@tooitchy probably because we do, the casual masses are ruining the industry by buying the same shit over and over again and encouraging publishers to keep making the same crap instead of trying something new.

It's under an 8 on Metacritic, lower than BF4, didn't see this one coming.

I think this is the first main CoD game (no portables or whatever) that falls under an 8. Good, it's about time critics jump OFF the bandwagon.

@Karmazyn not according to the critic average. It's worse.

Am I crazy or is he both praising and criticizing the campaign at the same time?

He's like "it's so great! Oh wait the story is crap".

Though shall not quote Community around these parts. That's my thing.

I still miss the original style of exploring vast beautiful historical cities, climbing upon ancient monuments and amazing well known architecture.

This feels more like a pirates game with assassins than an AC game with pirates.

Again an underwhelming campaign drags the score down a little. Still the scores means great by GS standards so it's clearly worth to play.

But why do I have the feeling CoD will also have an underwhelming campaign and get a 9?

@Gelugon_baat what mindset would prompt Tom to call Bioshock Infinite garbage. Garbage. And I like the guy, I agree most of the time, so I just don't get what happened especially since he loved the first Bioshock so it's not like the formula alienates him.

@Gelugon_baat actually I do, I just don't get their reasoning sometimes.

@WantYouBad because I like everything else. Also I agree with most reviewers here, but there a couple that make little sense half the time.