Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
This topic is locked from further discussion.
Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
[QUOTE="BuryMe"]Can we get a more reliable source, please?XenogearsMaster
You know there isn't any other site that does world wide sales... Why ask?
You know why that is? Because NPD does monthly US figures and Japan gets weekly ones. BUT there are NO accurate sources for the PAL region. No one gathers that data, so its pure guesswork, nothing else. What you think VGChartz calls up a couple of hundred stores in each ofFrance, Germany, Uk, Italy, Spain, Poland, Hungary, etc? Nope they make an absolute GUESS. Thats why any respectable poster on this site treat VGchartz weekly sales as a joke, especially for Europe.EDIT and before you get on your fanboy high horse think about this. Why do NO respectable gaming sites use VGcartz figures? Go ahead and check, not one.
[QUOTE="tango90101"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="tango90101"]even more sad is that you have to resort to personal attacks rather than addressing the issue..not suprising tho..
XenogearsMaster
The issue is that you don't have to believe in their numbers, they said it on their site that they're not 100% accurate. Going about it like, "OMgZ VGchartz hurts my feezlings, so I'm going keep bashing it without proof and it will make me feel better" is completely sad.
then cows need to stop using them as "proof".. that's all he was saying...
they're not official. they're not accurate. they're not accountable.
They're actually accurate.... enough...
Hence, they're proof.
"accurate enough"?
wow..that's reassuring..... but certainly not proof... on any level...
maybe to cows (as long as it shows the ps3 in a good light) ...but if you would have noticed last year, their 360 sales didn't move for months...
i guess NOONE bought a 360 for months, right?
i'd put their accuracy right about where SDF.com's accuracy is...
regardless, accurate means accurate... not guessing...
Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
XenogearsMaster
EDIT: If I said what I really wanted to say, I'd be banned from the goddamn internet, never mind System Wars.
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="BuryMe"]Can we get a more reliable source, please?blue_hazy_basic
You know there isn't any other site that does world wide sales... Why ask?
You know why that is? Because NPD does monthly US figures and Japan gets weekly ones. BUT there are NO accurate sources for the PAL region. No one gathers that data, so its pure guesswork, nothing else. What you think VGChartz calls up a couple of hundred stores in each ofFrance, Germany, Uk, Italy, Spain, Poland, Hungary, etc? Nope they make an absolute GUESS. Thats why any respectable poster on this site treat VGchartz weekly sales as a joke, especially for Europe.You have no proof of that.
[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="BuryMe"]Can we get a more reliable source, please?XenogearsMaster
You know there isn't any other site that does world wide sales... Why ask?
You know why that is? Because NPD does monthly US figures and Japan gets weekly ones. BUT there are NO accurate sources for the PAL region. No one gathers that data, so its pure guesswork, nothing else. What you think VGChartz calls up a couple of hundred stores in each ofFrance, Germany, Uk, Italy, Spain, Poland, Hungary, etc? Nope they make an absolute GUESS. Thats why any respectable poster on this site treat VGchartz weekly sales as a joke, especially for Europe.You have no proof of that.
What do you mean no proof? If there are reliable figures why does no where publish them? Don't be dense!And as I said in my edit, if VGchartz is even vaguely reliable, why does no reliable gaming site use those figures for Europe? (or for the US weekly figures they guess for that matter)
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
mjarantilla
How ****ing old are you? Six? Five? No, you'd have to be a goddamn FETUS to even think something as ignorant as that. How the HELL did you manage to make it to 1,400 posts on this forum without breaking down from the terrible verbal abuse you must have endured from other posters here?
I'm 22... Telephone calls and polls... come on now.
[QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
XenogearsMaster
How ****ing old are you? Six? Five? No, you'd have to be a goddamn FETUS to even think something as ignorant as that. How the HELL did you manage to make it to 1,400 posts on this forum without breaking down from the terrible verbal abuse you must have endured from other posters here?
I'm 22... Telephone calls and polls... come on now.
NPD runs polls involving THOUSANDS of participants.
VGChartz calls maybe a couple of dozen stores.
Interesting. PS3 does have some good exclusives that are coming this year or the start of next. No one can deny that.p4ddym
What goodexclusives are still coming this year? and the start of next? all I can think of is LBP, what are the others?
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="BuryMe"]Can we get a more reliable source, please?blue_hazy_basic
You know there isn't any other site that does world wide sales... Why ask?
You know why that is? Because NPD does monthly US figures and Japan gets weekly ones. BUT there are NO accurate sources for the PAL region. No one gathers that data, so its pure guesswork, nothing else. What you think VGChartz calls up a couple of hundred stores in each ofFrance, Germany, Uk, Italy, Spain, Poland, Hungary, etc? Nope they make an absolute GUESS. Thats why any respectable poster on this site treat VGchartz weekly sales as a joke, especially for Europe.You have no proof of that.
