NFL Union's All-Time Team- Watch for the Part 2 Thread soon.

Hey I gotta question. Is it an NFLUPS point to submit a list, or win one?detroitpistons0

Submitting one gets you a point, getting your list picked gets 3 points.

To be honest, I had to flip a coin between the 2 I liked the most. My pick goes to detroitpistons0.

Also, I keep forgetting to change the thread title. I'm bound to forget again, so a reminder from you guys would be appreciated.

Oh and sfgiantsfan, I believe you have my list. :P

To be honest, I had to flip a coin between the 2 I liked the most. My pick goes to detroitpistons0.

Also, I keep forgetting to change the thread title. I'm bound to forget again, so a reminder from you guys would be appreciated.

Oh and sfgiantsfan, I believe you have my list. :P

wallymartin

Sorry, i honestly didnt look at anybody elses, i just clicked on the topic, hit new message and started typing. Do youwant me to edit it?

[QUOTE="wallymartin"]

To be honest, I had to flip a coin between the 2 I liked the most. My pick goes to detroitpistons0.

Also, I keep forgetting to change the thread title. I'm bound to forget again, so a reminder from you guys would be appreciated.

Oh and sfgiantsfan, I believe you have my list. :P

sfgiantsfan8291

Sorry, i honestly didnt look at anybody elses, i just clicked on the topic, hit new message and started typing. Do youwant me to edit it?

No, it's fine. You can have a point anyway, just be more careful in the future.

[QUOTE="sfgiantsfan8291"][QUOTE="wallymartin"]

To be honest, I had to flip a coin between the 2 I liked the most. My pick goes to detroitpistons0.

Also, I keep forgetting to change the thread title. I'm bound to forget again, so a reminder from you guys would be appreciated.

Oh and sfgiantsfan, I believe you have my list. :P

wallymartin

Sorry, i honestly didnt look at anybody elses, i just clicked on the topic, hit new message and started typing. Do youwant me to edit it?

No, it's fine. You can have a point anyway, just be more careful in the future.

All right wont happen again, ill check other peoples lists next time, or ill just be the first one to post a list:P

Look's like we'll be using detroitpistons0's list.

Next position: Punters and Kickers, two seperate lists, 4-6 each

One Note: I'm not sure if Morton Andersen is officially retired, but you may use him.

I first would like to apologize for not being active, I just have way to many things going on.

I dont really know many retired kickers or punters so... I just feel like posting some of my favorite players, even though I know those positions are captured.

Quarterback: Steve Young

Halfback: Walter Payton

Wide Reciever: JERRY RICE BAY BAY!

Linebacker: Ray Nitchske was a great Tackler.

And I am so with you Wally on Brett. ;)

Well, I've compiled a couple lists. It took quite a bit of research though.

K
Morten Andersen
Gary Anderson
Jan Stenerud
Lou Groza
Tom Dempsey
Mike Vanderjagt(since he's technically inactive and I couldn't find anybody else worthy of the 6th spot)

P
Sean landeta
Darren Bennett
Ray Guy
Reggie Roby
Don Chandler

Yeah, Punters and kickers are a very hard category, so I'm not surprised that I'm the only one to submit lists. It took me quite a while to find the guys I put down, and beyond that, there was almost literally nobody else.

I think we should just go ahead and move onto the next position:

Wide Receivers, 10 players(no more, no less)

This should be easy for you guys.

WR:

JERRY RICE

Tim Brown

Art Monk

Steve Largent

Isaac Bruce (I'm not sure: Is he still playing? If so, Raymond Berry)

Lance Alworth

Lynn Swan

Cris Carter

Don Hutson

Charley Taylor

Fred Biletnikoff

Jerry Rice

Michael Irvin

Charlie Joiner

Lynn Swann

John Stallworth

Steve Largent

Lance Alworth

Cris Carter

Paul Warfield

Jerry Rice

Chris Carter

Antonio Freeman

Michael Irvin

Steve Largent

Lynn Swann

Tim Brown

Andre Reed (one of my all-time fav's)

James Lofton

Art Monk

Here is my list:

• Jerry Rice
• Tim Brown
• Chris Carter
• Dwight Clark
• Lynn Swann
• Art Monk
• James Lofton
• Andre Reed
• Antonio Freeman

• Jimmy Smith:oops:
• Jerry Rice
• Lance Alworth
• Raymond Berry
• Don Hutson
• Fred Biletnikoff
• Micheal Irvin
• James Lofton
• Lynn Swann
• Art Monk

Alright, time's up. I'm bored, so I'm going to run through several points, as all of these lists have something to be said for them.

