[QUOTE="Penguinchow"][QUOTE="z4twenny"]
i see what you're getting at, i personally would only relate religion to what its basic definition by a dictionary (which does require a belief in some spiritual being, thats vague though since i see myself as a spiritual being.... but thats a different thread entirely) but i'd call my old weekly D&D habits an enjoyable habit at best :P
really though when i define religion i ask 1 question which is "does your belief system have a group of people recognized by the gov't as a religion" in other words, if you're not tax exempt you're not a religion (and imo the US gov't is really really really easy going on what they consider a religion to be) and as many times as i've asked, i can't get my old D&D gang tax exempt.... they did tell me my 9th level drow fighter mage was exempt, which is good cuz he has a lot of loot.
z4twenny
I think he was trying to say that if you make something non-spiritual your god(in a figurative sense), you are in effect following said objects religion. And i agree in a way. Say a tribe in a jungle somewhere has a small wooden idol. Is it a deity? No but if the devotion they show this physical object surpasses anything else in their life I'd say it's a religion.oh i know what he was getting at, it was a roundabout way of what you were saying that yes anything with personal spiritual significance, whether or not it has that significance outside of the individual is still a religious doctrine or dogma as long as you feel spiritually connected with your higher power. its just that me, personally, i wouldn't call those a religion is all.
that being said -
"take what you want and leave the rest"
And neither would I. Originally I was just saying that a religion does not necessarily require a deity. But I may be wrong. All my point was was that some people might say that I play a certain role-playing-game religiously, and I may even concede and use the word myself, however the word comes with a certain stigma that may come across the wrong way.
I think all of our definitions work, it's just the context that matters.
Log in to comment