Uncharted better than Grand Theft Auto 4? (Now with Poll)

Are you kidding me VACA? I dont even know who these swiftD or whatever there name people are.

The fact we agree to disagree and your already trying to get me moderated, wow...

LastOfTheBest

[QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

Are you kidding me VACA? I dont even know who these swiftD or whatever there name people are.

The fact we agree to disagree and your already trying to get me moderated, wow...

MojondeVACA

im pretty sure im not the first too want too insult you, this feels like an elementary schoolyard, with you running too the teachers aid because we agree too disagree with you, where is the logic in that.

sorry to break it to you but, uncharted sucks.
tomertr

Damn. Where did you get that picture? 2006?Locke562

Does it really matter?

[QUOTE="MojondeVACA"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

Are you kidding me VACA? I dont even know who these swiftD or whatever there name people are.

The fact we agree to disagree and your already trying to get me moderated, wow...

LastOfTheBest

im pretty sure im not the first too want too insult you, this feels like an elementary schoolyard, with you running too the teachers aid because we agree too disagree with you, where is the logic in that.

Its your opinion to like Uncharted more than GTA4, but its a silly comparisson, and I'm sure that most agree.

I like ice cream better than Uncharted. Why? It tastes better.

[QUOTE="Arjdagr8"][QUOTE="LastOfTheBest"]

I guess another reason i didnt enjoy gta 4 as much as the other games was imo, the pretty awfull music selection on the radio.

I mean flashing lights and gettaway driver and top down fit, but some of the other stuff on the beat was plain awfull.

ESPECIALLY, the stuff where they tried too incorporate liberty city into their lyrics, those were some of the lamest rap songs I have ever heared in my life.

Always-Honest

i love the radio stations lol. maybe rockstar has my taste in music. all of the GTAs i thought the soundtrack was superb.

i even downloaded that russian song from the beginning of the game ("schweine">>>yeah, germamn word but russian song).

also i loved that "i wanna be a dog" (iggy pop) was on the playlist

lol yeah, i think shes says ein, zwei, drei i.e. 1,2,3. the soundtrack is really well done. appeals to a lot of different people. luckily my music taste is very wide.

I know we're talking opinions here and if I was to score the TC's opinion, I'd give it a 1.0.

Uncharted had better production values and its cover system was implemented better.

That's about it. As for the shootouts themselves, they were far more high octane and exciting in GTAIV. Three-Leaf Clover, Deconstruction for Beginners, Museum Peice, If the Price is Right and Hostile Negotiation were all EPIC shooutouts that I just didn't experience the likes of in Uncharted.

IMO, Uncharted is an 8ish kind of game. I think it is seriously overrated by Sony fans. It's a very good game, and it's a verypure kind of game, but I don't feel it does enough to set itself apart from other games.

GTA IV does. It is far more ambitious as far as its game environment, the dialogue in it is far more interesting than that in Uncharted (Uncharted is full of corny, popcorn chomper sort of dialogue), and it's just more clever in general.

I seriously don't get how anybody can like the story in Uncharted better. It's a pedestrian, placeholder kind of story. GTA's gameplay was actually designed around the story. It seems like alot more thought was put into it.

Another point:

If one student made a birdhouse and made it very pretty (Uncharted), I would give him props.

If another student made a birdhouse city and it was a little rough around the edges (GTAIV), I would give that student a huge award and the kid who made the single pretty birdhouse would be quickly forgotten.

Gta got about 20 tens from different review sites and mags... Uncharted ... Not so much.Vortec33

What I'm trying to say is, that score is just a number. It shouldn't be used to represent a game.

Uncharted looks much better than GTA 4, but GTA 4 has more Replay value. Both are Fantastic gmaes though that any PS3 owner should get. (i said that because 360 dosent get uncharted.)black_awpN1

I'm sure none of us could have figured that out. Thank God you came to the rescue. :roll:

Your thread title is incorrect. Go back to school before posting here again.elektrixxx

I wouldn't go that extreme, but I would say the TC should get a new opinion similar to mine, since my opinions are the best. :P

Uncharted was the definition of generic. It ripped off several movies and characters, yet it wasn't as nearly as compelling as any of them. Obviously, I'm just stating the majority opinion that GTA IV is vastly superior, as you can see by comparing the overall review scores for both.

