http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1131729/
First of all I have no idea why the film is called Pirate Radio in America, The Boat the rocked is a much better title. I find it hard to judge this film because the American version cut out more than 10 minutes of footage and rearranged the scenes in the film so it looks like the plot is much more convoluted than it was meant to be. This really pisses me off, I am a big fan of Richard Curtis and there is no reason to mess with his work. He is one ot the U.K's finest writers and it is a real shame that his film was messed with. So this will just be a temporary review, I will get the DVD and watch the film the way it was meant to be later. I will say that the main problem with this film is the lack of backstory for anyone. There are tons of characters, most of which are great but some seem like they were just thrown in for filler. There is a sub plot involving one of the characters Carl trying to figure out who has dad is on the ship, but that seemingly important plot gets forgotten and when it is resolved I didn't really care because I had almost forgotten it existed. Another character Mark is described by the characters in the film as the sexiest man alive, yet he never really does anything. While that may be the joke, there was a scene cut from the U.S version involving a midnight orgy, and a stag night. The best part about this film has to be the cast, Bill Nighy, Nick Frost, Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Rhys Darby, Chris O'dowd, Rhys Ifans, and Kenneth Branagh are all fantastic. Even Emma Thompson makes a quick cameo.They make characters with no real backstory or reason to care about them interesting with their unique charm and personalities.
They are not enough though to make the film much better, it starts out great but the middle drags a bit and brings up sub plots that are either too ridiculous to take seriouslly or not funny enough. There is just too much going on and not enough reason to care about any of it. Maybe the U.K DVD will fix this problem, but right now the film almost seems like a series of sketches on a boat with a vague connection having to do with the British government trying to get rid of them because they think rock music is filthy. This film was pretty disappointing overall, all the serious parts are not done well enough to take seriously because of a lack of connection to the characters, and a lot of the comedy isn't funny enough to make up for it. I hope scenes cut from the U.S version of the film add a lot and made the story more cohesive. Because right now this film feels like wasted potential. On the bright side though, the music is great. If you liek 60's music you will love the soundtrack. That brings up another problem, the historical aspect feels like background at best. There is music from the 60's, but the only way to really tell it is from the 60's are scenes of random people in 60's fashions dancing to the music and a brief mention of what happened to the ship before the credits. Then during the credits they show album covers, some of which are not even related to rock and roll like Kanye West. If the film was trying to show the influence of pirate radio beyond rock that would have worked, but it goes out of it's way to talk about Rock and roll. If you wan't to show the influence of a specific group of people on music, don't spend time avoiding the historical aspect of the story that could have added so much to the film. This is a shame because Richard Curtis is usually good with history, heck his greatest series Blackadder was based around it. The real pirate radio this film is based on has a rich and interesting history, this film doesn't seem to care much about that. It just uses the Pirate Radio as an excuse to show comedy. I don't want to sound too negative, heck this film has some very funny moments. I guess I am just very disappointed, I expected so much more from Curtis.
Overall I give it a 7 out of 10.
Log in to comment