Will anyone NOT be buying LA Noire?

[QUOTE="Lord_Nuclear"]

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"] You sound like one of those fools that bought a Yugo. I drive a Toyota, I like things to last, that is a BIG part of the value.HilbillyRokstar

Haha. No, I don't have a Yugo. And I agree that a Toyota holds its value. I like things that last, too. My point was that he should get the game regardless of how many hours it takes. The fact that you claim it is only 17 hours is irrelevent. It depends on if someone blows through the game or does every little thing that determines how long it really takes. So, if he is really interested in the game, it shouldn't matter if he spends 17 hours on the game or 10. It isn't the same as comparing a $60 game to a car. Also, sometimes the quality of the game can bring more value than the length of the game. I would much rather play a 10 hour game that is amazing than play a 17 hour game that sucks just because it has length.

[QUOTE="sir_dandan"][QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"] I'm wrong am I? You never just said just 17? [QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"] I'm gonna rent it. It has no multiplayer and the game is about 17 hrs long. So for me it is not a buy.HilbillyRokstar

Here's my ORIGINAL statement.HilbillyRokstar

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]

[QUOTE="sir_dandan"] Well done, you sure proved me wrong... sir_dandan

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]]Have you NEVER misspoke? I showed you my original statement.But you just won't be happy till you get your pound of flesh. I said 18-25 the guy before me mentioned 17 hrs and I mis-spoke. That's all. No biiggie unless your'e the kind of jerk that can't let it go. Thanks for admitting you wre wrong, though sir_dandan

Let it go.HilbillyRokstar

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]Let it go.sir_dandan

[QUOTE="sir_dandan"][QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]Let it go.HilbillyRokstar

I'll be renting it before I make a decision on whether to buy or not.

I'll be renting it before I make a decision on whether to buy or not.

DrD3V1L

[QUOTE="DrD3V1L"]

I'll be renting it before I make a decision on whether to buy or not.

sir_dandan

I won't be for a while. Don't really have the extra money to spend on games at the moment, and there are a lot of other games I would like to get before L.A. Noire. Looks like a good game though and would like to get it one day.

Just another overhyped Rockstar game that will get 10's across the board because they'll pay off everyone.

Just another overhyped Rockstar game that will get 10's across the board because they'll pay off everyone.

Hazzard6X

I will never buy it, never play it, and hopefully never be near a physical copy.

krunkfu2

I hope that the replay value is at least good enough to go through a second time; nevertheless, I'll be renting it.

It's a tough call for me. I pre ordered it so if I decide to get it I'll have one reserved. But Rockstar games are extremely hit or miss to me. I got TE newest GTA day one and absolutely hated it, but I waited a month or so before getting Red Dead and that was one of my top 5 games this gen. I'll probably end up canceling my pre order and just waiting until I see more.AdamRiggs4

I'll admit that the whole facial animations bit has me excited for it, but with my wallet screaming at the moment, I'm gonna have to hold off.

Maybe when it's 40$ or so.

Depends on how good it actually turns out. Looks to have a lot of promise and I've liked everything I've seen and heard so far, but I've been fooled many times by games that look promising but end up disappointing because of issues that would not be picked up on by watching trailers and whatnot.

I want it, but I probably won't, because I have to save my money for other stuff.

Those were jokes crybaby. Banter, for amusement only. Get over it.HilbillyRokstar

And you WERE wrong, but are surely finding every inch of possibility to stop from saying those simple words. Weird how fragile some people's egos are.

Anyways, after seeing the reviews, I dont see the point in renting. If I like it, which it sounds like I will, I'll just be spending $65/66 on it instead of simply $60! As for the value of it, even it were only 20 hours, then thats still pretty good if its a quality 20 hours.

And its always very hard to assess the time it takes a beat a game like this. Its very easy to take much more time than others and go through all the details, while others can simply rush through. I mean, I know its possible to beat Oblivion in like 8 hours, but that didn't stop me from taking 200 hours on my playthrough, ya know? I'm sure the difference wont be that extreme, but I think people should just realize that there's very little wrong with a game thats 20-25 hours long. There's many very good games that provide much less than that.

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]Those were jokes crybaby. Banter, for amusement only. Get over it.seankane

And you WERE wrong, but are surely finding every inch of possibility to stop from saying those simple words. Weird how fragile some people's egos are.

Anyways, after seeing the reviews, I dont see the point in renting. If I like it, which it sounds like I will, I'll just be spending $65/66 on it instead of simply $60! As for the value of it, even it were only 20 hours, then thats still pretty good if its a quality 20 hours.

And its always very hard to assess the time it takes a beat a game like this. Its very easy to take much more time than others and go through all the details, while others can simply rush through. I mean, I know its possible to beat Oblivion in like 8 hours, but that didn't stop me from taking 200 hours on my playthrough, ya know? I'm sure the difference wont be that extreme, but I think people should just realize that there's very little wrong with a game thats 20-25 hours long. There's many very good games that provide much less than that.

Exactly, and I'm sure that if you collect achievements then the game is over 30 hours.

You kids can be kids and fight while i will go buy this game and enjoy it because really 17, 20, 23, 30+ hours doesn't matter at all. :)halo3-player

This guy certainly isn't.

:cry:[QUOTE="seankane"]

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]Those were jokes crybaby. Banter, for amusement only. Get over it.HilbillyRokstar

And you WERE wrong, but are surely finding every inch of possibility to stop from saying those simple words. Weird how fragile some people's egos are.

Anyways, after seeing the reviews, I dont see the point in renting. If I like it, which it sounds like I will, I'll just be spending $65/66 on it instead of simply $60! As for the value of it, even it were only 20 hours, then thats still pretty good if its a quality 20 hours.

And its always very hard to assess the time it takes a beat a game like this. Its very easy to take much more time than others and go through all the details, while others can simply rush through. I mean, I know its possible to beat Oblivion in like 8 hours, but that didn't stop me from taking 200 hours on my playthrough, ya know? I'm sure the difference wont be that extreme, but I think people should just realize that there's very little wrong with a game thats 20-25 hours long. There's many very good games that provide much less than that.

Thank you for further proving that you're not funny in the least. *thumbs up*

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]

:cry:[QUOTE="seankane"]
Nobody's laughing. Perhaps you should give up on this 'joking' stuff, cuz you're not very good at it and only come off as crass and disrespectful.

And you WERE wrong, but are surely finding every inch of possibility to stop from saying those simple words. Weird how fragile some people's egos are.

Anyways, after seeing the reviews, I dont see the point in renting. If I like it, which it sounds like I will, I'll just be spending $65/66 on it instead of simply $60! As for the value of it, even it were only 20 hours, then thats still pretty good if its a quality 20 hours.

And its always very hard to assess the time it takes a beat a game like this. Its very easy to take much more time than others and go through all the details, while others can simply rush through. I mean, I know its possible to beat Oblivion in like 8 hours, but that didn't stop me from taking 200 hours on my playthrough, ya know? I'm sure the difference wont be that extreme, but I think people should just realize that there's very little wrong with a game thats 20-25 hours long. There's many very good games that provide much less than that.

seankane

Thank you for further proving that you're not funny in the least. *thumbs up*

[QUOTE="seankane"]

[QUOTE="HilbillyRokstar"]WAAAAA:cry: poor baby (somone needs a nap) lol

HilbillyRokstar

Thank you for further proving that you're not funny in the least. *thumbs up*

I agree with the rental idea.