Financing your college education.
A college education is fast becoming the new mortgage. Fifty to a hundred years ago mortgages were uncommon if not unheard of in some areas of the U.S. Today a mortgage is standard if you want to own your own home. The same is fast becoming true of college education. Your best financial weapon: research every option.
Assessing the cost and the need
You will need to pay for college: if not your own than someday your children. College costs are astronomical and projected to grow at a rate far exceeding inflation. Tuition and fees at public four-year colleges rose $344, or 6.3%, to an average of $5,836 for the 2006-2007 academic year, according to the College Board.
As if by some sinister collusion, the need for a college degree in order to obtain quality employment is also at an all-time high. If you are reading this, it is likely that your children - if not you yourself - will almost need a minimum of an associate's degree for even the most basic jobs. Half of all new jobs being created require a college degree (Consortium for Higher Education).
Between 1980 and 2004, earnings increased with education for all young adults ages 25-34 who worked full-time throughout the year. Young adults with at least a bachelor's degree consistently had higher median earnings than those with less education. Moreover, for the entire population and, in general, for each subgroup, the difference between the earnings of those with at least a bachelor's degree and their peers with less education grew during this period. For example, in 1980, males with a bachelor's or higher degree earned 19 percent more than male high school completers, while in 2004 they earned 67 percent more. (U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics)
Options for financing college
There are only three ways to pay for college: saving, borrowing, and grants. The general rule is to determine whether you are able to earn returns on your existing savings that exceed the borrowing rate. In other words, if you can make more money investing your cash than the interest you are being charged to take out a loan, your are better off investing the money and taking the loan. The opposite also holds true. If you have no savings, your only option is to borrow.
For example, you have two options: borrow $100,000 at 5.0% or invest your (theoretical) $100,000 at 6.0%. Since you can earn more on the investment, you invest the money and use the proceeds to pay off your college loan. If your borrowing rate were 7.0%, you would want to pay off your tuition with savings instead of financing, if possible. This rule is the same for cars, mortgages, and any other loan you might be considering.
Financial aid is increasingly tougher to get
Need-based financial aid, grants, and other gifts are not reliable sources of funding a college education, and I will not be discussing them. Some, like small grants from the Society for Women Engineers, are reliable. However, you cannot count on performance-based grants and gifts because the competition for those sources of funding is intensive. The odds of getting funding for attending a top-tier school, such as Harvard, is comparable to the odds of winning the lottery. Remember, your kids are special and talented, but so are everyone else's, and they all want that money, too. According to a recent survey of 1,400 parents and 200 student financial aid administrators:
- 72% believe their children have "special or unique talents" that will earn them scholarship funds
- 87% percent of parents are counting on their children receiving scholarship and/or grant money
- 92% of aid administrators say parents overestimate the amount of scholarship and grant money their children will receive
Consider the Pell Grant, one of the most common forms of student aid. According to a recent Dow Jones press release, approximately $12.7 billion in Pell Grants was awarded for the 2005-2006 academic year, down 3% from $13.1 billion the previous year. The average grant per recipient fell to $2,354, from $2,474. The majority of the 5.4 million Pell Grant recipients are from families with annual incomes below $40,000.
That being said, getting some money in the form of grants or other financial aid is not out of the question. A full 62% of full-time undergraduates receive grant aid according to the College Board. Also, you cannot get aid if you don't apply, so pick up a book and do some hunting on grant options that may apply to you or your children, particularly if you are in a low-income group or minority where it may be easier to find aid. You are also more likely to get grants and funding if you are getting a degree in math or science due to high demand in those fields. This is actually quite convenient, since those areas can offer some of the highest-paying jobs.
Financing higher education: Savings
Spending your savings is typically the best option for paying for college. For the majority of people, a Coverdell or 529 Savings plan will be the best saving vehicle. Savings accounts, CDs, and other low-interest savings vehicles will not keep pace with college tuition inflation. Roth and Traditional IRAs are great savings vehicles until you need to draw down interest earned, which you will need to pay taxes on should you withdraw more than your principal to attend college.
