[QUOTE="-M117-"]

[QUOTE="dethroned3"]

yeahhh...360 is beating ps3 on gamespot.
lets be open minded now and think about the rest of the world.


because halo wars and gta:lad got crappy scores from gamespot, you automatically use GR and MC.

how about just using GR and MC for better comparison between ps3 and 360??

dethroned3

http://www.metacritic.com/games/xbox360/scores/
21 games 90%+, 118 games 80 - 89%, 163 games 70-79%

http://www.metacritic.com/games/ps3/scores/
12 PS3 games 90%+, 85 games 80 - 89%, 91 games 70-79%

LOL i dont think cows should be using metacritic anytime soon for score comparisons

quite being so igorant.
this thread is about 2009 GAMES.

ok u got me. But you gotta admit thats quite embarassing for PS3 given those scores.

haze + lair = master piece.

nhh18

wrong, my scores were "A". Your games dont even count for a "A".

Motorstrom (A) , Rachet and Clank(A) = AA (better example)

[QUOTE="-M117-"]

PS3 Exclusives: Killzone 2 (AAA)

360 Exclusives: Stoked (A), Race Pro (A), Star Ocean (A), Ninja Blade (A)

Thats 4 games to PS3's 1 exclusive. Thats quantity. 360 has 4 "A". PS3 has 3 "A". Thats quality.

Throw in Halo Wars and GTA: LAD, two well received 360 games (82% and 90% on Metacritic.com respectively) but sadly not making the "A" cut on gamespot, the 360 exclusive lineup so far is really beating out PS3's.

dethroned3

yeahhh...360 is beating ps3 on gamespot.
lets be open minded now and think about the rest of the world.


because halo wars and gta:lad got crappy scores from gamespot, you automatically use GR and MC.

how about just using GR and MC for better comparison between ps3 and 360??

http://www.metacritic.com/games/xbox360/scores/
21 games 90%+, 118 games 80 - 89%, 163 games 70-79%

http://www.metacritic.com/games/ps3/scores/
12 PS3 games 90%+, 85 games 80 - 89%, 91 games 70-79%

LOL i dont think cows should be using metacritic anytime soon for score comparisons

[QUOTE="Synthetic_NinJI"][QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Yes, but it's omission just serves to undermine his viewpoint, which is ownage on his part.

GreenGoblin2099

i got owned by a sheep? ok, cool

(goes back to focusing on 360 vs PS3)

[QUOTE="-M117-"]

[QUOTE="nba532002"] actually the pol that was made was in favor for it being exclusive, also in gamespot's list of editor's choice games in the the year of 2009, they have mlb 09 listed as ps3 and does not show ps2 and psp as in other multiplats...nba532002

the poll is opinion. Actually it was IGNs review that put the debate to rest, saying both versions werent that different. I dont want to argue here, just know that ended the debate. And again, MLB 07 and 08 were AA and cows didnt care that its exclusive.

im sorry but the thread ended with it NOT being exlcusive. If you say it is exclusive, YOU WILL BE SHOT DOWN, by ppl besides from me.

Also, a major point was the MLB 07 and 08 were NOT considered exclusive, therefore 09 shouldnt either. Think about that.

[QUOTE="-M117-"]

[QUOTE="Nonstop-Madness"]@metacritic Xbox 360 has 68, 78, 74,82 and 73 Exclusive Scores for 2009. PS3 has 92 and 89 Exclusive Scores. Nonstop-Madness

dont forget the 90 for GTA.............

you and i both know it isnt really an arcade game..............just saying its content rivals that of many full priced games. Thats all.

[QUOTE="-M117-"]

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

Fair enough, but it would also go against your original post, stating that you are in fact wrong. Which would negate this thread. So the omission in fact helps out your illogical argument.

lundy86_4

true. Its just a lucky coincidence. Lems only care about beating PS3 and vise versa.

And i still wouldnt call it illogical. It is after all simple math. 4 > 3. So what if 4 games have to gang up on one, who said business is fair :P

Lol, but quality will always reign over quantity to any consumer of a product.

true, but my thread is talking about cumulative quality in system wars.

I prefer quality over quantity any day. So can you guess with one is winning 2009 to me? Yea exactly, the PS3.

TheGreatOutdoor

except 4 A > 3 A

simple math pal. Throw in GTA LAD, and Halo Wars and 360 has a better 09 lineup so far.

[QUOTE="-M117-"]

[QUOTE="lundy86_4"]

So you omit the Wii, because then your logic wouldn't stand up to scrutiny. Good call.

lundy86_4

no...........I omit the Wii because The Holy War only consists of 360 vs PS3.

Fair enough, but it would also go against your original post, stating that you are in fact wrong. Which would negate this thread. So the omission in fact helps out your illogical argument.

true. Its just a lucky coincidence. Lems only care about beating PS3 and vise versa.

And i still wouldnt call it illogical. It is after all simple math. 4 > 3. So what if 4 games have to gang up on one, who said business is fair :P

@metacritic Xbox 360 has 68, 78, 74,82 and 73 Exclusive Scores for 2009. PS3 has 92 and 89 Exclusive Scores. Nonstop-Madness

dont forget the 90 for GTA.............