Story: FEAR - I absolutely loved the story behind FEAR, especially the way it was presented through voicemails and interactive flashbacks....good stuff!
Graphics: Half-Life 2 - As good as FEAR looked, HL2 takes this category simply because it is on a much bigger scale. Maybe if FEAR or Doom had more outdoory environments.
Sound: FEAR - While HL2 had some great sound quality, FEAR actually used it as an instrument in the gameplay.
Level Design: Far Cry - the open ended nature of many of the levels really caused the immersion factor to go through the roof.
Weapons: Half-Life 2 - There may have not been as many weapons as other games, but they all felt really balanced and realistic.
Enemies: FEAR - The AI is what really made the game the hit that it was. The enemies were a bit repetitive, but each different type was unique and cool enough so that didn't matter.
Fun: FEAR - AI wins this category for FEAR again.
Overall: FEAR - Not to take anything away from HL2, it was just too linear and the enemies were too stupid. FEAR may have been on the short side, but the open-endedness of the combat lended itself well to multiple playthroughs.
Log in to comment