I gotta go with Thief 2 being the best of the series, with Thief 1 being second best and Thief 3 being the worst. Not to say Thief 3 was bad, being the worst Thief game is like being the slowest Ferrari. Other Ferraris may be faster than you, but you are still pretty damned fast. I really enjoyed Thief 3, I just got a lot more fun out of Thief 2.
Royas
No offense to the other people in thread, but this is the best response I've read in the entire thread. It paints a clearer picture of the Thief series, meaning that TDS is a great game, but for people who have played all 3 games in the series, it only ranks as 3rd. That bit about Ferrari cars made it clear that you can't go wrong playing any of these games.
I will have to agree with one point that was made about how it is wrong to immediately dismiss a game that has yet to be released as having no chance to exceed in quality an older game in the series. But that's just my opinion and everyone can state their opinion right? However, I have seen it happen in other series wherein I prefer the older iteration over the latest one. For example, in the Homeworld series, I'd still rank the first game as the one I enjoyed the most and love. In any case, knowing that every Thief game is a quality title, I think I will give TDS a try.
Log in to comment