The title pretty much says it all. The one-on-one fighter market has been pretty much split between these four titles for the past decade and a half (save for a number of smaller franchises such as Guilty Gear, Bloody Roar et al.). I know everyone has their favourite, and some may be so enamoured with one that they may even refuse to play the other three.
I'm not looking to start a flame war here, I'm just curious as to why people select a specific franchise (all four are, after all, quite different in their styles and tactics) and, more importantly, why people don't like or don't play the others.
For my part, I have Mortal Kombat 1-4 for the PC (and MK 1-3 for the PSP as part of the Midway Arcade Classics collection), Mortal Kombat vs. DC Universe for the PS3, Mortal Kombat Deception for the PS2, Street Fighter 4 and Alpha 2 for the PC, Street Fighter EX Plus Alpha 2 for the PS1, Street Fighter 2 for the PSP and PS1, Street Fighter Alpha 3 MAX for the PSP (plus SF2 as part of Capcom Classics Collection Reloaded), Tekken 1-3 for the PS1, Tekken 4, 5 and Tag Tournament for the PS2, Dark Resurrection for the PSP, Tekken 6 for the PS3, Virtua Fighter 1 and 2 for the PC and Virtua Fighter 5 for the PS3. So I have a fair bit of experience in this field.
My top franchise to date has to be Street Fighter, very closely followed by Tekken. I'm not a huge Virtua Fighter fan and I don't really like Mortal Kombat (except for the recent DC Universe crossover).
The reason for this, for me, is that Street Fighter offers a healthy mix of speed, flow and tactics with a reasonable and fair combo system. I think, with the notable exception of the EX series and Street Fighter 1, that the balance has been spot on every time.
Tekken takes a similar route, perhaps being a little slower and placing more emphasis on tactics and juggling. I'm not a huge fan of the juggling mechanism, but I don't consider it to be overly excessive as implemented in Tekken 3 and 5, which I consider to be the best instalments. I hated 4 and 6 with a passion. I'm also not keen on Tekken's reliance on stupidly powerful bosses at times (especially in 6).
Virtua Fighter is, in my opinion, far too lethargic to be any real fun, although I do appreciate the tactical depth and 'realism' behind it (no projectiles, for example).
Finally, I consider Mortal Kombat to be the worst of the lot, offering very little tactical scope, simply relying on button mashing and selling itself on the basis of blood and gore. The later titles, Deception and Deadly Alliance, were very poor, with battles that felt stiff, combos that felt artificial and set pieces that just felt disjointed from the game.
I'd love to know what you guys think, especially if you like Mortal Kombat.
Log in to comment