Ok so
Yahtzee has taken his already outspoken rage against webcomic
Ctrl-Alt-Del in his recent review. A large portion of me agrees with what Yahtzee is saying, no matter which way you look at it, this is a laugh-a-day wacky webcomic which has suddenly decided to become some kind of daytime soap opera. Even the game related stuff he's done recently just leaves me with this bitter taste in my mouth that this is "the webcomic that killed a baby".
I'll admit that I liked Ctrl-Alt-Del for a long time, I've read through all of them a number of times, and while Tim Buckley does do some hits and misses (as we all) it seems like he's suddenly become
that guy. You know the one; he used to be funny and you hung out with him, but then he suddenly cracks a racist joke. You begin to feel more and more awkward around him, wondering if he's going to try more on it or if you're going to become associated with him because you hang around him. No matter what he does from now on, this will always be at the back of my mind.
On the other hand, a part of me feels sorry for Tim. His CAD series is very popular but so is Yahtzee. There will be a bit of traffic coming his way from people who've never heard of him, but there is no doubt in my mind that there will be a number of people who will actively stop visiting CAD on the sole reasoning that Yahtzee said so, which is sad.
I still enjoy reading the older CAD comics and can see the formation of a storyline emerging, so maybe Buckley thought that a serious storyline would be the next logical step; maybe to show his versitility as a writer, I don't know. The thing that bothers me is that the exceptions to the rule that pop up every now and then. For example, a long running gag is Ethan getting shot with an arrow for no perticular reason, and yet we have these "serious" bits and bobs thrown in every now and then that stick for the rest of the series. It's hard to keep track on what should and should not be taken seriously.
Anyway, make of it what you will. My final thought is that Tim Buckley is a talented artist with lots of potential, but he needs to learn what should and shouldn't belong in certain strips. Take a note from
VG Cats's book, no not update when the magic 8-ball tells you to, but have numerous side projects for different themes.
Log in to comment