[QUOTE="ChinoJamesKeene"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="ChinoJamesKeene"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="ChinoJamesKeene"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="ChinoJamesKeene"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="hornymushroom"] How could something like this exist. It's a disgrace to gaming and shows that people should just watch TV all day and THINK they're exercising when they really just leaning side to side. This is a big step back for the gaming industry.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_iYBmAVuBns
mjarantilla
No, it's the biggest step FORWARD since WiiSports, and WiiSports was the biggest step forward since Pong. Hardcore gamers like you who bash it are like action movie junkies who wish that Hollywood should only make, well, action movies.
Wii sports is the reason i got a Wii but honestly Wiifit is going too far. If i want to exercise i'll go outside and run around, we don't really need some elaborate condecending aerobics video telling us what to do for $150. The Wii is meant to be for escapism and entertainment, i just can't see what anybody would get from a game simulating mundane exercises that could be done for free.
Yeah i know there are sports simulations, but how many poeple can be part of a club and play every week? let alone play for a pro team, at least sports games let you have that.
WiiFit isn't for exercise, it's for monitoring. Sure, you can exercise, but WiiFit provides detailed and helpful tools that you would otherwise have to create yourself (tracking graphs, comparisons, etc.). Exercise alone does no one any good unless the exerciser goes overboard with his workouts. Most people WANT to get fit, but most people can't be bothered with taking the time to track themselves getting fit. WiiFit does it for them. It lets them see their results in real-time, and with no more effort than it takes to change a TV channel.
Just as an analogous example, take hybrid cars. Part of the reason they help people save so much gas is because most hybrid cars have built-in mileage monitoring capabilities built right into the dashboard. Having that kind of at-your-fingertips, instant feedback goes a LONG way towards motivating you to keep up your positive momentum.
Yeah you could use it like that, but its being marketed as a fitness solution in itself. It's also pretty much pointless to track how fit you are getting, you should feel it when you are exerting yourself not looking at charts with happy stick figures underneath. If you want to get fit you are going to have to work to do it and you aren't going to get that stepping on and off that balance board, no amount of positive re-enforcement Wiifit gives you is really going to motivate you further than your own resolve.
Wrong. It's proven that even mild activity like Half an hour of walking and some yoga can have a significant impact on your fitness. WiiFit IS a fitness solution BECAUSE it provides positive reinforcement. Why do you think people hire personal trainers anyway, and why do you think those people see so many more benefits from their workouts than people who don't hire them? It's ALL about positive reinforcement. Having WiiFit doesn't preclude you from jogging or from lifting weights. It just helps you see the benefit. And the added exercises of WiiFit -- steps and yoga, among others -- are both proven to be effective fitness boosters.
So basically you are saying if you can get up to walk for 30mins you don't need Wiifit. Poeple get personal trainers because of the instruction they give about strengthening specific muscle groups and overall advise, but thats practical and logical. I just have trouble believing poeple would hold their computer generated stats as greater indicator of progress over the way they feel.
Oh my GOD, are you dyslexic? Can't you read when I say WIIFIT HELPS YOU TO MONITOR YOUR PROGRESS?
Here let me say it again. In nice, bolded, italicized, underlined, capitalized text:
WIIFIT HELPS YOU TO MONITOR YOUR PROGRESS.
It's seven words, none of them with more than three syllables. It CAN'T be that hard to understand.
And YES, personal trainers provide that level of instruction, too, but that's why personal trainers charge so much.
Basically you're just denying that positive reinforcement has any impact at all on a person's motivation to exercise. And that is just a stupid idea.
Is there really any need to personally attack me?
Maybe you need to work on your comprehension since I've already adressed your point twice. Maybe I should just accept that there are plenty of weak minded morons that need Wiifit to pat them on the back every week to keep exercising.
You basically summized that doing anything is better than nothing for your fitness and that Wiifit fits the bill.
First, read my edit.
Second, you can do your taxes without help, too, but most people still buy TurboTax because it takes away the hassle. It's not about being weak-minded, it's just about being inconvenienced. If you want to see REAL progress, you NEED feedback. Sure, you can do your thirty minute walk every day and HOPE you're making progress, but WiiFit SHOWS you your progress.
THAT is what you keep ignoring. You havent' "addressed" anything. You've been IGNORING everything because you keep thinking that WiiFit is supposed to REPLACE exercise. It's NOT. It's supposed to make exercise EASIER by removing the tedium of progress logging. Is that a BAD thing? Because it's just about the only product out there that actually does it (the Nike+iPod dongle does it, too, but only for jogging).
Well, I'm sorry if that what you think Im saying but im not ignoring your point. It your body, i don't think its fair to compare it to a tax return. It may hold some value for poeple, fair enough but i just figure since it's your health the feedback should be apparent and you should probably be exercising with some goal in mind. I'll just leave it at that.
Log in to comment