http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1103275/
It is odd seeing Joaquin Phoenix in this role and thinking what an odd turn his career has taken. There is even a scene in this film where he tries to rap, which was a great unintentional joke:P This is one of the best romance films I have seen in a while. It doesn't rely on visulal gimmick like some indie romance films. This is just a straight forward love triangle story. Phoenix is fantastic in this, so is Gwyneth Paltrow. Vanessa Shaw also plays her role well though she isn't given much to work with. This is a very depressing story about a man who tried to commit suicide after his fiance left him. Phoenix's character is pretty ambiguous throughout the film, he seems almost bipolar and cold toward people, but then he meets the girl who moves in next door who is equally ambiguous. We know Phoenix has a genetic disorder where if he has kids with his ex fiance they will not live long and that is why she left him, and he takes pills. Again we are not really sure why. Paltrow is shown as having a loud father who visits her sometimes, and is having a relationship with a married man. At this point most films would show the married man as being a jerk, but here he is shown as being kind and caring. He has a family, but he is concerned about Paltrow. He seems to know that she likes Phoenix, but all he says is "Keep an eye on her, I think she might be using again." Using what? We are never told, and really it doesn't matter. This is where the film sets itself apart from the typical romance. All the characters here feel like real people, while most romance films would have at least one archetype. This is not a Matthew Mcconaughey cheese fest, this is love at it's most savage and brutal.Don't expect things to turn out how you expect. This is a remake of the 50's film White Nights, but I think this is just as good if not better. Not only do you get a feel for the characters and their situations, but you understand why they are who ever despite how vague the film is when it comes to explanations. This film does not baby you, there are not definite reasons for some of the characters actions and the ending is left open in a way that may frustrate or confuse some people. There are tons of romance films around, some that try and mix humor, with emotional drama and gimmicky visuals and a random dance scene like 500 days of summer. They have their place and they are good in their own ways. This is very different though, there are no visual gimmicks.
No hip soundtrack that will appeal to the youth market, the soundtrack is minimal. What this is though is one of the more heartfelt and passionate romance films. Few films can show the passion of love and how desperate some of us can get when we want someone we can't have. I respect Phoenix for this role, it is one of his best and most powerful. If you want to watch a great romance film without all the gimmicks that indie films have made popular then I highly recommend this. It doesn't do anything new really with it's story, but few films this decade show the amazing and heartwrenching power of love like this one. How it can tear apart your soul and step on your heart until you literally feel like dieing. How it can somehow make every problem in your life float away on the wind and seem insignificant compared to how you feel. Phoenix's character is in his 30's, and lives and works with his mum. In Paltrow's character he see's something different. He seems to love the girl his parents set him up with, but even that is left open to interpretation. She has the misfortune of loving Phoenix, and having a connection with his parents who want him to be happy, but also wouldn't mind the extra money their son's marrige to this daughter of a nearby business rival would bring. In Paltrow he see's a sense of freedom, and this is very apparent at the end of the film when she offers him a chance to be liberated from his life and he embraces it with a passion that lifts our spirits. Will he find the happiness he deserves in Paltrow or will he decide to stay with the easy choice he has been provided by his parents. He stays in a room in his parents apartment surrounded by past treasures, old posters, and a picture of the woman who left him. Few films are able to soothe your heart with sudden promises of hope. Then steal them away and kick you to death with a steel tipped boot like this one. Yet there is always a sense of the possibilities for the future, all is never lost in this film despite how sad it may seem. I look forward to when Phoenix comes back to acting, if he does that is. This film is a real gem.
Overall I give it a 8.5 out of 10.
Log in to comment