Dan Marino
Joe Montana
Fran Tarkenton
Johnny Unitas
Steve Young
John Elway
Warren Moon
Jim Kelly
Joe Montana
Steve Young
Dan Marino
Terry Bradshaw
john Elway
Johny Unitas
Warren Moon
Roger Staubach
Johnny Unitas
detroitpistons0
I think TBH got struck by that on GS quick quote glitch. But now that he made me look at my list again, I notice I have on too many. I'll go and edit it.detroitpistons0
[QUOTE="detroitpistons0"]I think TBH got struck by that on GS quick quote glitch. But now that he made me look at my list again, I notice I have on too many. I'll go and edit it.thetombradyhate
Actually, he did have 8.
DP0, you have Unitas listed twice. That's why it looked like 9.
[QUOTE="thetombradyhate"][QUOTE="detroitpistons0"]I think TBH got struck by that on GS quick quote glitch. But now that he made me look at my list again, I notice I have on too many. I'll go and edit it.wallymartin
Actually, he did have 8.
DP0, you have Unitas listed twice. That's why it looked like 9.
Oh I just counted the names, didn't read them
Here is my list. These are in no particular order
I'm not going to be here later, so any Officers on after 7(central), just go ahead and start the collaboration process. I'll give my thoughts tomorrow if a consensus hasn't been reached by then.
Guess I'll start then.
I pick thetombradyhater's list. He included the 5 people that IMO are musts, and the other 3 are just as deserving.
I feel like my list is the best too... but then again since I made it of course thats probably how I'm going to feel. We should have some officers who didn't make a lists opinion's.thetombradyhate
You can't pick your own list, anyway.
That's why I picked yours instead of my own. :P
[QUOTE="thetombradyhate"]I feel like my list is the best too... but then again since I made it of course thats probably how I'm going to feel. We should have some officers who didn't make a lists opinion's.wallymartin
You can't pick your own list, anyway.
That's why I picked yours instead of my own. :P
I will also nominate tbh's list. It is a good list that I can pretty much agree with.HumanTorch101
Alright, one more vote will seal it early.
Nevermind, we have our 3rd vote, and thus our candidates.
Moving on, here's the next position:
Defensive Tackle, 8-10 players
Note: we are considering Reggie White to be a DE only.
Here's mine:
Merlin Olsen
Randy White
Alan Page
Bob Lilly
Dan Hampton
Buck Buchanan
Mean Joe Greene
Bill Willis, because we aren't including his Middle Guard position, and DT is the closest thing to it.
Mean Joe Greene
Henry Jordan
Alan Page
Dan Hampton
Ernie Stautner
Merlin Olsen
Bob Lilly
Leo Nomellini
Randy White
Buck Buchanan
Joe Greene
Alan Page
Randy White
Earnie Stoutner
Artr Donovan
Bob Lilly
Merlin Olsen
Dan Hampton (IF he coutns)
Dan Hampton (IF he coutns)
detroitpistons0
He counts. Hampton made the 80's All-Decade Team as a DT and nobody mentioned him in the DE Discussion. So for the purposes of creating this team, he will be a DT only.
Had I been back on in time, I would have voted for sfgiantsfan.
Anyway, that 2 for my list and the 24 hour limit is up, so we have our DT candidates.
Next up: Center, 8 players(no more, no less)
Had I been back on in time, I would have voted for sfgiantsfan.
Anyway, that 2 for my list and the 24 hour limit is up, so we have our DT candidates.
Next up: Center, 8 players(no more, no less)
wallymartin
Why thank you wally:)
Anyways-
Mike Webster
Frank Gatski
Jim Langer
Jim Ringo
Jim Otto
Dwight Stephenson
Clyde Turner
Mel Hein
Some guys played other line positions than center, so who counts for what?
[QUOTE="wallymartin"]Had I been back on in time, I would have voted for sfgiantsfan.
Anyway, that 2 for my list and the 24 hour limit is up, so we have our DT candidates.
Next up: Center, 8 players(no more, no less)
sfgiantsfan8291
Why thank you wally:)
Anyways-
Mike Webster
Frank Gatski
Jim Langer
Jim Ringo
Jim Otto
Dwight Stephenson
Clyde Turner
Mel Hein
Some guys played other line positions than center, so who counts for what?
According to profootballhof.com, all 8 of those guys' primary contributions came as Centers. They're are eligible for this.
I can't do this at the lesser known positions. I couldn't name 8 retired centers.thetombradyhate
You've got time to do research on it. And even if you can't fill out an 8-man list, a 5-man attempt will still get you a point.
^Chuck was one i was referring to earlier, he was more known as a LB, but he also played Center. I believe the award for the best college LB is the Bednarik.sfgiantsfan8291
Yeah, the kicker award in colelge is Groza, who was not only a PK, but an OT :|
^Chuck was one i was referring to earlier, he was more known as a LB, but he also played Center. I believe the award for the best college LB is the Bednarik.sfgiantsfan8291
One of the rules on the first post says that if a player was well-known for playing 2 positions on different sides of the ball (such as C-LB, K-G, etc) he is eligible for both positions.
And Bednarik made the 50's All-Decade Team as a Center.
[QUOTE="sfgiantsfan8291"]^Chuck was one i was referring to earlier, he was more known as a LB, but he also played Center. I believe the award for the best college LB is the Bednarik.wallymartin
One of the rules on the first post says that if a player was well-known for playing 2 positions on different sides of the ball (such as C-LB, K-G, etc) he is eligible for both positions.
And Bednarik made the 50's All-Decade Team as a Center.
Ok, thx for the clarification.
I know the 24-hour limit is passed, but I'm going to submit mine anyway. Then we'll start the picking.
Jim Otto
Chuck Bednarik
Mike Webster
Frank Gatski
Mel Hein
Bulldog Turner
Jim Ringo
Dwight Stephenson
With that out of the way, my pick goes to sfgiantsfan. I was leaning towards dp0, but then I realized he was missing both Jim Otto and Dwight Stephenson, while sfgiantsfan is only missing Bednarik.
Well, looks like we have a winner now.
Next position: Cornerback, 8-10 players
And before you ask: Ronnie Lott will be considered a Safety, Rod Woodson will be considered a CB.
Herb Adderly
Mel Blount
Jimmy Johnson
Mike Haynes
Lem Barney
Dick "Night Train" Lane
Mel Renfro
Willie Brown
Deion Sanders
Rod Woodson
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment