Uncharted better than Grand Theft Auto 4? (Now with Poll)

Yeah right, did Uncharted sell 9 million copies month one and is Uncharted at 97 % at Game Rankings? Hype_Status

Still doesnt change the fact that I enjoyed Uncharted more then GTA4. It's my opinion that Uncharted is better then GTA4, just like it's everyone elses opinion GTA4 is better.

both were amazing, i think gta4 beats it because of how much it does. it has very good shooting mechanics, very good physics system, very good driving system, very good ragdoll system, very good atmosphere, very good soundtrack, very good story...as you can see i can keep going. the game does an unbelievable amount but unlike the previous GTAs, each part is so much more polished and refined.

uncharted i thought was amazing, the story, characters, graphics. sound and gunplay was very good.

[QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

BioShockOwnz

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

[QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

BioShockOwnz

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

oh cmon cut the SW rules BS and tell me that dark sector and Uncharted are seriously compareable in terms of quality? If u can then im sorry but your beyond help...

[QUOTE="Hype_Status"]Yeah right, did Uncharted sell 9 million copies month one and is Uncharted at 97 % at Game Rankings? W1NGMAN-

Still doesnt change the fact that I enjoyed Uncharted more then GTA4. It's my opinion that Uncharted is better then GTA4, just like it's everyone elses opinion GTA4 is better.

actually, from my friends gta 4 was the worst of the series, and im starting too agree, even if I did disagree at first.

It adds some better graphics, a nice physics engine and an o.k cover system.

But what did it take away? a whole lot more than it added thats for sure.

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

W1NGMAN-

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.LastOfTheBest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

[QUOTE="Hype_Status"]Yeah right, did Uncharted sell 9 million copies month one and is Uncharted at 97 % at Game Rankings? LastOfTheBest

Still doesnt change the fact that I enjoyed Uncharted more then GTA4. It's my opinion that Uncharted is better then GTA4, just like it's everyone elses opinion GTA4 is better.

actually, from my friends gta 4 was the worst of the series, and im starting too agree, even if I did disagree at first.

It adds some better graphics, a nice physics engine and an o.k cover system.

But what did it take away? a whole lot more than it added thats for sure.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

angelkimne

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

BioShockOwnz? :P

Anyway, while Uncharted was 8 hours of damn good game, Grand Theft Auto 4 was 20 hours of damn good game, and around 10 hours of monotony for me.

GTA 4 wins.

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.MojondeVACA

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

You do know it's not hard looking at your previous threads right?

I like how your confusing me with two people I have never heared of tho, nice...

HELL NO

GTA 4 is the superior game here

Better story

More Variety

LONGER(WAY LONGER)

Multiplayer

Good gameplay

Far more immersive

GTA 4 is completely superior to Uncharted in every way but graphics. and even then GTA 4 has the bigger scale and is just a larger game in general.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

angelkimne

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

Should I? I'm just using his doubled standard, flip flopping logic. That's all.

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

[QUOTE="Hype_Status"]Yeah right, did Uncharted sell 9 million copies month one and is Uncharted at 97 % at Game Rankings? LastOfTheBest

Still doesnt change the fact that I enjoyed Uncharted more then GTA4. It's my opinion that Uncharted is better then GTA4, just like it's everyone elses opinion GTA4 is better.

actually, from my friends gta 4 was the worst of the series, and im starting too agree, even if I did disagree at first.

It adds some better graphics, a nice physics engine and an o.k cover system.

But what did it take away? a whole lot more than it added thats for sure.

i disagree, i dont think it took a whole lot more than it added

[QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

esperyo

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

BioShockOwnz? :P

Anyway, while Uncharted was 8 hours of damn good game, Grand Theft Auto 4 was 20 hours of damn good game, and around 10 hours of monotony for me.

GTA 4 wins.

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.LastOfTheBest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

You do know it's not hard looking at your previous threads right?

I like how your confusing me with two people I have never heared of tho, nice...

[QUOTE="esperyo"][QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

angelkimne

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

BioShockOwnz? :P

Anyway, while Uncharted was 8 hours of damn good game, Grand Theft Auto 4 was 20 hours of damn good game, and around 10 hours of monotony for me.

GTA 4 wins.

Oh please, there are many of us manticores, it doesn't change the fact that just you own all systems that your in no way bias at all.

No, a respected, unbias member of GS. Unlike you.angelkimne

You just attacked my very third post, and you've managed to make a full profile analysis of me. Congratulations.

[QUOTE="esperyo"][QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"][QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"][QUOTE="XturnalS"]its ok bio thinks dark sector > any other game this gen ROFL

Uncharted isnt better then GTAIV but Uncharted is damn good and a great game. And I was dissapointed by GTAIVs lack of Epic Missions, there were a few but not as many as SA or VC for that matter. Really wish they would of had crazier missions, and cut out the fat of "variety and dead space" in SA.

angelkimne

Not being very honest, eh? You may want to start stating factual claims.

Also, Uncharted scored 8.0, Dark Sector scored 7.5. Truly not a far cry from one another, my friend.

You rated Dark Sector an 8.5, how is that possible its a fact that Dark Sector is a 7.5 game because GS said so...:roll:

BioShockOwnz? :P

Anyway, while Uncharted was 8 hours of damn good game, Grand Theft Auto 4 was 20 hours of damn good game, and around 10 hours of monotony for me.

GTA 4 wins.

you realise thats a different guy you just quoted, not W1NGMAN

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"][QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.MojondeVACA

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

You do know it's not hard looking at your previous threads right?

I like how your confusing me with two people I have never heared of tho, nice...

