[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"][QUOTE="observer77"]

really if it were not for sentiments in law we would not have certain laws that are based on those sentiments in mind without some kind of sentiments in law we proble wouldn't have laws that were not outside of the guide lines of the bible.

So yes they should play a role the victim is the reason the person is being punished which is why victims and victims families are alllowed to have some say/influence on if a person will get out of prison. the punishment is for the family,

but must follow the guidlines of the set laws and if the set laws in this situation say she has this kind of say then she is allowed to have this kind of say for the punishment.

observer77

yeah I realized my posts are going off on something else so I moved my thoughts to another post but I do beleive that if the laws in her country are that she has a say in the matter then I feel that is their choice.

[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"][QUOTE="remmbermytitans"]Is that any different from our death penalty system? It's essentially "an eye for an eye", you killed someone, now you get killed too. remmbermytitans

[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"][QUOTE="observer77"]

impractical to you but to a bunch of other people it isn't, but I am also for the death penalty so in my mind this makes sense. I am not saying everyone for the death penalty should be for this I am just saying because i beleive in the death penalty as a sensical act I feel that blinding him makes sense to me.

observer77

really if it were not for sentiments in law we would not have certain laws that are based on those sentiments in mind without some kind of sentiments in law we proble wouldn't have laws that were not outside of the guide lines of the bible.

So yes they should play a role the victim is the reason the person is being punished which is why victims and victims families are alllowed to have some say/influence on if a person will get out of prison the punishment is for the family but must follow the guidlines of the set laws and if the set laws in this situation say she has this kind of say then she is allowed to have this kind of say for the punishment.

Is that any different from our death penalty system? It's essentially "an eye for an eye", you killed someone, now you get killed too. remmbermytitans

[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"][QUOTE="observer77"]

wow. I don't think being a "proud american" has anything to do with what I think would be a fitting punishment (I am not "proud to be an american") I think it has more to do with ones emotions toward the incident then where one is from or feels for his/her country.

personally I think the punishment would fit the crime just fine in this case he is sure to do something else, I mean if he can still see and gets out of prison and still has his"need" for her he could go back and find her and he has already made it hard for her to defend herself if that were to happen. He deserves it I beleive he would just keep coming back or find someone new to harrass.

observer77

impractical to you but to a bunch of other people it isn't, but I am also for the death penalty so in my mind this makes sense. I am not saying everyone for the death penalty should be for this I am just saying because i beleive in the death penalty as a sensical act I feel that blinding him makes sense to me.

[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"]Unless you can give me a valid reason for that punishment, I'd dismiss it as an unreasonable and emotional 'solution'. tofu-lion91

[QUOTE="JabbaDaHutt30"]Disgusting. There's no doubt in my mind that some "proud Americans" here would find the punishment fitting.observer77

wow. I don't think being a "proud american" has anything to do with what I think would be a fitting punishment (I am not "proud to be an american") I think it has more to do with ones emotions toward the incident then where one is from or feels for his/her country.

personally I think the punishment would fit the crime just fine in this case he is sure to do something else, I mean if he can still see and gets out of prison and still has his"need" for her he could go back and find her and he has already made it hard for her to defend herself if that were to happen. He deserves it I beleive he would just keep coming back or find someone new to harrass.

[QUOTE="Euroshinobi"] Britain has one of the highest rates of immigration in the world. ;)Ninja-Hippo

What does the immigration rate have to do with the pleasantness of a country anyway? It just means that region is more... accessible for other people.

[QUOTE="Rigga911"][QUOTE="God_of_duty117"]Sure. I can't say that were in the best of shape right now, but I'd still rather be here than anywhere else really.Euroshinobi