Everything you ever wanted to know about the Gamespot Soapbox
(Publicly available information only)
HOW TO GET THE SOAPBOX EMBLEM
Welcome to the GameSpot Soapbox, in which you can always find the latest rants, diatribes, well-reasoned arguments, and baseless speculation about gaming both from the GameSpot editors and GameSpot users. Want to be spotlighted? We'll consider every GameSpot blog post marked with the category "editorial" for inclusion. Sound off!
(Gamespot) last updated: Sep 21, 2007 5:09 am ET
Comment - This is the only publicly available, official information and indication on how to get on the Soapbox. All we know is it needs to be marked "editorial" and be about gaming.
SOAPBOX MECHANICS
1 - Users that have the Soapbox emblem have their entry automatically posted to the top of the Soapbox when they mark them as, "Editorial."
2 - Users can lose the emblem, have lost the emblem, and will continue to lose the emblem. I have known at least three users lost the emblem, BraindeadRacr (he discusses its loss here), Misfit1119, and TheCritic9392 (recipient of the banhammer). The reasons for loss vary, though it is theorized that Misfit lost the emblem after this entry because the entry pertained to Gamespot rather than gaming.
3 - The final decision on who is awarded the Soapbox emblem is a Gamespot editor. According to Caddy06_88 in this forum post, it was formerly Greg Kasavin, who has since left Gamespot. A list of the Gamespot editorial staff is located here. User Thraxen kindly informed me that the aforementioned Editorial staff list is outdated, and that several of the listed staff have left or had title changes. I have submitted a request for this to be updated, but it may take some time.
4 - Entries by emblem holders marked as "Editorial" in blog posts made in affiliated sites such as Filmspot and TV.com will appear in the Gamespot Soapbox.
SOAPBOX STATISTICS
I began tracking Soapbox entries in June (you know, for fun). Below are the number of posts marked "editorial" by emblem-holders that went up on the Soapbox, totals over the past three months, and total posts overall.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/329a2/329a25e3de07ac4bafd57cb532fdc9cfc030e248" alt=""
CURRENT SOAPBOX EMBLEM HOLDERS
The list below contains all the users I know of that have the Soapbox emblem currently. There may be more (possibly many).
acadiascreech, Acepace, Baroque-Legacy, Benny_is_here, Bokista, Bozanimal, carolynmichelle, Chikahiro94, Cube_of_MooN, curtrazo, dannyodwyer, DawnBurn, DJ_Lae, Donkeljohn, Draqq_Zyxorian, EarthThatWas, Enterprise-E, fishdalf, FriedConsole, Gigastormz, hart704, JaMeS4418, Jerell_rast, JonathanL, juradai, KFrandsen2, kori911, Korubi, laughlyn12, Link2025, m0zart, Messier75, metagnome, MrCHUP0N, NekoTheSpook, NeoJedi, Nickolai1979, nocoolnamejim, Reetesh, ruff_edgz, Sagacious_Tien, Shifty_Pete, Soulreavercross, subrosian, TheNay-Sayer, Thraxen, trifuzion, U1, vikingwwu, warden72, weemadando, WhollyNight, wootex, yariang, yian, ZimpanX, Zkeptik
BOZANIMAL'S SOAPBOX OPINION SECTION Subject to change with the author's opinion (and he has been known to flip-flop).
It's Always The Same People (i.e. Overposting)!
This is absolutely true. Sort of. Only users with the emblem have the ability to post to the Soapbox, and so the same users pop up all the time. However, new users are added continuously. In fact, nine users were added in September 2007 alone (so far). Further, I forward a link to this blog entry to each and every Soapbox user as they garner the emblem. Therein I suggest to each emblem-holder they impose a measure of self-regulation to limit their posting, thereby allowing other users a chance at the podium. This is, of course, only my opinion, but I hope it limits user complaints that they are always seeing the same people. Click the aforementioned link for details and discussions in the comments.