BioShockOwnz

You are stating a majority opinion? well aren't we mr. high-and-mighty? I wish I could speak for millions/billions of people. Or at least thought I could.

I for one feel that as far as fun factors go, uncharted and GTAIV are about on the same level playing field. the only thing that sets them apart is GTAIV's online. but really, neither are all that great for replay value, as both get old. GTAIV lasted me a little longer because of online, but Uncharted left me wanting to play through again to get all the little extras, like the new costumes and guns and stuff.

To each their own, but when someone starts trying to pass off their own opinions and feelings as some kind of "majority" or "absolute truth", thats when I have to step in.

You may THINK you know what the majority has to say, but I must tell you, 10 reviewers and 1000 fanboys do not equal the majority.
0rin

Yes, we can't know for sure what the majority thinks, but for all practical purposes, GTAIV seems to be generally preferred.

Just because we can't know for sure which one is considered better by consensus, we can still make an educated guess and based on all the evidence we have, more people seem to consider GTAIV a better game.

It is more popular, got better reviews nearly everywhere, more people in this very thread seem to prefer GTAIV, and so on.

That's all he was saying. You're trying to make everything moot and I just don't see the point of doing that in a video game debate forum.

And can you seriously make an argument for Uncharted? Surely, one game is prefered by more people, right? They can't be equal. Wouldn't it stand to reason that it would be GTAIV that more people like better?

Uncharted was the definition of generic. It ripped off several movies and characters, yet it wasn't as nearly as compelling as any of them. Obviously, I'm just stating the majority opinion that GTA IV is vastly superior, as you can see by comparing the overall review scores for both. BioShockOwnz

The majority of opinions disagree with you because almost no one ( except you ) called Uncharted "the definition of generic".

GTA4 is a better game but Uncharted is far from generic.

They're both overrated

Uncharted? :lol: GTAIV? This is like comparing Mass Effect to Lego Indiana Jones on the Wii, and then saying Lego Indiana Jones is a better game.Stevo_the_gamer

No not at all.

Uncharted? :lol: GTAIV? This is like comparing Mass Effect to Lego Indiana Jones on the Wii, and then saying Lego Indiana Jones is a better game.Stevo_the_gamer

Uncharted? :lol: GTAIV? This is like comparing Mass Effect to Lego Indiana Jones on the Wii, and then saying Lego Indiana Jones is a better game.Stevo_the_gamer

No not at all.

W1NGMAN-

[QUOTE="BioShockOwnz"]

Uncharted was the definition of generic. It ripped off several movies and characters, yet it wasn't as nearly as compelling as any of them. Obviously, I'm just stating the majority opinion that GTA IV is vastly superior, as you can see by comparing the overall review scores for both.

0rin

Underlined part... read! :roll:

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

No not at all.

Stevo_the_gamer

Crazy to imagine it can score an 8.0 here with such shortcomings and somehow average an 89% over at gamerankings....:roll:

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

No not at all.

W1NGMAN-

Crazy to imagine it can score an 8.0 here with such shortcomings and somehow average an 89% over at gamerankings....:roll:

[QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

No not at all.

Stevo_the_gamer

According to your logic, your favorite game Gears of War sucks too because it can be beat in 7 hours, shallow gameplay and very linear level designs.

[QUOTE="Stevo_the_gamer"][QUOTE="W1NGMAN-"]

No not at all.

Ninten007

According to your logic, your favorite game Gears of War sucks too because it can be beat in 7 hours, shallow gameplay and very linear level designs.

Replay value of uncharted is massive, I'll never get tired of playing through that game.

I don't think I'll ever touch GTA again, I got 96% and just gave up. Won't see it again.

While GTA has the more enjoyable and intense first runthrough, after that its not that good, so I'll probably go for uncharted.

gta4 knocks drake's out, then smushes his head into the sandy bland beaches of Uncharted.

Uncharted is one of the least inspired games i've played in ages - perfect example of style over substance gone wrong.