What do you mean no proof? If there are reliable figures why does no where publish them? Don't be dense!And as I said in my edit, if VGchartz is even vaguely reliable, why does no reliable gaming site use those figures for Europe? (or for the US weekly figures they guess for that matter)
I think there is another that does European sales.
But as for the question, they're an independant group. They do this for free.
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]mjanrantilla, just get over it. It's like VGchartz hurted your feelings at some point.mjarantilla
They did, by pretending that they can ever be an alternative to official sources. They're an insult to professionals who earned their station, like faith healers pretending to be doctors, writers who pay publishers to print their books, and people who buy their "education" from a diploma mill.
Now, that is sad....
You're a sad boy. :(
For caring about professional integrity? I think it's sad to ignore it, and utterly pathetic to promote it.
EDIT: Actually, not just pathetic. It's despicable. At least they haven't started charging anyone for their numbers.
Yet.
It's like you're offended by their numbers. Care to tell me how accurate NPD is with actual proof.
I can't explain anything to you if you know nothing about statistics. And if you knew anything about statistics, you would be agreeing with me about VGChartz. So what's the point of trying to explain anything?
Here's the raw information:
- NPD gathers data from over 60% of all retailers.
- NPD conducts polls and surveys involving thousands of actual buyers to compensate for the 40% that they are missing
- The demographics of those surveys are recorded and factored into the final statistical calculations
I only took statistics in my third year for my engineering degree, so I'm missing the finer points of market analysis. But the fundamental principles of statistics point to the conclusion that NPD has MORE than enough data to achieve a margin of error of less than 5% for 95% of their estimates. In fact, it's possible that their ACTUAL precision can be as low as 0.1% margin of error for 99% of their estimates, depending on their actual methodology, which they don't disclose.
VGChartz gathers data from ONLY small and independent retailers. They REGULARLY miss the mark by tens of thousands of units every single month. Yet for some reason people here trust them? Is one month really so long to wait?
I liked VGChartz back when they were VGCharts.org and they only ever compiled official data without making their own speculations.
So NPD just gives people polls andgather datas? LOL, NPD is no different from VGchartz.
No point in trying to explain to him. He's obvioulsy no older than 14 and can't quite comprehend what you're saying to him. Don't blame him, blame his school.
Edti: I'm talking to mjarantill. Something tells me XenogearsMaster isn't very bright.
I think there is another that does European sales.So where do they get their european data from? Why don't sites like Gamespot publish euro numbers lik e they do for Japan and the US? You know why? BECAUSE THERE AREN'T ANY! Feel free to prove me wrong. You won't be able to though.But as for the question, they're an independant group. They do this for free.
XenogearsMaster
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"][QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]Come on now... polls and telephone calls...?
That's hilarious. VGchartz is practically doing the same. LOL.
mjarantilla
How ****ing old are you? Six? Five? No, you'd have to be a goddamn FETUS to even think something as ignorant as that. How the HELL did you manage to make it to 1,400 posts on this forum without breaking down from the terrible verbal abuse you must have endured from other posters here?
I'm 22... Telephone calls and polls... come on now.
NPD runs polls involving THOUSANDS of participants.
VGChartz calls maybe a couple of dozen stores.
The thing is you keep on assumming...
No point in trying to explain to him. He's obvioulsy no older than 14 and can't quite comprehend what you're saying to him. Don't blame him, blame his school.
kingtito
I don't think he ever went to school.
[QUOTE="mjarantilla"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]I'm 22... Telephone calls and polls... come on now.
XenogearsMaster
NPD runs polls involving THOUSANDS of participants.
VGChartz calls maybe a couple of dozen stores.
The thing is you keep on assumming...
I'm not assuming anything.
[QUOTE="kingtito"]No point in trying to explain to him. He's obvioulsy no older than 14 and can't quite comprehend what you're saying to him. Don't blame him, blame his school.
mjarantilla
I don't think he ever went to school.
Even if he did, he obviously failed the ECON and STAT classes.
[QUOTE="kingtito"]No point in trying to explain to him. He's obvioulsy no older than 14 and can't quite comprehend what you're saying to him. Don't blame him, blame his school.
mjarantilla
I don't think he ever went to school.
Assuming...
VgCharts (Europe)actually fones Game which has over 700 stores across western Europe and acounts for 72% of game/console sales.the other 28% is a quess so it is techinically more reliable than NPD Americas results.
