X360 has one shot at a 2008 AAAE or higher

:lol: last year PS3 fanboys were begging not to use GS scores

this year 360 fanboys are begging not to use GS scores :lol:

SW has always come down to GS scores, no getting around it.

Lets just face it, as far as GS and SW is concerned:

2007: 360 = great and PS3 = sad

2008: 360 = sad and PS3 = great

abdelmessih101

you guys realize MGS4 has it already, You guys should know gamespot is biased as hell, an considering probably most of the reviewers grew up and loved MGS, well that should be self explanator, personally i think little big planet should get it even though i loved MGS4hikari33

biased to what? the metal gear solid series?

i really thought Fable2 would get AAA

I know Gears 2 will get AAA

Banjo will proably get 8-8.5

Mkavanaugh77

[QUOTE="abdelmessih101"]

:lol: last year PS3 fanboys were begging not to use GS scores

this year 360 fanboys are begging not to use GS scores :lol:

SW has always come down to GS scores, no getting around it.

Lets just face it, as far as GS and SW is concerned:

2007: 360 = great and PS3 = sad

2008: 360 = sad and PS3 = great

Baird-06

I never said I listened to Gamespot's reviews, I specifically stated that as far as GS and SW is concerned those things are true. I just find it hilarious what a difference a year makes - everyone here seems to have a short selective memory and I love the irony. Next time actually read what I wrote before trying to make a smart ass remark, because you'll get burned like this every time. ;)

[QUOTE="Mkavanaugh77"]

i really thought Fable2 would get AAA

I know Gears 2 will get AAA

Banjo will proably get 8-8.5

theironstallion

it isn´t.

I´m thinking you are a fakeboy

i really thought Fable2 would get AAA

I know Gears 2 will get AAA

Banjo will proably get 8-8.5

Mkavanaugh77

I doubt you've played the first fable then, most people who think fable 2 will get AAA were just feeding into the hype

[QUOTE="DeathScape666"]

I've been praying to God all year for Gears of War 2 to flop.

And God likes me.

Slashkice

I hope it does. SW would be goddamned hilarious if Gears flopped.

Yeah no. Who the hell WANTS a game to fail? That's just stupid.

[QUOTE="Mkavanaugh77"]

i really thought Fable2 would get AAA

I know Gears 2 will get AAA

Banjo will proably get 8-8.5

All_that_is_Man

I doubt you've played the first fable then, most people who think fable 2 will get AAA were just feeding into the hype

[QUOTE="hikari33"]you guys realize MGS4 has it already, You guys should know gamespot is biased as hell, an considering probably most of the reviewers grew up and loved MGS, well that should be self explanator, personally i think little big planet should get it even though i loved MGS4CaseyWegner

biased to what? the metal gear solid series?

how come you dont close most of these threads since they cant provide a link to backup their claims?

My thread that you closed earlier was not even half bad as some of the claims in this thread and you didnt give me a chance to find a link or something to back it up, I got it now.

[QUOTE="abdelmessih101"]

:lol: last year PS3 fanboys were begging not to use GS scores

this year 360 fanboys are begging not to use GS scores :lol:

SW has always come down to GS scores, no getting around it.

Lets just face it, as far as GS and SW is concerned:

2007: 360 = great and PS3 = sad

2008: 360 = sad and PS3 = great

theironstallion

It's pretty much implied that we're only talking about retail games. PSN / XBLA games have always been left out.

[QUOTE="epic_pets"]

[QUOTE="ExtremeOne316"]The PS3 has only one AAA game this year and thats MGS 4. Microsoft will answer that with its own AAA Game and thats Gears of War 2
ExtremeOne316

Little big planet is AAA

Oh ok so it has 2 and Gears of War 2 will be a bigger hit sales wise than LBP

cool. so how much will you profit from geow2's sales success? i just wanna know so i can get in on this.

Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. GeoW2 and Left 4 Dead have a good chance at being AAAE. Not sure about the Last Remnant. XanderZane

it's barely AAA on gamerankings and could easily drop down to AA.

