[QUOTE="Ultimas_Blade"]
[QUOTE="DivergeUnify"]Aborting defenseless babies vs. not providing "free" healthcare for mostly-capable adultsDivergeUnify
A life is a life is it not? For all the moral (and for some religious)questions that surround these debates, how can you rationalize an adult's life and fetus's life are not the same? Why does saving the fetus come before preserving the adult?
Nobody's saying healthcare is free (which I alluded to in my earlier response, fiscal realities, etc). What about the people who haveunexpected accidents or ailments that they cannot afford in the current system? Why shouldn't the community want to ensure it has healthy citizens? Not only would UHC do much in the way of early detection (which SAVES money) of ailments, but you have a population that isn't spending so much time not working because they are much healthier.
1) Abortion is a personal decision. It is also a personal decision to do whatever is neccessary to maintain one's health to the best of one's ability. Some people get terribly sick. We're animals. It happens. Organisms have been dying "unjustly" for billions of years( and humans for thousands of years)
2) Abortion is an explicit action to kill a baby/fetus. Not providing universal healthcare is not an explicit death sentence to individuals. If it was, if it was even comparable, there would be no USA right now
Whether we should have UHC provided is a decent debate, but not having it isn't morally comparable to not allowing abortion
One is an allowance for a mother to kill her fetus. The other is simply not resting all medical responsibility on the government.
I don't necessarily disagree with how you are rationalizing this, but by having the current insuredHCsystem you are damning many people toavoidable fates. I don't see how you can say "people havebeen dying unjustly for billions of years" and then appeal to emotions with "allowance for a mother to kill her fetus". It's crocodile tears. You are stonecold in one breath yet all caring in the next.
Pro-lifers make the stand that life is precious but why is that scope just limited to abortion? All in all the abortion wedge is a baseless emotional appeal that helpselect people who would oppose things like Medicare (for the old)and Medicaid (for the poor and children) that help keep our loved ones ALIVE.
Log in to comment