The Soapbox Emblem is like The One Ring
I firmly believe that half of the complaints regarding the Soapbox are founded by users' desire to garner the emblem. If there was no emblem, many users obsessed with writing "Soapbox-worthy" editorials would discontinue their endeavor immediately, and complaints would cease from all but a few members.
Poor Grammar from Emblem-Holders
Some of the Soapbox emblem holders are not native English speakers, such as Reetesh. Be sure to consider this the next time you disparage an entry for poor grammar; the user may have something intelligent to say and contribute but - English being the difficult language that it is - are inhibited since English is their second language. I use Reetesh as an example because his gaming views are often unique relative to those of the West. He once told a poignant story about how gaming affected his relationship with his brother that was quite memorable, if not up to the standards of Franklin-Covey grammatically. Of course, some native English Soapbox emblem holders fail to proof-read their entries, leaving them filled with misspellings and poor grammer. I believe flaming in this situation is justified.
It's Not Fair!
The Gamespot community would benefit from reading the editorials of users like GabuEx and digi_matrix, but they have both written many editorials and have not (yet) been added to the Soapbox. Do they deserve it? Sure. Is it unfair or unjust that they not have the emblem? No. The Soapbox is an arbitrary system, and arbitary systems do not need to be fair. It's like Calvinball.
Everyone Writes About The Same Game!
(e.g. Halo 3, Crysis, Bioshock, etc.)
This is more or less true. However, the editorials I have seen on Bioshock were all addressing different issues. DawnBurn discussed how she did not want to see any sequels to Bioshock for reasons of story continuity and preservation of the original's integrity, Wootex discussed the lack of a death penalty in the game, and I myself discussed the implementation of Digital Rights Management and other issues associated with its launch and distribution. While all discussed Bioshock, they were very different takes on independent issues.
That Editorial Was Stupid
This happens sometimes; nature of the beast and all that. In my opinion, all "Top Ten" lists should immediately disqualify Soapbox emblem holders. It's a good thing, therefore, I am not a Gamespot editor!
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/f8868/f8868ead2cb2035332e6ebe7ecf940325f7c1df6" alt=""
(Unofficial) HOW TO EARN THE SOAPBOX EMBLEM
Suggestions from Bozanimal
1 - This is the internet; keep in mind the short attention span of readers.
2 - Keep your editorial to less than 800 words. Anything longer may begin to bore the reader, and implies that you are unable to make your point in a succinct manner.
3 - Make an outline and put your conclusion in your first paragraph. Lazy readers will read the first paragraph then throw in a comment before moving along. Your opinion goes in the middle. Put facts at the end to back up your opinion.
4 - Break up the text with judicious use of pictures to illustrate your point. Nobody likes a wall of text except the writer.
5 - Highlight your key points and/or facts with bullets, bold-face, and/or underlining, but don't overdo it. Too much formatting can make for reading as tough as walls of text.
6 - If you submit an editorial and do not get the Soapbox emblem, do not complain. Nobody likes a whiner.
7 - If you submit an editorial and do not get the Soapbox emblem, do not follow-up with several additional editorials. If I were a Gamespot editorial and recently rejected a user editorial, and that user posted another editorial that week, I would be less inclined to accept the editorial than if I saw the same editorial a month later.
8 - Proof-read. Spellnig mistaKes 'nd grammer miztakes are like zits in your wriTing.
Soapbox Complaints This is a compilation of links to entries where people have complained about the current Soapbox system. It is by no means comprehensive. I neither agree no disagree with any of the following opinions, except where I have made opinions.
A Zkeptik Editorial, a number of users complain about the Soapbox in the comments section.
Site Enhancements & Feedback - Beef with GameSpot User Soapbox Just like it sounds.
The_PC_Gamer wants into the Soapbox in this blog entry market "Rant"
xboxrulze got the Soap Box blues Also, just what it sounds like.
AJMarra's Editorial of Irony A funny entry; check out the comments for some users miffed at the Soapbox.
This guide was written and compiled by
Bozanimal. He is not a Gamespot employee or moderator, and has no official input in the Soapbox system other than the editorials he chooses to post. You are free to link-away.
Log in to comment