If so, why exactly? The setting, detail, atmoshphere are all FANTASTIC, if going on that alone, then yes, easily a contender.

But based on the content? A short, basic horrible story? Redundent uninspired sidequests? It's a shame those parts of the game don't live up to the rest.

I can't decide. I'm trying to get all the must play games coming out arond now(Akyrim, BF3, Arkham etc) and i can't decide if it fits in with those.

How many does gamespot usually give anyway? I'll just go with 6.

Battlefield 3

Dark Souls

Zelda

Arkham City

Skyrim

Gears Of War/Uncharted 3

Predict a winner - Skyrim.

So make a list of 1-20 and i'll count them with points. -20 points to the first game on your list, 1 to number 20. I'll add them up in a few days. There are plenty of top 20 lists out there on various sites, just trying to get an overall thing.

Also, lists are like crack to me.

A few years ago i would want to 100% any game i own, esp rpg's, but..i'm just don't care to invest SO much time in my gaming any more. I picked up Dark Souls, and while it's a beautiful game, i played it for about 30 minutes and...i just don't want to invest 60-70 hours in a video game any more. Esp one as time consuming and frustrating as DS. It just seems....easier and more...''fun'' to pick up and play a game that you can get some quick enjoyment out of like..BF3 or Batman.

Maybe i'm growing out of video games.

Yes, the age old battle. We've seen it a million times before. But i'm planning to replay all 3 soon enough, and i'm curious as to what people think nowdays.

So, a couple of headings.

Best Story

Worst Story

Best Characters

Worst Characters

Best Soundtrack

Worst Soundtrack

Best battle sytem

Worst battle system

Best Summons

Worst Summons

Best Ending

Worst Ending

Best Villians

Worst Villians.