I was just looking at /b/, when I came across this. Normally I wouldn't post stuff copypasta from /b/ on other boards, but this is actually pretty interesting and not just plain stupid. Also, I thought I'd post this here as opposed to the GGD or Portal/Orange Box board since it's more of a physics question than a Portal question. Although I'd happily report this topic if a mod things it would be a better fit elsewhere.

Anyway.

[QUOTE="UnrighteousFury"]

I left up all the ones that I vehemently disagree with.

Knocking on Heaven's Door is one of the few instances where I think the Dylan original is better than the cover. I much prefer Dylan's melancholic mumble over Axl's squawk.

I don't think anyone does The Who better than The Who. You're actually the first person I've ever seen who prefers Elton's Pinball Wizard over The Who's.

And Drowning Pool is pretty awful, no matter what song they're doing.

OmegaCookie7

I've never liked Dylans voice, so I'm probably going to lean towards any cover really over Dylans recordings. I'm also a huge GnR fan, so that's another reason I selected their cover. And while I like The Who, I'd much prefer Rush - their entire cover album was great IMO. And I'm not a huge Drowning Pool fan, but I do like Billy Idol, and the cover just grew on me. It's a harder version of a song I love. (good to see this topic finally getting some discussion going. A music board would be nice :))

Listening To: Us And Them - Pink Floyd.

So much for conversation btw. :P

Sunny Moon - The Cat Empire

Top 5:

1. The Car Song

2. Beanni

3. The Chariot

4. Protons, Neutrons, Electrons

5. Two Shoes