Coverdells are tax-free savings accounts similar to Roth IRAs, but are for higher education expenses rather than retirement. You deposit use after-tax earnings which then grow tax-free. You can deposit a maximum of $2,000 per beneficiary, but if multiple people contribute for a single beneficiary and the deposit amount exceeds $2,000 penalties will be owed. Also, only contributors with modified adjusted gross income below $95,000 ($190,000 for couples) may open a Coverdell account. The beneficiary must be under 18 during the savings period. For more detailed information, visit SavingforCollege.com
Section 529 savings and prepaid plans are a great vehicle for middle- and upper-income investors. Low-income investors are better served by Coverdells, grants, and other aid opportunities. Section 529 plans are state-sponsored investment vehicles, and almost every state offers one. You can invest in any state plan, since some plans are definitely better than others.
529 plans are available to everyone, and contribution limits are high (typically in the $100,000 to $300,000 range or more). After-tax dollars are deposited and can be withdrawn tax-free to pay for qualified higher education expenses. Many states offer a tax deduction for contributions. The plans offer multiple portfolios of mutual funds for investing, but their age-based portfolios are the best option for most investors; the underlying investments adjust their risk profile as the beneficiary approaches college. 529s are not considered in the FAFSA calculation (which is a good thing). The plans are almost always superior to UGMA/UTMA accounts.
However, there is a large amount of research involved in selecting the right plan. Savings plans are generally better than prepaids because they allow for appreciation beyond the rate of college inflation. Fees vary widely from plan-to-plan, so check Savingforcollege.com. Morningstar also issues a list of top plans once per year and - while it excludes many great plans and might not include your state - is a reasonable starting place for most savers.
To check if your state offers a 529 savings or prepaid plan, visit: http://www.collegesavings.org . Another excellent source of information is the aforementioned Savingforcollege.com. The site owner, Joe Hurley, is a CPA and 529 plan genius.
Financing higher education: Borrowing
According to a recent study by AllianceBernstein, the median amount parents plan to save for their children's college education is likely to cover 23% of their children's undergraduate expenses, at best. The remaining costs will need to be covered by a combination of aid and debt. If you are going to get a government loan, you will probably still need to complete a FAFSA. You can borrow from:
The Department of Education: Direct Stafford Loan (grade dependant, subsidized loans are need-based), Direct Plus Loan
Banks: FFEL Stafford Loans (grade dependent, subsidized loans are need-based), FFEL PLUS Loans
Credit Unions: FFEL Stafford Loans (grade dependent, subsidized loans are need-based), FFEL PLUS Loans
Private Lender: FFEL Stafford Loans (grade dependent, subsidized loans are need-based), FFEL PLUS Loans
School of Attendance: Federal Perkins Loan (amount is capped and is need-based)
Direct Loans and FFEL Loans charge origination fees of up to 3%, so avoid them if possible. To find participating lenders in any or all of the above programs, call 1-800-433-3243. Make sure you have read the suggested materials below in "FAFSA" before inquiring. Also, contact multiple lenders to make sure you're getting the best deal available. You want to eliminate any charlatans, and the best way to do that is to contact multiple lenders.
In general, when evaluating loans (debt), you want to compute the present value of your future obligation. A brief discussion of this calculation is given in a prior blog entry.
The FAFSA!
The FAFSA (Free Application for Federal Student Aid) is required for all students considering applying for financial aid. The most comprehensive resource is avilable at the aforementioned link. Your search for help with Financial Aid should begin with this PDF and a visit to www.federalstudentaid.ed.gov. The guide talks througb Pell Grants, ACGs, National SMART Grants, and every other type of Federal aid currently available. Start here, because internet information is often out of date.
Refinancing
I saw an ad saying I could save money by refinancing, should I? Be careful, refinancing is a dangerous business. Often there are layers of hidden fees for the account application process, credit checks, and other administration work that goes into the refinancing. Refinancing may also extend the period of you loan.
Resources
http://studentaid.ed.gov
http://federalstudentaid.ed.gov
http://www.students.gov
http://www.savingforcollege.com
Your state will also have an agency dedicated to financial aid. You should absolutely contact the agency for help in financing you edcuation. Contact the State Treasurer's office if you are having difficulty finding the agency.
Log in to comment