add all the enemies and you allways have huge battles. Considering that, and the fact it has the same visual quality of Uncharted 3, i would say it´s a very impressive achievement.

Oh, you mention fire and water, very apropriate. Why dont you also bring explosions, particles, smoke, god rays, etc to the equation?

Better looking textures? Why isn't it showing up in any of the pics. Both look the same quality to me. OH! You mean, better art style. I agree then.

Why do people post about UC3 or Gears 3 looking better than one another... When they both look on par VISUALLY in almost every comparable scene?Is anyone on SW blind? Or is it plain fanboyism? Or maybe people are suddenly convinced that better set pieces = better graphics. I guess Enslaved is more technically advanced than Gears 3 too..CorbraMax

[QUOTE="CorbraMax"]Why do people post about UC3 or Gears 3 looking better than one another... When they both look on par VISUALLY in almost every comparable scene?Is anyone on SW blind? Or is it plain fanboyism? Or maybe people are suddenly convinced that better set pieces = better graphics. I guess Enslaved is more technically advanced than Gears 3 too..tormentos

So yeah. Uncharted 3 has "Better textures". Find me a pic from your PC version of Uncharted 3 with incredible texture filtering.

Better looking textures? Why isn't it showing up in any of the pics. Both look the same quality to me. OH! You mean, better art style. I agree then.CorbraMax

I think that Uncharted 3 looks better than Gears of War 3 because of the combination of lighting, environmental detail, and textures. Uncharted 3 is one of the most beautiful games i've ever played.

So yeah. Uncharted 3 has "Better textures". Find me a pic from your PC version of Uncharted 3 with incredible texture filtering.CorbraMax

[QUOTE="CorbraMax"]So yeah. Uncharted 3 has "Better textures". Find me a pic from your PC version of Uncharted 3 with incredible texture filtering.tormentos

1.) That's not a bad capture of Uncharted 3

2.) Mercy is one the prettiest places in the game besides Azura since it wasn't blasted by the Lightmass Bomb. And if you venture further in that chapter, the citizens will great you with open arms:)

Why stop with posting pics? I can post an entire video sequence for BOTH games. Feel free to point out the superior textures since both games uses POM.

1.) That's not a bad capture of Uncharted 3 2.) Mercy is one the prettiest places in the game besides Azura since it wasn't blasted by the Lightmass Bomb. And if you venture further in that chapter, the citizens will great you with open arms:) Why stop with posting pics? I can post an entire video sequence for BOTH games. Feel free to point out the superior textures since both games uses POM.CorbraMax

[QUOTE="sts106mat"] you keep mentioning this spinning fire, is that the same for all fire in the game or just sometormentos

God of War 3 and Killzone 2/3 both use spinning fire. I guess they don't count anymore too.