Why are people so god damn obssessed with GameSpot scoring things AAA? Mass Effect and Fable 2 are a couple of the best games on the 360, and guess what? They're not AAA! Teh shocker! :oBaird-06

Their not AAA on Gamespot, but most normal people could care less. I'm not obsessed with Gamespot scores at all. I get my numbers from GameRankings.com.

***************************************************************

besides. geow2 will MOST LIKELY (99%) chance of going to the pc. therefore..by my calculations....no AAAE?mclovin401

You must have missed the Cliffy B. interview. Doesn't look like GeoW 2 will be coming to the PC.

Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. GeoW2 and Left 4 Dead have a good chance at being AAAE. Not sure about the Last Remnant. XanderZane

[QUOTE="XanderZane"]Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. GeoW2 and Left 4 Dead have a good chance at being AAAE. Not sure about the Last Remnant. CaseyWegner

it's barely AAA on gamerankings and could easily drop down to AA.

GS Score of Uncharted and R&C prove you wrong.

Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. GeoW2 and Left 4 Dead have a good chance at being AAAE. Not sure about the Last Remnant. XanderZane

gears = MGS4

LBP = Fable 2

L4D = R2
theironstallion

lol. close but this is how it REALY is.

mgs4= PERFECT.....geow2 = (yet to be decided). but it will be (according to GS scores that is) on par with mgs4 or worse.

LBP > fable 2

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]There is now no way for the 360 to "win" 2008, the PS3's library has beaten it for this year. It can only happen if both Gears 2 and Banjo scroe AAAAE. delaystation3

If Gears 2 scores AAAAE and gets GOTY i would argue the x360 won because it would have the best game in 2008 on it. I dont want to play a number of shatter games i want to play the best.

Well if you compare just one game versus two games lbp and mgs4 I would still think the ps3 won... 10.0 against 10.0 than sony has its 9.0 LBp and don't forget about Resistance 2 which has a chance at AAA. I still think it will get 8.5 though.

[QUOTE="theironstallion"]gears = MGS4

LBP = Fable 2

L4D = R2
mclovin401

lol. close but this is how it REALY is.

mgs4= PERFECT.....geow2 = (yet to be decided). but it will be (according to GS scores that is) on par with mgs4 or worse.

LBP > fable 2

LBP does not equal fable 2....

GEOW not rated yet but will get AAA I know that, but will it get AAAA? TIme will tell

L4D its multiplat R2 isn't

gears = MGS4

LBP = Fable 2

L4D = R2
theironstallion

Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. XanderZane

[QUOTE="theironstallion"]gears = MGS4

LBP = Fable 2

L4D = R2
mclovin401

lol. close but this is how it REALY is.

mgs4= PERFECT.....geow2 = (yet to be decided). but it will be (according to GS scores that is) on par with mgs4 or worse.

LBP > fable 2

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]There is now no way for the 360 to "win" 2008, the PS3's library has beaten it for this year. It can only happen if both Gears 2 and Banjo scroe AAAAE. superjim42

this

ps3 still has resistence 2, motorstorm 2, socom, naruto which looks A-AA material and maybe few others for this year.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Lemmings are whinning now (no offense) ?

Cows had to put up with this stuff up to the release of MGS4.

Fable = AAE

The 360 does only have 1 shot for a AAAE title, and thats Gears 2 but it WILL be AAAE cause the game will own.

Nisim19

no, gears 2 will be AAA because its a shooter and not RPG like FABLE (or mass effect)

dont be a fanboy we all know that fable 2 is realy an AAA game like mass effect.

Im not being a fanboy, the game got an 8.5 , not a 9.

[QUOTE="theironstallion"]gears = MGS4

LBP = Fable 2

L4D = R2
desyple

[QUOTE="superjim42"]

[QUOTE="Floppy_Jim"]There is now no way for the 360 to "win" 2008, the PS3's library has beaten it for this year. It can only happen if both Gears 2 and Banjo scroe AAAAE. diped

this

ps3 still has resistence 2, motorstorm 2, socom, naruto which looks A-AA material and maybe few others for this year.

Well socom got messed up by sony and its bad servers. Don't even know why they had a beta if they still had problems. Naruto if you read from previews from all other sites they are pretty stoked about it I say it will get AA. Resistance 2 now that game has potential for AAA. Than there is valkyria chronicles which can also be AAA but probaly most likely AA. Motorstorm 2 definately AA

[QUOTE="Nisim19"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Lemmings are whinning now (no offense) ?