(I bet my post gets over looked for not being fanboy enougth btw)
[QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]I think there is another that does European sales.So where do they get their european data from? Why don't sites like Gamespot publish euro numbers lik e they do for Japan and the US? You know why? BECAUSE THERE AREN'T ANY! Feel free to prove me wrong. You won't be able to though.But as for the question, they're an independant group. They do this for free.
blue_hazy_basic
Atually there is a website called chart-track that runs numbers for the UK,Republic of Ireland and Denmark in detail and gets around 50% of other european data but quesses the rest much in the same way as NPD
Admit your pawned and i will be on my way :D
VgCharts (Europe)actually fones Game which has over 700 stores across western Europe and acounts for 72% of game/console sales.the other 28% is a quess so it is techinically more reliable than NPD Americas results.
(I bet my post gets over looked for not being fanboy enougth btw)
muff07
ARe there any links to back all those claims up?
I would specifically love to see a link about Game's supposed 72% sales of all of Europe.
[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="XenogearsMaster"]I think there is another that does European sales.So where do they get their european data from? Why don't sites like Gamespot publish euro numbers lik e they do for Japan and the US? You know why? BECAUSE THERE AREN'T ANY! Feel free to prove me wrong. You won't be able to though.But as for the question, they're an independant group. They do this for free.
muff07
Atually there is a website called chart-track that runs numbers for the UK,Republic of Ireland and Denmark in detail and gets around 50% of other european data but quesses the rest much in the same way as NPD
Admit your pawned and i will be on my way :D
Actually the UK and Ireland do keep track of their sales, I never said otherwise, I was talking about the PAL countries (and specifically European sales which VGchartz punlishes). Didn't know about Denmark. However as this counts towards what somthing like 6 or 7% of Europe and the British and Irish have very different buying habits from the rest of Europe this is not ownage. In fact what you have demonstrated is that apart from the UK, Ireland and, I'll take your word for it, Denmark as I said there is no data for the PAL countries.Ownage denied.
Game only has stores and franchises in UK, Eire, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Spain, Portugal andFrance. Do you have a link a) to back up what you said. b) what about info from all the other countries. every european country has its own character and buying habits you can't extrapolate continent wide data from one country and apply it to another.VgCharts (Europe)actually fones Game which has over 700 stores across western Europe and acounts for 72% of game/console sales.the other 28% is a quess so it is techinically more reliable than NPD Americas results.
(I bet my post gets over looked for not being fanboy enougth btw)
muff07
EDIT and c) with no stores in countries like Germany, Holland, Belgium, Italy or any of eastern europe how can they possibly account for 72 % of console sales Europe wide?
I fear sir I have to say LAIR LAIR PANTS ON FIRE
[QUOTE="muff07"]Game only has stores and franchises in UK, Eire, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Spain, Portugal andFrance. Do you have a link a) to back up what you said. b) what about info from all the other countries. every european country has its own character and buying habits you can't extrapolate continent wide data from one country and apply it to another.VgCharts (Europe)actually fones Game which has over 700 stores across western Europe and acounts for 72% of game/console sales.the other 28% is a quess so it is techinically more reliable than NPD Americas results.
(I bet my post gets over looked for not being fanboy enougth btw)
blue_hazy_basic
EDIT and c) with no stores in countries like Germany, Holland, Belgium, Italy or any of eastern europe how can they possibly account for 72 % of console sales Europe wide?
beacuse the UK ireland and france on there own are 60% of the European market
Eatern europe is very small in video games terms due to them being very deprived(athlough recovering) former comunist countries
LMAO no no no nohttp://www.chart-track.co.uk/index.jsp?c=p/software/euro/index.jsp
can i claim ownage now?
muff07
you have to actually provide a link to somewhere that provides the information. What they in fact provide is UNITED KINGDOM only hardware sales!
http://www.chart-track.co.uk/index.jsp?c=p/hardware/index.jsp
Doh :lol:
[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="muff07"]Game only has stores and franchises in UK, Eire, Sweden, Denmark, Norway, Spain, Portugal andFrance. Do you have a link a) to back up what you said. b) what about info from all the other countries. every european country has its own character and buying habits you can't extrapolate continent wide data from one country and apply it to another.VgCharts (Europe)actually fones Game which has over 700 stores across western Europe and acounts for 72% of game/console sales.the other 28% is a quess so it is techinically more reliable than NPD Americas results.
(I bet my post gets over looked for not being fanboy enougth btw)
muff07
EDIT and c) with no stores in countries like Germany, Holland, Belgium, Italy or any of eastern europe how can they possibly account for 72 % of console sales Europe wide?
beacuse the UK ireland and france on there own are 60% of the European market
Eatern europe is very small in video games terms due to them being very deprived(athlough recovering) former comunist countries
Wait, where'd your evidence that VGChartz gets information from Game?
