I'd have given it about a 7.0,
it wasn't exactly revolutionary, way too similar to previous titles,
graphics are awesome, and sound is great,
but the game itself, has a whole "been there, done that" feel about it...
I regret the purchase myself, would have been a good/smart rental for me.

Andrew_Xavier

I agree with Andrew_Xavier. Based on the demo, I'm not even going to bother picking it up. To me, it just seems like they updated the graphics and shipped it out the door. I think the transition from PS2 to PS3 should have been much more revolutionary.

Having owned both games, my opinion would be to get COD4. Like others have said, the single-player campaign is short but it has a great story. The multi-player is where you'll spend most of your time. I like the idea that you unlock new weapons and new add-ons the more you play. This was my first FPS that I played online and it's not terribly hard to get into. Yeah, I sucked for a little while, but I'm decent now. Plus it's been confirmed that there will be additional maps coming out this spring to help keep the game fresh.

As for Uncharted, it's a fun game with great graphics and a cool story, but I beat it once and didn't really see the point in going back to it. That's just my opinion, as others like to keep playing through it until they've completed all of the achievements and found all of the treasures.