If you really must know Why I think your such a huge troll.

Your name is a dead give away, I trust you know what it means.

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]No, a respected, unbias member of GS. Unlike you.esperyo

You just attacked my very third post, and you've managed to make a full profile analysis of me. Congratulations.

GTA IV - 3,6, 6, 9.

Uncharted - ?????? 1????

[QUOTE="esperyo"]

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]No, a respected, unbias member of GS. Unlike you.angelkimne

You just attacked my very third post, and you've managed to make a full profile analysis of me. Congratulations.

Wait what? lol what posts were directed to me?

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.Always-Honest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

watch out lastofthebest, mojondevaca is constantly reporting to mods. he is by far the worst fanboy here. hence his name (look it up)

I know, ive seen whenever a thread involves the ps3 he feels the need to post, How he hasn't been banned yet is beyond me based on some of the things he says.

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

LastOfTheBest

I love the playlist, I hate that they play the same songs over and over. What happen to the huge list of songs posted? I'm constantly hearing the same songs over and over again.

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

LastOfTheBest

i love the radio stations lol. maybe rockstar has my taste in music. all of the GTAs i thought the soundtrack was superb.

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

W1NGMAN-

I love the playlist, I hate that they play the same songs over and over. What happen to the huge list of songs posted? I'm constantly hearing the same songs over and over again.

I liked ringking and the reggae station, lets see, theres some good ones, but you have too pick them out from the huge mountain of crap on the stations.

I guess in that regard they nailed realism well, as radio stations in RL usually play crap also :P

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.Always-Honest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

watch out lastofthebest, mojondevaca is constantly reporting to mods. he is by far the worst fanboy here. hence his name (look it up)

[QUOTE="Always-Honest"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.LastOfTheBest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

watch out lastofthebest, mojondevaca is constantly reporting to mods. he is by far the worst fanboy here. hence his name (look it up)

I know, ive seen whenever a thread involves the ps3 he feels the need to post, How he hasn't been banned yet is beyond me based on some of the things he says.

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

Arjdagr8

i love the radio stations lol. maybe rockstar has my taste in music. all of the GTAs i thought the soundtrack was superb.

i even downloaded that russian song from the beginning of the game ("schweine">>>yeah, germamn word but russian song).

also i loved that "i wanna be a dog" (iggy pop) was on the playlist

[QUOTE="angelkimne"][QUOTE="esperyo"]

[QUOTE="angelkimne"]No, a respected, unbias member of GS. Unlike you.W1NGMAN-

You just attacked my very third post, and you've managed to make a full profile analysis of me. Congratulations.

Wait what? lol what posts were directed to me?

System Wars the name of the board explains everything,if you dont like the bashing dont post here..i dont get banned because i dont flame people when i post simple.
MojondeVACA

yet you report people when thay have names similar to your own (insulting the other console)or when they say something criticall about 360.

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="Always-Honest"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.LastOfTheBest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

watch out lastofthebest, mojondevaca is constantly reporting to mods. he is by far the worst fanboy here. hence his name (look it up)

How would I get moderated for disagreeing with you.

Ive never seen such a troll in denial, I mean it's not exactly like you hide it.

If you hate the ps3 so much thats fine, im not trying too make you like it, I just don't see why you have too wreck most threads talking about a ps3 game or anything ps related so much.

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="Always-Honest"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]Lastofthebest did you know that bandodging is bad? your last accounts were banned SwiftDragon616 and SwiftD6.LastOfTheBest

who exactly are those. im just stating my opinion based on your previous posts.

watch out lastofthebest, mojondevaca is constantly reporting to mods. he is by far the worst fanboy here. hence his name (look it up)

How would I get moderated for disagreeing with you.

Ive never seen such a troll in denial, I mean it's not exactly like you hide it.

If you hate the ps3 so much thats fine, im not trying too make you like it, I just don't see why you have too wreck most threads talking about a ps3 game or anything ps related so much.

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]
System Wars the name of the board explains everything,if you dont like the bashing dont post here..i dont get banned because i dont flame people when i post simple.
Always-Honest

yet you report people when thay have names similar to your own (insulting the other console)or when they say something criticall about 360.

If you hate it that much cant you just ingore him....angelkimne

[QUOTE="Always-Honest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]
System Wars the name of the board explains everything,if you dont like the bashing dont post here..i dont get banned because i dont flame people when i post simple.
MojondeVACA

yet you report people when thay have names similar to your own (insulting the other console)or when they say something criticall about 360.

people just have to look in the "äsk the mods" thread and look for your name for a couple of pages. all whining

to bad these don't work no more:

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26414458

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26413258

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26397615

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26393947

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26392706

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26390130

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="Always-Honest"]

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]
System Wars the name of the board explains everything,if you dont like the bashing dont post here..i dont get banned because i dont flame people when i post simple.
Always-Honest

yet you report people when thay have names similar to your own (insulting the other console)or when they say something criticall about 360.

people just have to look in the "äsk the mods" thread and look for your name for a couple of pages. all whining

to bad these don't work no more:

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26414458

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26413258

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26397615

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26393947

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26392706

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26390130

No my problem if you can't follow the rules.
MojondeVACA

none of these threads are about me. these are crying whining questions to mods about banning people and locking threads that are criticaLL about 360.. lol...

Are you kidding me VACA? I dont even know who these swiftD or whatever there name people are.

The fact we agree to disagree and your already trying to get me moderated, wow...

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"]

No my problem if you can't follow the rules.
Always-Honest

none of these threads are about me. these are crying whining questions to mods about banning people and locking threads that are criticaLL about 360.. lol...

sorry to break it to you but, uncharted sucks.tomertr