- While I do like Antonio Freeman as a receiver, I really don't think he belongs on a list of the Ten Greatest WRs. That leaves HT and Ngamer out in the cold.
- Actually, I kind of like seeing Jimmy Smith's name mentioned here. Correct me if I'm wrong, but doesn't he have better career numbers than any WR currently in the HoF? Unfortunately, the lack of both Tim Brown and Cris Carter, not to mention Steve Largent, makes it a bit more difficult topick CommanderShiro's list.
- sfgiantsfan, you're missing Brown, Raymond Berry, and Don Hutson. That puts you in the same boat as CommanderShiro. Good lists, just missing people that want to see on there.
- Yes, Isaac Bruce is still playing. I would have liked to see Michael Irvin, but it's still a very solid list.

Something makes me want to pick CommanderShiro's list. I think it's the fact that he had the gusto to include Jimmy Smith. But I can't do it. He also left off essentials(Carter is a must).

My pick goes to detroitpistons0.

I had Irvin before, but I decided he was a little overrated.detroitpistons0

You better delete that before Espurs sees it:wink:

Oops, guess I was a little late. Sorry.

Jerry Rice

Lance Alworth

James Lofton

Cris Carter

Michael Irvin

Steve Largent

Art Monk

Lynn Swann

Alright, detroitpistons0 gets the win.

Next position: Safety, 8-10 players

Ronnie Lott

Ken Houston

Larry Wilson

Willie Wood

Yale Larry

Paul Krause

Emlen Tunnell

Darren Woodson

Steve Atwater

Ronnie Lott

Paul Krause

Ken Houston

Willie Wood

Jack Christiansen

Larry Wilson

Emlen Tunnell

Yale Lary

Mike Wagner

Jack Tatum

I tried to make my own list last night, but it wouldn't let me post it. Something about a censored word, but I couldn't figure out which one.

So we're left with 2 choices. Either list is fine, but I lean towards Bobbles. Not because of Woodson though. I wouldn't have included him, but I also wouldn't include Wagner or Tatum.

Alright, Bobbles takes the position.

Next up: Tight End, 8 players

Mike Ditka

Jackie Smith

Kellen Winslow

Ozzie Newsome

Dave Casper

Shannon Sharpe

John Mackey

Charlie Sanders

^I cant really come up with anyone else deserving besides the guys on that list.sfgiantsfan8291

Yeah, those were the only ones I could find that were worthy...

Mike Ditka

Kellen Winslow

Don Hutson

John Mackey

Dave Casper

Shannon Sharpe

Jackie Smith

Ozzie Newsome

Bah, I guess nobody's paying attention anymore. I'll let Ngamer have it just to move things along.

We need to go with something that will attract interest again, so...

Head Coaches, 8 of them.

Tom Landry

Marv Levy

George Allen

Don Shula

Vince Lombardi

Chuck Noll

George Halas

Bill Parcells

Vince Lombardi

Marv Levy

Don Shula

Chuck Noll

John Madden

Paul Brown

Bill Walsh

George Halas

• Bill Walsh
• Dick Vermeil
• Vince Lombardi
• Hank Stram
• George Halas
• Chuck Noll
• Tom Landry
• Don Shula

• John Madden
• Vince Lombardi
• Bill Parcells
• George Allen
• George Halas
• Don Shula
• Weeb Ewank
• Ray Flaherty

All of these lists are good. It's a tough choice, but I think I'm going to lean towards thetombradyhater.

Oh, and thank you for changing the title. I got distracted last night and forgot about it.