If you watch NBC even a tiny bit you're no doubt aware that it has brought back the old show American Gladiators. I don't remember watching the show religiously or anything back in the day, but I would check it out if nothing else was on and I did play the super crappy video game version of the show. Out of curiosity, and because I enjoy shows like MXC and that other Japanese show Ninja Warrior where they have to climb the huge tower at the end, I figured I'd record the first three episodes to see how this new take on an old show had turned out.
It's pretty much exactly what I figured it would be. The show doesn't take itself too seriously, which is a good thing, because it's just plain goofy. If you're a Hulk Hogan fan you'll enjoy him in his role as announcer, and if you're not a fan of the Hulkster, his knack for calling everyone "brotha" will drive you insane. Oh yeah, his wristwatch is giant and shiny and it distracts me. Laila Ali is decent, but every time I see her I can't help but think that she looks and sounds like a younger, skinnier, more attractive Queen Latifah. That's not really a problem for her--because those are all good things--but seriously, that's all I think about when she's on. The contestants are surprisingly competent and it's impressive that even the smaller people have a shot at winning. The thing is, they're all terrible at talking trash--a shame since they get interviewed before and after every single event.
The Gladiators are another story. It's painfully obvious that none of them were given any time to practice the events and some of them have put on some downright pitiful performances. Mayhem was a joke in the Joust, stepping onto his opponent's platform during both duels. Hellga looks like she'd be a beast, but she has only been used twice, both times putting on less-than-stellar performances in Gauntlet. Toa tries too hard to be intimidating and just comes off looking lame. The only gladiator that has skill and a personality is Wolf. He's entertaining and he's competent in a large number of events. Is it just me, or does he look like Ben Stiller in costume though?
Most of the events will be familiar to fans of the old show and for the most part, they hold up pretty well. I'll break the events down in a list:
Assault: This is the one where the gladiator shoots tennis balls out of a cannon. It's not very good because it's too easy to hit the contestant and the contestants all look hella confused.
Earthquake: This is a wrestling match on top of a platform that's hanging a few feet off of the ground. I didn't like it until Militia pulled himself back onto the platform as he was falling by grabbing one of the cables that hangs the platform from the ceiling. That was pretty cool.
Gauntlet: The contestant must rush past four gladiators, each armed with foam blocks. This one's lame because the gladiator's don't seem to try very hard so it's rare that someone doesn't clear at least 3 of the four zones.
Hang Tough: Contestants try to use rings to swing over a pool to a platform on the other side. One gladiator tries to stop them. This one's usually pretty entertaining as both the contestants and the gladiators have some unique methods to get the job done.
Hit and Run: Contestants try and cross a bridge while gladiators swing giant 100 pound balls at them from the side. This event stinks unless someone gets hit--then it's awesome.
Joust: Stand on a pedestal high above the water and try and knock the other dude off into the water. This is seldom interesting. Why can't the contestants go head-to-head here?
Power Ball: This is the one where you grab a ball and try and place it in one of the bins in the middle of the playfield. Because there are two contestants and three gladiators nobody should ever, ever score, but they do. Why? The only good thing about this event is that it caused the first injury when that chick blew out her knee.
Pyramid: This is a 30 foot tall foam pyramid that the contestants have to climb. It would be easy, but each person has a gladiator assigned to stop them. This one is fun to watch because the contestants usually get destroyed, but it doesn't seem like anyone should ever get to the top (even though one did), so maybe it's too hard.
Wall: Contestants have to climb a 40 foot rock wall with gladiators nipping at their heels. This one's decent, especially when people fall off.
Eliminator: My big beef with the final obstacle course is that it makes the rest of the competition irrelevant. You earn a half a second head start for every point you're up on your opponent. The problem is the leads can vanish in the blink of an eye. Also, there doesn't seem to be any penalty for falling off the rolling things right after the cargo net climb. I hate the rolling things to start with and this makes me hate them even more. I do like how they show the losing contestant struggling to finish the Eliminator while they interview the winner.
Things the show could do better:
The contestants aren't good at talking trash. Stop interviewing them so many times.
Give us more information on injuries. I want to see the x-rays. And why gloss over a gladiator injury? That's awesome! Let me know what happened!
It's cool to see the old events, but a few newer ones would have been nice. Assault has got to go.
Let the gladiators be meaner. I should never see a gladiator congratulating an opponent unless they did something mind-blowing to beat them.
Random things I like:
I do enjoy how most events involve someone falling a good distance into water. I also like how they have flashing lights under the water. It gives me hope that one day someone will accidentally get electrocuted.
The music that plays when someone loses is good, but why doesn't it play all the time?
Watching people swim under fire, rocks.
The contestants are pretty skilled.
It's in HD. Everything on network television should be in HD.
The verdict: American Gladiators is a fun show, but I have my doubts as to how long it will be on the air. It seems like they shot the first season already so I'm sure we'll get to see who wins, but I don't see it lasting longer than a year. Bump the prize money up to a million (it's a paltry 100k right now) and give us more action during the hour (there's too much standing around talking) and the show will have some potential.
Log in to comment