What is the Better Fighting Game....Soul Calibur 4 vs. SSBB

[QUOTE="Technoweirdo"][QUOTE="Gamer556"][QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

nVidiaGaMer

Brawl's combat is awful. Each character has like 4 moves.

You're way off.

I don't understand how fighting with cartoonish characters can be fun. To eaches own I guess.

Looking through the Wii's entire gaming library is like lookng through PG movies. Theres only select few M rated games and there terrible like Red Steel and Far Cry.

maybe you dont like fighters and only voted against the wii to let you platform look better ?:roll:

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

MikeE21286

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

Super Smash Bros. Brawl

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

darkspineslayer

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

good ol' SW logic

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

darkspineslayer

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

People here act as if I'm the only person to have ever made this comparison......

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

Gamer556

Brawl's combat is awful. Each character has like 4 moves.

4 B moves

4 smash A moves

forward A moves

up A moves

areal moves

etc.

[QUOTE="darkspineslayer"][QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

MikeE21286

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

People here act as if I'm the only person to have ever made this comparison......

as far as i've seen you are...nobody else has said its a platformer that i've seen

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"][QUOTE="darkspineslayer"][QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

darkspineslayer

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

People here act as if I'm the only person to have ever made this comparison......

as far as i've seen you are...nobody else has said its a platformer that i've seen

well I'm really not....but hey, I'm not gonna be confrontational about it, I just wanted to see what everyone thought was the better game.

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"][QUOTE="CB4McGusto"]

If your talking about fighters in general then you ought to be ashamed of yourself for this poll.

If just comparing the two listed in the title then SSBB because I haven't played Soul Casual 4. :P

DeathScape666

I really picked these two because

1. They are two of the biggest games of the year in the fighting genre....and...

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

Do you even know what a platformer is?

Brawl puts more of a emphasis on maneuverability (jumping and running) than the average fighter which is usually close ranged.

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

darkspineslayer

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

and mario galaxy is a shooter with platforming elements :P

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

darkspineslayer

by your logic...Halo is a platformer because your jumping and fighting...

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"][QUOTE="MikeE21286"][QUOTE="CB4McGusto"]

If your talking about fighters in general then you ought to be ashamed of yourself for this poll.

If just comparing the two listed in the title then SSBB because I haven't played Soul Casual 4. :P

Shinobishyguy

I really picked these two because

1. They are two of the biggest games of the year in the fighting genre....and...

2. Nintendo fans scream up and down that SSBB is a serious fighting game when it's almost more of a platformer

Do you even know what a platformer is?

Brawl puts more of a emphasis on maneuverability (jumping and running) than the average fighter which is usually close ranged.

Yeah but its still not much like a platformer.

I find SSBB more fun than SC4.

Don't get me wrong, though. SC4 is a great game too :D

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"][QUOTE="nVidiaGaMer"][QUOTE="DeathScape666"][QUOTE="nVidiaGaMer"][QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

nVidiaGaMer

Brawl is the worst game I've ever played.

No, it isn't. You are just saying that to show your extreme dislike for a highly popular game, but I'm sure there a lesser known games that have scored poorly that you disliked even more.

If you haven't, then I'm seriously surprised.

No I played the Wii at my friends house and I must say Zelda and Brawl are boring and the Wii is a childish console IMO.

You just lost all credibility with that statement. :|

There's a difference between "kiddy" and "family friendly fun."

Maybe if the Wii was out back in 98 then I would have fun with it but its geared towards young gamers.

The Wii shoes gamers that it's not all about being the best all the time btu actually ahving fun. We don't need M rated games to do that but somehow we lost track of this concept

as a traditional fighting game, SCIV is obviously better.

that being said, i believe SSBB can be just as balanced IF and only IF all the items are off including the final smashes.

as for me, i prefer brawl because SC games are too complicated to learn all the combos and everything for me. i just like how you can pick up smash and just play it almost as well as a world champion.

