Which game should have gotten a higher rating from GS?

Which game (in YOUR opinion) should have gotten a higher rating?

For me its MGS. It only got a 8.5!:(

Serously, MGS4 got a 10 but they give MGs a 8.5!:evil:

BTW,im new:)

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

identity crysis...

Mario Kart 64 and Diablo 2.

Mass Effect and Left4Dead

Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.godofwar2610

I would go with Shenmue, Mario Kart 64 and MGS probably.

Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.godofwar2610

fifa 09 should have got a 9.0 its the best overall sports game ever

most realistic gameplay

best graphics

i dont know about best licensing because madden there is only soldier field that isnt licensed so that goes to madden

• Sonic Unleashed
• Shinobi
• PixelJunk Eden
• Mirror's Edge
• Shenmue I & II
• The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
• The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
• Dead or Alive 3
• Last Bronx :evil:

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

identity crysis...

ImaPirate0202

[QUOTE="godofwar2610"]Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.jg4xchamp

amount of content =/= amount of replayability

YOU FAIL!

Uncharted.

Seriously this game should have gotten at least a 9 or 9.5

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"][QUOTE="godofwar2610"]Left 4 Dead, anyone thats played it will agree that it deserved at least a 9.5, it has the best replayability this gen.whatisazerg

amount of content =/= amount of replayability

YOU FAIL!

Fifa 09.........ras2009

This

[QUOTE="whatisazerg"]

[QUOTE="jg4xchamp"] objection, it launched as a 4 map game :| and the competitive MP was what a 2 map game. That was very little content for "best replayability this gen" Sure the game was something new, different, refreshing, and easily the best coop experience out there but best replayability this gen? not so much. Harry_Balzac

amount of content =/= amount of replayability

YOU FAIL!

I'm not saying what the game deserved for a score.... but claiming the game doesn't have great replayability and then saying the reason why is because it was low on content, simply doesn't make any sense.

[QUOTE="Harry_Balzac"][QUOTE="whatisazerg"]

amount of content =/= amount of replayability

YOU FAIL!

whatisazerg

I'm not saying what the game deserved for a score.... but claiming the game doesn't have great replayability and then saying the reason why is because it was low on content, simply doesn't make any sense.

Actually I would say that it makes a lot of sense

ICO, Shadow Of the Colossus and Uncharted should have got a 9.0

[QUOTE="Harry_Balzac"][QUOTE="whatisazerg"]

amount of content =/= amount of replayability

YOU FAIL!

whatisazerg

I'm not saying what the game deserved for a score.... but claiming the game doesn't have great replayability and then saying the reason why is because it was low on content, simply doesn't make any sense.

Super Mario Galaxy

Metroid Prime 3

Zelda Twilight Princess

Street Fighter 4

Little Big Planet

Metal Gear Solid

Zelda Majoras Mask

Valkyria Chronicles. That game deserved to be AAA. Should have gotten at least a 9. Such an awesome game.

Super Mario Galaxy

Metroid Prime 3

Zelda Twilight Princess

Street Fighter 4

Little Big Planet

Metal Gear Solid

Zelda Majoras Mask

chocolate1325

9.5 wasn't enough?

Halo wars and fifa, seriously 6.5 for such a great game?

[QUOTE="whatisazerg"]

[QUOTE="Harry_Balzac"] Left 4 Dead is good....But damn it is WAY too shallow to be a 9.5. I'd say the game got it's deserved score on here. It is good and belongs in my collection...But it has a plethorea of negatives that stop it being a aaa game this gen.....For starters the graphics are about on par with Haze..... It offers too little or next to nothing for the solo player experience to mention the two biggest flaws. It's positives is that it's a fun quick pick up and play, then throw away, fast paced arcade experience. But 9.5 on GS.....Please.macca404

I'm not saying what the game deserved for a score.... but claiming the game doesn't have great replayability and then saying the reason why is because it was low on content, simply doesn't make any sense.

Actually I would say that it makes a lot of sense

YOu and the other guy supporting the "low content = low replayability" argument.... need to look up the meaning of "REPLAY"ability.

Ratchet and Clank Future: Tools of Destruction

identity crysis...

ImaPirate0202

Uncharted Drake's Fortune & FIFA 09

Both should've got 9.0 IMO

Uncharted Drake's Fortune & FIFA 09

Both should've got 9.0 IMO

leo_andres_21

With Fifa 09 it seemed as though the review that was written didn't match the actual score.

Reading the review I thought it deserved 9.0 at least.

Vampire: the Masquerade Bloodlines and Deus Ex. No one who's played either of them can say with credibility that their scores were justified.

Freelancer
Vampire Bloodlines
Deus Ex
System Shock 2

zelda majoras mask

zone of the enders second runner

zelda tp

mario kart 64

metal gear solid

SMG (9,5 was not enough, considering gta4 and mgs4 got 10 lol)

metroid prime 3 corruption

madworld

System Shock 2, Deus Ex, and Metal Gear Solid 1 for me jg4xchamp

Mass Effect CrackdownPG_Chimp

Mount & Blade deserves a lot better than 6.0.

[QUOTE="PG_Chimp"]Mass Effect Crackdowncainetao11

Which game (in YOUR opinion) should have gotten a higher rating?

For me its MGS. It only got a 8.5!:(

Serously, MGS4 got a 10 but they give MGs a 8.5!:evil:

BTW,im new:)