Now where are you're other links to
1) Game makes up 72% of console sales
and
2) Game supplies VGChartz with their figures.
lol don't use wiki kiddo. Go here http://www.gamegroup.plc.uk/gg/about/business/ and you can find the proper info you're looking for. I'm from the UK and I doubt that Game has even a 70% market share there. and covering maybe a 1/4 of europe how is it possible to have a 72% share of the whole euro market when you MAYBE have that much in the area you do cover. You're talking utter nonsense and you're embarrasing yourself.http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GAME_%28retailer%29
and theres the link about game having over 700 stores
muff07
I doubt its 72% as well but wikipedia is the best source of information that i have.
muff07
Even if it was 72%, you still haven't given any evidence that says GAME gives VGChartz their numbers.
and thats why I provided you with Game's own web page on its business. Wiki is good for certain things, business facts are not one.I doubt its 72% as well but wikipedia is the best source of information that i have.
muff07
Chart track only provides UK hardware sales not europe wide!!! for gods sake do you read your own links?I think Gamespot should register with chart-track so that they can post the hardware sales and it would stop arguments like this.
muff07
[QUOTE="muff07"]and thats why I provided you with Game's own web page on its business. Wiki is good for certain things, business facts are not one.I doubt its 72% as well but wikipedia is the best source of information that i have.
blue_hazy_basic
Wiki is pretty good overall though.
[QUOTE="muff07"]http://www.chart-track.co.uk/index.jsp?c=p/software/euro/index.jsp
can i claim ownage now?
LosDaddie
You could claim ownage if that link provided any info.
Nice try though
you have to become a registered member of the website and pay the fee to get the information.
chart-track is a very poor website but it doesn't actually post any sales numbers just what is in which position for software
[QUOTE="muff07"]Chart track only provides UK hardware sales not europe wide!!! for gods sake do you read your own links?I think Gamespot should register with chart-track so that they can post the hardware sales and it would stop arguments like this.
blue_hazy_basic
-------------------------------------------------------------
Chart-Track in conjunction with GFK produce the only software market report to cover Europe. The report is based on software sales from 11 European territories:
Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom.
Data is compiled from more than 12,000 European retail outlets, including:
Blockbuster, Comet, Game, Woolworths, Dixons, PC World, Virgin, WH Smith, Fnac, Media Märkte, Kaufhof, Hertie, Expert, karstadt, Contiente, Neckermann, Kykshop, Citta Mercato, faref, ITI, Zattarin, Hom...
The formats covered are:
PC Games, Sony Playstation, Sony Playstation 2, Nintendo Gamecube, Nintendo Gameboy, GBC, GB Advance, GBA SP, Microsoft Xbox, Nokia N-Gage.
For pricing and further details please contact Chris Poole: cpoole@chart-track.co
When did Italy and France join the UK?
[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="muff07"]and thats why I provided you with Game's own web page on its business. Wiki is good for certain things, business facts are not one.I doubt its 72% as well but wikipedia is the best source of information that i have.
LosDaddie
Wiki is pretty good overall though.
yes and no. the problem is anyone can edit it, so while the overall article may be ok, certain facts but be wildly inaccurate either through accidently or deliberate design. (I've taught courses and our students weren't allowed to use wiki as a reference, although they can use wiki to find other references)[QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"][QUOTE="muff07"]Chart track only provides UK hardware sales not europe wide!!! for gods sake do you read your own links?I think Gamespot should register with chart-track so that they can post the hardware sales and it would stop arguments like this.
muff07
-------------------------------------------------------------
Chart-Track in conjunction with GFK produce the only software market report to cover Europe. The report is based on software sales from 11 European territories:
Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Ireland, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal, Spain, Sweden and United Kingdom.
Data is compiled from more than 12,000 European retail outlets, including:
Blockbuster, Comet, Game, Woolworths, Dixons, PC World, Virgin, WH Smith, Fnac, Media Märkte, Kaufhof, Hertie, Expert, karstadt, Contiente, Neckermann, Kykshop, Citta Mercato, faref, ITI, Zattarin, Hom...
The formats covered are:
PC Games, Sony Playstation, Sony Playstation 2, Nintendo Gamecube, Nintendo Gameboy, GBC, GB Advance, GBA SP, Microsoft Xbox, Nokia N-Gage.
For pricing and further details please contact Chris Poole: cpoole@chart-track.co
When did Italy and France join the UK?
Thats for SOFTWARE!!!!HARDWARE!!! ---->http://www.chart-track.co.uk/index.jsp?c=p/hardware/index.jsp
Chart-Track monitors sales each week of all the major games consoles: Sony Playstation, Sony Playstation 2,Sony Playstation 3, Sony PSP, Sony PSP Slim & Lite,Nintendo Wii, Nintendo DS, Nintendo DS Lite, Nintendo Gamecube, Gameboy Advance, Microsoft XBox and Microsoft Xbox 360. Data is available to subscribers every Monday afternoon on the previous week's UK sales (via email).
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment