Halo 4 > The Last of Us

Tom doesn't want to come out of his hole to defend his review?

Anyone else tired of these clowns Carolyn Petit and Tom McShea? I just looked through some notable reviews from these 2. Here's their score and the Metacritic average. As you can see Tom and Carolyn are always more than 10% off the average

Donkey Kong Country Returns 3D

Tom

7.0

Metacritic

83

Luigi's Mansion: Dark of the Moon

Carolyn 65

Metacritic

86

The Last of Us

Tom 80

Metacritic 95

Need for Speed Most Wanted U

Carolyn 75

Metacritic 86

Trine 2 Director's Cut:

Carolyn 65

Metacritic 84

The Legend of Zelda Skyward Sword

Tom 75

Metacritic 93

Anybody else want to start a petition to fire McShea? I'm tired of this clown. A 3 minute video review for something the developers took years to make

Super Mario Galaxy 2 getting a 10/10 from McShea means that is the greatest game of all time

8.0 = no buy

@Dante-xero It's pretty low when the average is in the 95% range. That's 15% lower then the average

Tom McShea just justified his review with all the people that will visit this site because of this review. I'm predicting 10000 plus comments on this review especially considering it has a 95 average on metacritic with 49 reviews. Gamespot knows they are a sinking ship and wants that money

Something has been a little messed up in the last few years with GameSpot's review scores. Outside of Kevin there has been a ton of questionable review scores. I actually don't think many of the Gamespot reviewers enjoy games anymore. Either that or they love to give games lower scores because the last 2 years they have given Game of the Year to games given a 9.0.

@northArrow @MortalKombat147 Gamestop said Xbox One would be cheaper at launch than the 360 Launch. The 360 launched for 300$ and 400$. This means the Xbox One has to launch for 250$ and 350$ to be cheaper