I own only a Wii and I must say SC4 is a much better game. SSBB is the most overhyped piece of crap.Jazunn

trust me you are wrong;)

Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionMikeE21286

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

In any case. traditional fighting games wipe the floor with it

SC,DOA,Tekken and virtua figher > SSB

[QUOTE="Jazunn"]I own only a Wii and I must say SC4 is a much better game. SSBB is the most overhyped piece of crap.fishfake

trust me you are wrong;)

Because someones opinion on a product can be wrong!:o

[QUOTE="Jazunn"]I own only a Wii and I must say SC4 is a much better game. SSBB is the most overhyped piece of crap.fishfake

trust me you are wrong;)

HIS opinion of a game is wrong?

Link?

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

In any case. traditional fighting games wipe the floor with it

SC,DOA,Tekken and virtua figher > SSB

and since sc4 is on ps3 and 360 ......

owned ?:roll:

you dont have a wii right ?:P

[QUOTE="fishfake"]

[QUOTE="Jazunn"]I own only a Wii and I must say SC4 is a much better game. SSBB is the most overhyped piece of crap.ukillwegrill

trust me you are wrong;)

HIS opinion of a game is wrong?

Link?

its just my opinion that he is wrong ! i dont need a link for that;)

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionfishfake

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

In any case. traditional fighting games wipe the floor with it

SC,DOA,Tekken and virtua figher > SSB

and since sc4 is on ps3 and 360 ......

owned ?:roll:

you dont have a wii right ?:P

Oh but i do.

Owned?

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"][QUOTE="fishfake"]

[QUOTE="Jazunn"]I own only a Wii and I must say SC4 is a much better game. SSBB is the most overhyped piece of crap.fishfake

trust me you are wrong;)

HIS opinion of a game is wrong?

Link?

its just my opinion that he is wrong ! i dont need a link for that;)

Is that even possible?

In any case. Well played sir, well played

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

And cows and lems will vote SC4.

Plus SC2 still superior

Your point?

[QUOTE="fishfake"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

In any case. traditional fighting games wipe the floor with it

SC,DOA,Tekken and virtua figher > SSB opinion

and since sc4 is on ps3 and 360 ......

owned ?:roll:

you dont have a wii right ? highly possible

Oh but i do.

Owned?

since it was a question no;)

but if owned looks that funny "picture" i think about it

I don't have SC IV yet, but I do love Brawl. The online isn't great, but I've heard from friends that SC IV sure does compete with Brawl's online... :( That's not good to hear...

So it sounds to me DOA 4 still has the best online... :D

I love DOA 4 though, and I'd probably say I prefer it more than the other fighters this gen, but we'll see. XD

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionmagiciandude

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

And cows and lems will vote SC4.

Plus SC1 is still superior

Your point?

The point was a poll is gonna fail. Can you not see that?

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"][QUOTE="fishfake"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionfishfake

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

In any case. traditional fighting games wipe the floor with it

SC,DOA,Tekken and virtua figher > SSB opinion

and since sc4 is on ps3 and 360 ......

owned ?:roll:

you dont have a wii right ? highly possible

Oh but i do.

Owned?

since it was a question no;)

but if owned looks that funny "picture" i think about it

And yes, it is a rather funny picture.

Fact is, i have a Wii, i dont like it, and i rather dislike SSBB.

[QUOTE="Gamer556"][QUOTE="Technoweirdo"][QUOTE="Gamer556"][QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

DeathScape666

Brawl's combat is awful. Each character has like 4 moves.

You're way off.

OK, that was an exaggeration. The game is still shallow as hell.

*Takes a look at your top rated games.*

What makes those games so deep, aside from a few, like Morrowind?

I couldn't even tell you what games I've reviewed right now. Never really got into to that feature. Besides, let's stick to the same genre. Compared to other fighting games, Brawl is extremely simple and unsatisfying. After a week of playing it I felt there was nothing more left to be done. In more traditional fighting games it takes much longer to master a character, and the competition level is usually much higher.

Not saying I'm a really good player after a week or anything, I just couldn't find a reason to keep playing (and neither could my friend, who owns it).

