i think Greg Kasavan was the best reviewer here! The review of ocarina of time and halo are indeed very good!

but GRAW is an AAAE because GRAW on PS3 is A ( i think ), thus exlussively AAA on xbox360! Ninja gaiden got on both places AAA! if ninja gaiden II came to ps3, and it scored AAA, then it would be an AAAE

Omg why even ask??

Its like asking whats better Ferrari or a g wiz (google it) you just dont compare them

PS_John

you're full of yourself, of systemwars and of PS3! yea MGS would win! but splinter cell is also very good! i loved the first one! second one got 9.1 here! that's not bad!

1 overrated game doesn't change everything.

sure PDZ doesn't deserve a 9.0

but Halo 3, Forza 2, and Graw are AAA on metacritic.

Where as only MGS 4 is AAA on metacritic.

Meaning the AAA gap would still be in 360s favor. Even though here MGS 4 got a 10.

Now the AA games for the 360 outnumber the PS3 10- 4 here and 10-5 on metacritic.

So either way nothing really changes.

Cause then from a length standpoint Uncharted and Heavely Sword are way too short. Do they count, when they are more worthy of a rental?

See personal preferencce shouldn't go into the tally system.

Plain and simple if you are gonna argue reviews. All reviews on gamespot count as final say. Not just a select few.

If you are going to make a graphics comparison. DOn't single out one platform. Mention all of them.

Talk sales, all systems count.

In direct comparison sure keep it limited but for overall standards no. Every system is included. jg4xchamp

yes, thank you! i coudn't say it any better!

Technically PDZ counts as a AAAE, but you will have a hard time convincing anyone that it is a better game than Uncharted or Resistance. I think if anything it just shows how idiotic the whole AAAE argument is. Bashing other consoles because of arbritary opinions on one website is just pointless.Elutheria

finally! someone with brains! yes, that's true, an idiot wouldn't understand! if they want to take part of systemwars they have to take the rules as they are here ( stupid but yea, it would be more intresting if systemwars uses al scores from gamerankings or metacritics) ! i found it a pitty you can't have a conservation here with everyone acting like fanboy's and children...

no mass effect floped

too buggy

micky4889

so, you accept pdz didn't flop here? and it does count, cause i accept mass effect flopped. ( sorry for these 3 posts after each other )

Well then we should also count count Uncharted as AAA if we use your logic.The-Big-Easy

but did you even understood what i said? you just pointed out that cows not counting pdz, is wrong ! that's what i meant too

Some ( not all ) are saying that PDZ doesn't count as an AAAE or isn't worth mentioning because in their opinion it sucks! Can we count mass effect then as an AAA? cause most people found it an AAA worthy game! ( i don't want to suggest that we would count mass effect really in, just making clear it doens't make any sense to let pdz out! what a score got is it"s real score :) so count it!