Literally "When the Cicadas Cry", this is a "murder mystery" anime based off games of the same name. The story, if you can call it that, mainly revolves around the tiny country village of Hinamizawa and the curse of Oyashiro-sama which befalls the village every Cotton Drifting Festival.
I should probably expand on my story remark; the anime series is a collection of several different stories residing in seemingly different universes. In each "arc", as they're known, the setting stays the same but the backgrounds and characters are completely different. This is my first gripe with it, there is absolutely no point in getting attached to any of the characters as their personalities can do complete U-turns, varying from placid and lovable to bitterly psychotic. There also exist a pair of identical twin girls - Mion and Shion Sonozaki. When I say identical, I literally mean you cannot distinguish between the two besides their clothes and hairstyles, which doesn't help when the two start swapping places without any kind of incentive.
Story wise, it does a good job of raising suspense during the serious moments of the arcs, but often I feel they're a tad schizophrenic with the other half being over-the-top comedic anime expressions and poses. This has leaked into the serious sections on more than one occasion, if only by accident. One instance coming to mind is when Satoko, a girl no older than 10, manages to push Keiichi, a boy at least 6 years older and several stone heavier, clean across a classroom...twice. The transition between serious and non-serious occurs sporadically which adds to the overall tension of the arc, but they occur with such jump-starts you're at risk of breaking your neck. Spotting whoever's done it (or should that be "dunnit"?) is like playing Where's Wally if someone had highlighted him with a bright neon sign. Simply look for the person who laughs manically for no reason and who's eyes dilate to the size of periods. This leads me onto my second grip; a lot of the so-called "mystery" behind these events could be simply solved if someone, anyone, just stopped and said "whoa, whoa; what's going on and what do you mean by that?" instead of leaping to phenomenally polarised conclusions.
Overall I think I may be a bit overly critical of it. It's certainly a fresh approach to storytelling, and the suspense is very real and well executed, but I feel that the constant changing in characters personalities disconnects the viewer from any kind of emotional attachment to the story and/or characters. However that's not to say it's bad anime, it's just too differently executed for my tastes.
7/10
Good idea, flawed execution
Log in to comment