No Starcraft II means that list is fail.loco145It's 15th. This list isn't surprising in the least. The sample size is odd though. Why so small a sample?
Nirron's forum posts
sports get a pass because the purpose of the game is to make sure you team wins every match. they don't need story line to stay interesting, especially online play.
i never said gears gets a pass. i said that the action makes you forget that it lacks a deep story line. if you'd bought the limited edition set, the book it comes with explains the story though tbh, epic should have done that in the game. gears does have a plot but it's not that evident. this goes for mario. the difference is, like i said before, that mario's story is the same story that never changes. the princess is kidnapped, go defeat bowser and save her. nintendo never put focus on the story, they just left it the same. it's not lack of story. it's lack of changing the story.
cowgriller
Now we're getting deep into subjectivity though. The bolded statements could be applied to a Mario platformer by someone else. The variety of worlds, power-ups, and puzzle-type play could have the same effect as the action in Gears. I'm not really seeing how it's much different. IF I can apply these same principles to Mario, and please tell me why if I can't, then why do they need to alter the story if the majority is immersed and entertained enough by the gameplay elements that you forget the story hasn't really changed?
And for what it's worth, I actually agree that story is an important element in video games. It's what got me into RPGs in the early SNES/Genesis era, and keeps me going to them now.
Dude, it's just an analogy. You're going to far and connecting things that don't need to be connected. He's right. And sure, a sports game isn't story focused, but then again, neither are the Mario games.[QUOTE="Notsogr8one"][QUOTE="cowgriller"]
actually, your logic is faulty. sports games aren't about the story, hence why most of them don't have one. they are about playing the sport on a tv rather than going outside to play them in real life. btw, NFl Blitz was different than the madden games in that it was centered about breaking bones and having fun injuring the competition, not just scoring touchdowns.
cowgriller
i have a bad tendency to over analyse things. great for school and real life, bad for system wars.
It really seems more due to inconsistency. You blame Mario for having a lack of story, saying that games need to be story driven. Then you qualify that by saying Gears is fine because it's action packed, and sports games are fine because they don't depend on the story but are instead going for emulation. Why exactly do those get a pass but Mario doesn't? You're making exceptions for everything except what you're criticizing.I think only emo lemmings remember things like that.[QUOTE="PvtGump8"][QUOTE="blue_hazy_basic"]Remember when Sony blacklisted Kotaku and ensuing ****storm of bad PR they relented? Well I guess the didn't learn their lesson :roll:BioShockOwnz
No need to bait fanboys with names like "emo".
I agree. I hate when others use emo as flamebait
Why haven't Sony thought of putting KZ2 on the 360 before? The foolishness of that company astonishes me sometimes.Floppy_JimWe need to instill discipline in all of Sony. Sony will know discipline. Then and only then will their tomfoolery end.
[QUOTE="kidcool189"]
[QUOTE="-Traveller-"]
I have to agree with you here.
I'm playing Persona 4 right now :P
-Traveller-
hope you're enjoying it
and make sure to get the true TRUE ending ;)
I'm enjoying it a lot. Great RPG.
Haha, I have no idea what you mean, but i'm gonna do it (I hope).
It's got three endings. Bad, Normal, and True. Bad if you do something, well, bad, and Normal if you end the game where the game tricks you into thinking you're done. It's not TOO hard to figure out the true ending. Basically when you think the game's over and you're just playing the post-game walking around part...don't do what you think the game is telling you to do.[QUOTE="kidcool189"]
persona 5! persona 5! persona 5!
or some thing shin megami tensei...:D
-Traveller-
I have to agree with you here.
I'm playing Persona 4 right now :P
Nonono, pray for a port or remake of Devil Summoner: Soul Hackers, the awesome game that never made it out of Japan. I actually would love to hear a Persona 5 announcement, but I really think they should try taking advantage of getting more SMT out there other than Persona since so many people are interested in it now. SMT 4 would be my dream announcement, regardless of what system it was on.A man can dream. I know we probably won't hear any Atlus goodness until TGS. Until then, Atlus Faithful announcements shall have to tide me over.
[QUOTE="Michael324"]I sure wish them luck cause ninty has been at this since 06 and they're MEETING DEMAND now.WilliamRLBakermeeting demand isn't the same as underpricing since launch, and releaseing as much shovelware as possible. Interesting, I wasn't aware that Nintendo was the one releasing shovelware on the Wii. Though I have to give them respect for managing to release multiple shovelware titles scoring 80 or higher. Though I guess if we want to look at the bad games, Nintendo could easily ramp up poduction on them. We've only seen DK Barrel Blast and WIi Music, the latter getting a 6.5, by Nintendo get sub-A. Feel free to correct me if I'm wrong, but I think we can safely say that Nintendo raised the bar for good shovelware, especially with shovel-tastic titles like Wario Land and Animal Crossing. If shovelware can score 7.5, then we should easily see developers ramping up to 9.5-10 games constantly.
Log in to comment