Honestly, I love both games but Id rather play Battlefield any day. Although, Ive got to ask, how would you buy Premium for $40? I bought the standard edition for $40 just a few weeks ago. Cyanide4Suicid3

I have Halo 4 but I haven't opened it yet. I might return it and get Battlefield 3 premium for the same price of $40 because it seems like a better deal which comes with the full package of DLC and future ones, something like 25 extra maps, but the downside is 24 player matches as opposed to PC. Halo is just sitting there with the other Halos and it just seems like I'll like it at first until it starts to feel like the same game again, when I could have just saved money and play Reach. I also want to expand on my collection since I don't have a Battlefield game yet except Bad company 2 on my brothers laptop which I don't play. My main gripe is Halo 5 is already announced (which I think is seriously too early) and possibly even a 2013 release with 720 along with Battlefield 4, so should I just wait instead? Or should I just be like **** it, play Halo 4 since its right there. Thanks.

to me I feel a little disappointed because while it's a good game, I'm forcing myself to take the time to play it and I'm at 21 hours so far still at the first island so I haven't beaten it, but I heard the campaign is only 10 hours long if you went straight to the main quests. I feel like I shouldn't even be forcing myself but what I'm doing is travelling by foot and not using fast travel as much. And I heard there's nothing really to do once you beat the game, other than fighting pirates and once you capture all of the outposts, the world becomes empty, so on this save I'm just not going to capture any outposts.

Pretty much my OCD tells me to buy games if the campaign is worth the dollars paid, so I mostly wait to buy games when there $20 if the campaign is only like 10-15 and if it's longer then great, but this is the first game I bought this year at full price because I was really hyped for it and I should have waited for a price drop on this one. Atleast for me, my game didn't come with pre order extras and the bestbuy clerk said it should have. This is obviously not the best opinion you can get on the game though but it's a good game, I just wish I got it for $50 because frys has it on sale this week so I'm pretty pissed off when I just bought the game for full price.

Is there any replay value after beating the game? And how's the online? I'm thinking of getting xbox live just to try it out.

it's on sale for $40 at Target and gamestop. Should I get this or Battlefield 3 Premium edition which is also $40 on amazon. I noticed not a lot of people on my friends list are playing Halo 4 anymore and only have like 200 achievements so it looks like they have no interest in it.

you should try aiming a little upwards with the flame thrower so the flame goes farther.