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"][QUOTE="Gamer556"][QUOTE="Technoweirdo"][QUOTE="Gamer556"][QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

Gamer556

Brawl's combat is awful. Each character has like 4 moves.

You're way off.

OK, that was an exaggeration. The game is still shallow as hell.

*Takes a look at your top rated games.*

What makes those games so deep, aside from a few, like Morrowind?

I couldn't even tell you what games I've reviewed right now. Never really got into to that feature. Besides, let's stick to the same genre. Compared to other fighting games, Brawl is extremely simple and unsatisfying. After a week of playing it I felt there was nothing more left to be done. In more traditional fighting games it takes much longer to master a character, and the competition level is usually much higher.

I agree.

Brawl is alot less competetive then most fighter. Even Meele was more competetive.

Butt for saying such things i get told im a "fakeboy" Although i happen to be female, and have the game .

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

Brawl has everything melee has and more.

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionShinobishyguy

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

Brawl has everything melee has and more.

It just seems toned down to be more casual.

It's far more forgiving

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

Brawl has everything melee has and more.

It just seems toned down to be more casual.

It's far more forgiving

In melee the top tiers were dominated only by the fast character such as marth, sheik, fox etc.

In brawl it's more varied.

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

Gamer556

Brawl's combat is awful. Each character has like 4 moves.

There was a very similar thread on the Soul Calibur 4 forum so I'll just copy and paste what I said there:

"This topic may has well be changed to "Are you a gimboid?"

If you answered: "LOL BRAWL/SOUL CALIBUR IS FOR DUM DUMZ U JUTS TAP DE BUTENS! IT SO SHALLO.", then yes.

If you answered: "Comparing the two is just plain silly!", then props to you."

[QUOTE="ukillwegrill"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionShinobishyguy

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

Brawl has everything melee has and more.

It just seems toned down to be more casual.

It's far more forgiving

In melee the top tiers were dominated only by the fast character such as marth, sheik, fox etc.

In brawl it's more varied.

Meta Knight is balanced?

[QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"][QUOTE="Shinobishyguy"][QUOTE="ukillwegrill"]

[QUOTE="MikeE21286"]Ok, so Soul Calibur 4 has just released and after playing it the thought came to my mind of.....which is a better fighting game, Soul Calibur 4 or SSBB? Thoughts/opinionukillwegrill

All the sheep will vote SSBB...you should remove it for being lame.

Add in SSBM, far superior.

Brawl has everything melee has and more.

It just seems toned down to be more casual.

It's far more forgiving

In melee the top tiers were dominated only by the fast character such as marth, sheik, fox etc.

In brawl it's more varied.

Meta Knight is balanced?

plus MK is very easy to knock away.

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

Brawl. The amount of modes and all the extra little additions just make it godly like. But really, it's the combat that kicks the crap out of Soul Calibur IV's. It's different. The characters aren't in close proximity, and there's just a lot of noticeable differences.

Super Smash that hoe!

nVidiaGaMer

Brawl is the worst game I've ever played.

Oh? Mind backing up your statement?

SC4 is just like all of the others.

SSBB reinvents the genre so people who dont even like fighters that much (like me) love the game. And the fact that there are over 40 characters just makes you want to buy it even more. If youre a fan of Snake, you'll buy it. Mario fanboy? Bought? Looking for a quality game starring sonic? Its a must-have.

For me, theres no contest.

SSBB because its one of the best local multiplayers games i have ever played.

SC4, because SSBB is not a fighting game to me. Don't get me wrong tho, SSBB is a great game, But it's like asking what's the best FPS between Halo3 and MGS4.Tykain

MGS4 IS NOT AN FPS AKA A FIRST PERSON SHOOTER. IT IS A STLEATH ACTION 3RD PERSON GAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1:x

[QUOTE="Tykain"]SC4, because SSBB is not a fighting game to me. Don't get me wrong tho, SSBB is a great game, But it's like asking what's the best FPS between Halo3 and MGS4.Sergeant343

MGS4 IS NOT AN FPS AKA A FIRST PERSON SHOOTER. IT IS A STLEATH ACTION 3RD PERSON GAME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1:x

That's the point...