Cows had to put up with this stuff up to the release of MGS4.

Fable = AAE

The 360 does only have 1 shot for a AAAE title, and thats Gears 2 but it WILL be AAAE cause the game will own.

Nonstop-Madness

no, gears 2 will be AAA because its a shooter and not RPG like FABLE (or mass effect)

dont be a fanboy we all know that fable 2 is realy an AAA game like mass effect.

Im not being a fanboy, the game got an 8.5 , not a 9.

Fable 2 should have been AAAE. Too bad Gamespot don't know how to score games. It's AAAE on Gamerankings. GeoW2 and Left 4 Dead have a good chance at being AAAE. Not sure about the Last Remnant. XanderZane

Uncharted is now AAAe too :shock:

And L4D is multi, and the better version will be the the PC one

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="Nisim19"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Lemmings are whinning now (no offense) ?

Cows had to put up with this stuff up to the release of MGS4.

Fable = AAE

The 360 does only have 1 shot for a AAAE title, and thats Gears 2 but it WILL be AAAE cause the game will own.

theironstallion

no, gears 2 will be AAA because its a shooter and not RPG like FABLE (or mass effect)

dont be a fanboy we all know that fable 2 is realy an AAA game like mass effect.

Im not being a fanboy, the game got an 8.5 , not a 9.

Because you are in Gamespot Forums, plus it a System Wars Rule.

[QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"][QUOTE="Nisim19"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Lemmings are whinning now (no offense) ?

Cows had to put up with this stuff up to the release of MGS4.

Fable = AAE

The 360 does only have 1 shot for a AAAE title, and thats Gears 2 but it WILL be AAAE cause the game will own.

Nonstop-Madness

no, gears 2 will be AAA because its a shooter and not RPG like FABLE (or mass effect)

dont be a fanboy we all know that fable 2 is realy an AAA game like mass effect.

Im not being a fanboy, the game got an 8.5 , not a 9.

Because you are in Gamespot Forums, plus it a System Wars Rule.

Don't listen to this cow. Show me a rule book for SW. Exactly their isn't one. We all know 50 opinions > 1 opinion.

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

Nonstop-Madness

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

theironstallion

and uncharted, just respond this

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25700934

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26147540

Owned

[QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

Giancar

and uncharted, just respond this

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

theironstallion

From the stickied threads:

"The official policies of System Wars currently dictate that only GameSpot scores count, however other sites are often used to attempt to predict GameSpot's review scores"

In SW, yes, GS and only GS decides it.

[QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

abdelmessih101

From the stickied threads:

"The official policies of System Wars currently dictate that only GameSpot scores count, however other sites are often used to attempt to predict GameSpot's review scores"

In SW, yes, GS and only GS decides it.

[QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

theironstallion

and uncharted, just respond this

yeah first gamerankings now metacritic :|but lets wait until more fable 2 reviews come, oh and the fable 2 review is 89, not 89,7 over there

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25700934

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26147540

Owned

Nonstop-Madness

[QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Giancar"][QUOTE="theironstallion"][QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

Fable 2 = 8.5 =/= AAAE

LBP = 9.0 = AAAE

Fable is not a AAAE game

We need a moderator to explain the rules.

Giancar

and uncharted, just respond this

yeah first gamerankings now metacritic :|but lets wait until more fable 2 reviews come, oh and the fable 2 review is 89, not 89,7 over there

Don't listen to this cow. Show me a rule book for SW. Exactly their isn't one. We all know 50 opinions > 1 opinion.

WILL THE LEMMING LEADER PLEASE STAND UP AND EXPLAIN THE RULES THAT WERE CREATED by LEMMINGS.

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=25700934

http://www.gamespot.com/pages/forums/show_msgs.php?topic_id=26147540

Owned

theironstallion

Nobody cares what Gamespot considers a AAA title, but those are the rules and basis for discusision on this forum. We all have our own opinions and agree/disagree with whatever review site we want, and that's all well and good, but none of it applies to this forum.