I'm a big horror fan as well, the game looks great to far and can't wait to try it out. That being said, definitely not a full price day one buy for me.

Monster Hunter 3 Ultimate.

Super Mario Bros. Deluxe and Pokemon Blue.

From the list the obvious choice for me was the PS1, love that console. So many great games, across all genres, but mostly for JRPGs and Survival Horror in my case.

Probably in the minority, but Saturn has my pick.

I would say go with Lunar, I'm a big Xeno fan and Lunar's story meshed with me well.

Mario Kart 64 for me I believe. I remember some arcade machine I played at the local pizza joint that was racing, but can't recall the name.

Majora's Mask for me, hands down.