What is the best 10/10 game on GS this gen. ?

For me It's gotta be Mario Galaxy 2, wow just finished that game, and it has everything ! Perfect gameplay, storyline, SOUNDTRACK !!! ( OH YEAH ! ) :D, and of course it has Yoshi ! :P

But thats just me.... so what do you think is the best 10/10 game this gen ?

I am going to go with SMG2 and I havent played it yet. I think that MGS4 and GTA4 were both average at best so SMG2 wins by technical default lol

SMG2.

Funny that most people propose SMG2 yet it isn't listed.

You mention SMG2 as your favorite but.... it's not in the poll itself? :?

Don't think SMG2 had a storymysterj

I would vote for SMG2, but it isn't on the poll?

[QUOTE="mysterj"]Don't think SMG2 had a storyUnArguably

msg for me but why isnt smg an option in the poll?ruthless12

[QUOTE="ruthless12"]msg for me but why isnt smg an option in the poll?Mr_Cumberdale

Don't think SMG2 had a storymysterj

Sure it did :?...who cares if the story is older and more stagnant than the iceman.

[QUOTE="mysterj"]Don't think SMG2 had a storyR3FURBISHED

Sure it did :?...who cares if the story is older and more stagnant than the iceman.

None i guess, my best games so far are Fable 2, Lost Odyssey, Demon Soul, Mass Effect 1-2, Alan Wake, Muramasha etc and none is 10/10 here ( i think )

I never play Mario games, i hate their style frm my childhood days, always loved Zelda and hated Mario

It is rather funny that i cant think of a single 10/10 game that is in my top20 gameslist for this generation

Guess MGS4 because I did hate GTA4 and I don't like 3D mario games.

[QUOTE="R3FURBISHED"]

[QUOTE="mysterj"]Don't think SMG2 had a storymysterj

Sure it did :?...who cares if the story is older and more stagnant than the iceman.

[QUOTE="Elian2530"][QUOTE="mystic_knight"]Funny how the acronym for Super mario galaxy and Metal Gear Solid are the same just re-arranged. Anyhow i hated them all to be honest. My fav game this gen got a 9 and second fave got a 9 as well. (3rd fav was an 8.5)mystic_knight

It is rather funny that i cant think of a single 10/10 game that is in my top20 gameslist for this generation

a_simple_gamer

[QUOTE="a_simple_gamer"]

It is rather funny that i cant think of a single 10/10 game that is in my top20 gameslist for this generation

Elian2530

Indeed, Demon Soul (best combat in an Action/RPG), Fable 2 (most unique RPG/Adventure), Lost Odyssey (best old school JRPG), Mass Effect 1-2 (best NPCs and sci-fi RPG), Muramasha (best 2D scrollibngadventure)etc

SMG2 for me. I got more play time out of MGS4 and GTAIV, but SMG2 was just pure awesome from beginning to end. MGS4 was cool, but it really felt like a step back for the series. I've never liked GTA games so the fact that I even managed to make it through GTAIV says a lot.

All three games raised the bar in one way or another, but SMG2 was just pure fun gameplay non stop.

The one that´s coming out on July 27th.

I haven't SMG2 that much to comment on it. (Still got to pick up a copy of my own). So for me it's between MGS4 and GTA4. Well MGS4 is one of my disappointments of this gen so I'll go with GTA4.

None of the games that have received a 10/10 never deserved a 10/10. None of them.

I'd say MGS4. Bias opinion though.

E.g: I will stay rank 32 forever due to it's title even if I need to get moderated on purpose lol.

The one that´s coming out on July 27th.

Arach666

[QUOTE="Arach666"]

The one that´s coming out on July 27th.

R3FURBISHED

SMG2, it's a fantastic game that will be remembered as a classic.

I'd say MGS4. Bias opinion though.

E.g: I will stay rank 32 forever due to it's title even if I need to get moderated on purpose lol.

tmntPunchout

[QUOTE="R3FURBISHED"][QUOTE="Arach666"]

The one that´s coming out on July 27th.

Arach666

I would most definitely say SMG2. One of the funnest games I've played this gen.

Best 10/10 this gen I'd say is Mario Galaxy 2

Best 10/10 ever is defo Soul Calibur

And the game that should be a 10, as it's an abomination of man kind to see that it's not, is Half Life 2. This game is better than all the 10's on this site.

Best 10/10 this gen I'd say is Mario Galaxy 2

Best 10/10 ever is defo Soul Calibur

And the game that should be a 10, as it's an abomination of man kind to see that it's not, is Half Life 2. This game is better than all the 10's on this site.

Raymundo_Manuel

SMG2 is way more fun than MGS4 and GTAIV, so that one.

Mario Galaxy 2 imo